Feast or famine
Top picture: my score yesterday in normal games, where i have a very low elo (silvers/bronzers).
Bottom picture, my latest ranked games, Plat 2 ELO @ EUW. Make what you think of that.
Meanwhile, Aatrox's winrate hits the lowest winrate ever. 46% both TOP and Jungle (champion.gg)
Here is an idea of a healthy buff / with a compensation nerf :
Buff his scaling stats / AD ratios => make him more viable in High Elo. You know? Like exactly what you did to Xin Zhao in the next patch. Nerf his ability to heal based on bonus AD when <50% HP => make him less oppressive in lower ELO stomps
IS IT SO HARD TO AT LEAST _TRY _DOING SOMETHING LIKE THAT ?