Skip to content

Why are Jhin's W and R coded as single targeted when they damage multiple enemies?

AP Ezreal is OP··14 votes·3,733 views

There is no reason why they should be coded as single targeted when they hit multiple enemies (including minions)

At least, code them like Karthus' Q, so they're single targeted only if they strike one enemy champion (and not minions).

This just makes Deathfire Touch ridiculous on Jhin due to not only gaining huge amounts of AD, but also the fact that he has so many ways to fully proc the 6 seconds burn.

That is my only concern about him.

39 Comments

SaltyKracka12 votes

They...don't hit multiple champions.

AP Ezreal is OP2 votes

Multiple ENEMIES.

this includes enemy minions.

If Jhin's W, for example, hits a champion AND minions, it shouldn't be coded as a single target spell.

However, if Jhin's W only hits a champion, noe, it should be coded as a single target spell, just like how Karthus' Q is coded.

SaltyKracka2 votes

...Actually you know what?

I don't necessarily think you're right, but it would definitely be a good change to bring his power back into line.

AP Ezreal is OP2 votes

Minions hit by Jhin's W receive 65% of the damage, which proves that the spell can hit multiple targets.

However, it stops at the first champion hit.

My point is, if the spell only hit a champion, it should be treated as it is in live, but if it also hit minions in its way, it should be treated as an area of effect anility, thus reducing the effectiveness of things like Deathfire Touch.

EddardStark849 votes

What? He's not out of line in the first place..

SaltyKracka1 votes

His winrate's only been going up.

EddardStark845 votes

His win rate went DOWN from last patch (according to champion.gg and it's not as high as Ashe and Jinx with similar play rates). What did happen was other adc's who cannot abuse the Youmuus build got worse. This meta is all about snowballing and winning lane early which is what the Youmuus build exacerbates. All that needs to happen is further nerfs to first item rushing Youmuus. "Problem" solved.

MoarCowbell981 votes

{quoted}

They...don't hit multiple champions.

basically this. the abilities are not AOE on champions. so deathfire touch won't be abused in the sense of jhin getting DFT on all 5 champions like a champ like xerath, ziggs, or lux can. (potentially here, obviously that doesn't happen all the time)

instead, jhin gets really really good single target ability damage combined with DFT. its a unique niche, but its cool to be honest.

Jhin is actually balanced ish imo. his lane phase is pretty oppressive and his late game is good, but his immobility and severe lack of self peel make him shit on outside of lane phase quite often.

D3m37r112 votes

Those abilities can hit multiple minions but only a single champion. So vs minions it counts as aoe.

manbearswine1 votes

{quoted}

Those abilities can hit multiple minions but only a single champion. So vs minions it counts as aoe.

Well when karthus hits a single champion and some creeps it still counts as aoe, so op has a point.

D3m37r11 votes

Honestly that would be a nice buff for karthus.

manbearswine1 votes

{quoted}

Honestly that would be a nice buff for karthus.

Well you can kinda implement this to all champions with aoe abilities when they hit a single champion

I kinda have to agree with the op though, this goes against clarity/consistency, I don't mind jhin getting compensation buffs with this, but currently the way deathfire touch works with his abilities is counter-intuitive, and that's bad.

Then again so do a lot of abilities with rylais(and maybe dft, I'm not sure), so I don't really know, also rylai's should probably be nerfed, but I'm really getting off topic here.

Omnem Occido7 votes

When factoring it in, his W and R do only hit one CHAMPION, which is the only way you can proc DFT (doesn't work on minions).

AP Ezreal is OP1 votes

which is bullshit, because they also hit minions.

All I ask is that the spells are treated like Karthus' Q and are coded as simgle targetted only if they do hit only one enemy.

Atanchan8 votes

The difference between Karthus Q and these two abilities, however, is that Karthus Q can hit multiple champions, as it's as vanilla AoE as it gets. Jihn's stuff never can. What would probably make more sense is to make his abilities count as AoE when proccing stuff on minions, while stay single-targeted when proccing stuff on champions.

Though, honestly, this isn't really necessary at all, since these rules for ability tags aren't really consistent anyway, they just tend to make sense on the ability in a vacuum - see how "damage over time" effects are said to proc spell effects at far less effectiveness but that's actually entirely wrong and it's debuff-based damage ( which is basically always DoT, but not all DoTs are debuff-based; check out all that confusion from Morgana pool or Swain Q with Thunderlord's ) and the fact that some pets proc spell effects while others don't, leading to the fact that Rylai's "pet-based" slow is actually entirely arbitrary.

Modl Ryden l3 votes

[{quoted}](name=AP Ezreal is OP,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=AAj9sP5a,comment-id=00010000,timestamp=2016-07-08T05:13:19.405+0000)

which is bullshit, because they also hit minions.

All I ask is that the spells are treated like Karthus' Q and are coded as simgle targetted only if they do hit only one enemy.

Karthus' Q just has a condition, when met, deals extra damage.

Jhin's W and R are linear passthrough skill shots that stop at the first enemy champion hit.

As with all Keystone masteries their effects are ubiquitous with champions.

blfUvZ8Ybu4 votes

Jhin's kit is overloaded.

AP Ezreal is OP2 votes

The sky is blue

Bârd3 votes

Because each shot can only hit one champion.

IGII23 votes

They count as AoE spell for the purposes of spell vamp and item 3116 when hitting minions, they count as single target spells vs champions because they stop on the first enemy champion hit. Actually, more spells are coded like this, some spells count as single target if they manage to hit only one target (although they are still able to hit multiple).

It's there to prevent enormous spell vamp by hitting dozens of minions with your ult / W (in case you build item 3812 / item 3146 ) while still allowing things like Deathfire touch appealing to Jhin. If Jhin ever becomes meta champion and Riot needs to nerf him, this is one of the possible ways to siphon some of his "hidden" (as the Riot likes to call it) power.

Aniela3 votes

Because those abilities only hit one champion (per shot on ult), and DFT only procs on champions. The change you're calling for doesn't really make sense considering the effect has no real effect on minions, not to mention it wouldn't overall change much outside of laning phase I guess? Come teamfights those abilities won't be hitting much if any minions.

Michael7021 votes

I faced a Jhin top. He kept stacking his traps. Any time I tried to engage, he would just run to his traps.

EddardStark844 votes

If you lost to a jhin top laner... Uh. I. I don't even..

AP Ezreal is OP1 votes

T A N K J H I N

Quepha1 votes

Probably a combination of it looking like the abilities could really go either way in their definition of being single target or AoE and EVERY OTHER KEYSTONE FEELS LIKE CRAP ON JHIN (except stormraider's)

blfUvZ8Ybu1 votes

Salty adc mains everywhere.

MunchCrunchLunch1 votes

so that they can say that "Deathfire touch" does damage.

seriously. his ult. is 4 shots. each of them. hit multiple minions. sure 1 enemy. but 1 ult hits. 4 people. lucian ultimate. can never. hit 2 champions at once. at the same time. its coded as AOE.

THE ONLY REASON JHIN ULT AND W CODED AS SINGLE TARGET IS TO PRETEND THAT DFT ISN'T TRASH

when you have a single case where something standard goes abnormal. its done for an abnormal reason and thats reason is what i provided. riot doesn't want to show that a mastery keystone i useless. there are a cpl champions outside jhin that use death fire. however. the mastery itself does no signiificant damage. I mean with a 1k ap veigar ult . I barely. barely kill a target because of dft when they have like. no healthbar visible left. the mastery does so little damage and making it over time is too weak with all the sustain options we get in the game nowdays.

graves ult. is coded as aoe. despite the first part of the explosion. hitting one champion. and the latter part being aoe.

go ahead build full ad. i mean 5 . 75 ad items varus. and use dft and Q someone. the damage you will see. is UNNOTICEABLE. it takes 600+ ad (of jhin). and cheated abilities ti maximize its damage. (single target) for death fire touch to do any damage. no champion gets that much ad and no ad ranged champ thas that much ranged single target damage

with 1k ap. my veigar ult is doing an extra. 256 magic damage over time. single target. maximum damage possible.

with 1k ap if i proc thunderlords it will do 280 damage.

dft is pure trash

LSmaster162 votes

Pretty sure Lucian ult is coded as aoe to stop it from abusing manamune. Otherwise each bullet would process manamune's on hit.

CaptnJakSparrow1 votes

This is why nobody listens to Gameplay and Bronze.

Out of the 1,000s of post made each day. None of them ever have anything worthwhile to say regarding balance.

It is a single target spell. None of his spells except Q and E damage multiple champions. Thus, they are all single target.

frankly this thread should just be deleted.

WaterTribe4 votes

What an ass. Is it so hard to just tell him why without having to be a complete asshole? Kindness goes a long way, he is bronze so he obviously still has a lot of learning to do.

Toxic community just wow.

CaptnJakSparrow1 votes

{quoted}

What an ass. Is it so hard to just tell him why without having to be a complete asshole? Kindness goes a long way, he is bronze so he obviously still has a lot of learning to do.

Toxic community just wow.

Nah.

I get shit talked and downvoted by the bronze lords on a regular basis whenever I make a thread about Kindred.

As far as I'm concerned nothing would be lost if 90% of the G&B posters suddenly got removed from the forums.

I'm sure there'll be a QQ thread about X champ here pre' soon.

AP Ezreal is OP1 votes

G&B might have its flaws, but do you think you're better, going around and being an asshole because some people disagree with you?

Plus, Kindred aren't even that strong right now, why would you complain about them? They got nerfed multiple times.

CaptnJakSparrow1 votes

[{quoted}](name=AP Ezreal is OP,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=AAj9sP5a,comment-id=000c000000000000,timestamp=2016-07-08T14:22:28.562+0000)

G&B might have its flaws, but do you think you're better, going around and being an asshole because some people disagree with you?

Plus, Kindred aren't even that strong right now, why would you complain about them? They got nerfed multiple times.

.... I actually am one of the like 20 people that said they're getting a bit too nerfed. And I was right.

AP Ezreal is OP1 votes

If they got overnerfed, then good

ranged junglers are annoying, especially when they come to bully you in your own jungle ;c

Tho right now, they're not that strong as a duelist if you decide to invade the,, unless you're someone like Warwick who won't even get to them.

CaptnJakSparrow1 votes

[{quoted}](name=AP Ezreal is OP,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=AAj9sP5a,comment-id=000c00000000000000000000,timestamp=2016-07-08T14:45:31.847+0000)

If they got overnerfed, then good

ranged junglers are annoying, especially when they come to bully you in your own jungle ;c

Tho right now, they're not that strong as a duelist if you decide to invade the,, unless you're someone like Warwick who won't even get to them.

I don't play favoritism.

But in all honesty, any jungler can bully just about anyone in the jungle.And I'm actually getting really tired of Riot's power rotations instead of actual balance.

Kindred sucks now. So, now it's basically right back to.

Graves KogMaw While all the random tanks that do assassin level damage with no items run around shitting on everyone going strong for 7 months now.

AP Ezreal is OP1 votes

I am Platinium I, so please, make a little research before you call anyone Bronze.

Plus, my point was just that since it actually hit multiple enemy units, the spells should be considered area of effect. Right now, they are considered single targetted when they actually hit a champion (because it only hits one champion, I knew that)

My point is, if the two spells actually hit multiple enemy units, regardless if it's only one champion among tons of minions, they should be considered like area of effects abilities, but if they only hit one enemy champion or one enemy minion, then, they should act like single targetted spells.

A bit like how Karthus' Q works.

Keep ur Jhin up1 votes

I'm confused. Whats wrong with his W and ult passing through minions?

Astôlfo1 votes

Because it is single target? This thread is pointless.

Also people crying about Jhin is fucking hilarious.

More from Gameplay

More by AP Ezreal is OP