Make it melee only. I'm sure I don't have to remind you WHY you nerfed it in the first place. And when I say melee only, I meant this buff, not the item itself. Make it stack to 30% for melee champs only. Stop dancing in circles because you KNOW that some time VERY soon, we're going to run into the SAME problem we had before.
Rester4 votesHaving nightmares of Lucian bot again. Pls no.
(Pls no as in I dont wanna experience that horrror bot again)
Mizaya2 votesThere's a buff that could possibly make a couple of ranged champs stronger? Oh heavens no!
Trust me, Lucian, sitting at his measly 47% winrate, isn't going to instantly start popping off because he shreds 6% more armor or whatever. MF, yeah, she's already so much stronger than almost every other ADC that it really won't matter anymore until rito drops the nerf hammer.
Just be happy with your buff lol, you'll feel good with that and new grasp. Riot reworked my main 4 years ago into a boring ass champ, I don't make a complaint thread every patch he doesn't (and won't ever be) reverted.
Brain Errör 4041 votesYou don't understand. The problem is, if it gets out of hand for ranged again, then we go back to the same "it has to be nerfed" scenario.
Bronze 5 Teeto1 votesJust a heads up. Riot has never taken an idea from the boards into their game in their entire existence. :)
Death by Glamour1 votesConsidering kindred was designed by a boards poster i would have to disagrew with you
Bronze 5 Teeto1 votes[{quoted}](name=Pink Leg Warmers,realm=EUW,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=ENBZdp1Q,comment-id=00000000,timestamp=2017-12-06T10:49:17.789+0000)
Considering kindred was designed by a boards poster i would have to disagrew with you
thats cool. haha guess im wronggg xD
hoyohai1 votesWell, that's depressing...
Death by Glamour1 votesIm goimg to play devils advocate and say why?
Most of its melee users are doing great currently
Why not just buff renekton and darius who are the ones tgat need the help right now and nerf maokai.
Broadstroke buffs like this will just cause more pain to the bruiser class when it is intended to hit the tanks
Brain Errör 4041 votesOutside of fringe cases like Olaf, Pantheon, Garen, Illaoi and Wukong, the others really aren't doing so hot. Granted, there aren't even THAT many melee users of BC when you look at it in such a small vacuum, which is exactly why they should make it melee only so ranged champions don't abuse what is suppose to be intended for bruisers.
Death by Glamour1 votespanth
wu
j4
you didnt have to wait long
Brain Errör 4041 votesNah, I re-edited it. And J4 goes assassin right now, not bruiser build. So does wu, for the most part.
Death by Glamour1 votesand they still build black cleaver
who are the others that dont do well?
Brain Errör 4041 votes
Granted, Camille would like triforce over BC, though.
Death by Glamour1 votesand trynd wouldnt buy it...
fiora is the odd one, she should be doing great and i would never have thought i would say this but she needs a wee bit of early game love
Colton1471 votesWhat about the Urgod?
He is going to end up non-existent if Black Cleaver is melee only.
Brain Errör 4041 votesHe's a special case. I think they should honestly just code urgot to be a melee champ. His range is pretty freaking low to be a ranged champ as well. If Urgot is in range to do damage to a melee champ, he's in range for retaliation. I wouldn't mind Urgot abusing melee items.