What if AA damage were fixed for each Champion ?

heterosexual DIE·2/1/2017, 2:52:28 PM·7 votes·1,780 views

Hello there !

So I had this idea few hours ago, and I thought it would be nice to share it here and let you guys see if it could be a good change to this game or not. I'm gonna try to explain it as clear as possible with my poor English, and French accent. I think it's my first time posting in the Gameplay section, so please be kind with me !

Alright, so basically, my idea is pretty simple, I guess :

##What if each Champion of the game had their own AA damage, scaling with base damage and not with building AD or AP ?

What I mean by that is, except of scaling with Champion's Stats ( mostly AD ), why don't they scale with base stats, like every spell of every champion ? By that, problems of right-clicking champs would be solved, and it will force them to actually use their brain and spells and not only walk into someone and right click to death.

Or it could also help to actually fix the problem with underpowered junglers ( mostly AP ) AND overpowered junglers ( here AD ). It would procure more help to clean for AP junglers and will prevent AD junglers to clean too quick.


I am aware that this is some big change that can take a lot of time to establish because it would bring change obviously on AA, but also on Spells for some champions, but I really think that this is the only way to re-balanced properly the game.

Thanks for reading, if someone has any idea to complete this thread, you are welcome ! [slayer-jinx-catface] And if someone can help me explain my idea with a real English, you are welcome too !

36 Comments

Big Lincoln2/1/2017, 3:07:09 PM5 votes

That'd be terrible; right clicking isn't an inherently bad thing, and there are champions whose kits focus entirely around working with their basic attacks

It would just make things horribly confusing when it doesn't need to be, and the main appeal of League is that you have a lot of build options

Deep Terror Nami2/1/2017, 2:56:23 PM5 votes

I'm gonna try to explain it as clear as possible with my poor English, and French accent.

Tbh I couldn't tell you had an accent at all.

Into The Aether2/1/2017, 3:05:09 PM4 votes

I don't think the existence of autoattack focused champions is really considered a negative.

In most cases, they do still have to actually press QWER.

Typing little jibberish 4 letter words isn't limited to mages.

This would also make Marksmen in general weird to build.

Tryndamere'd probably be a tank or something.

doublelift fg2/1/2017, 5:15:34 PM1 votes

first i hate your name

second i didn't understand your idea, can someone explains pls?

Quepha2/1/2017, 5:38:29 PM1 votes

adc is considered the most mechanically intense role in the game but you're talking as if it's the simplest.

Kaioko2/1/2017, 5:42:42 PM1 votes

What's the point of getting any gold then? If the only damage you get on your abilities and autos is just from your base damage then there's no point in getting damage items. In other words, everyone should just build tanky?

Grokmir2/1/2017, 6:45:09 PM1 votes

So most adc's just become either shitty ranged bruisers or stupidly op ranged bruisers. Nice.

Ariel the Cruel2/1/2017, 7:02:01 PM1 votes

RiP Dawngate.

Hyperiön2/1/2017, 7:10:35 PM1 votes

Then whats the point of farming gold is your damage is all predetermined.

NastyMcOutplay2/1/2017, 8:38:35 PM1 votes

this is the worst thing i have ever seen

Legacy Hydralpha2/1/2017, 8:50:31 PM1 votes

This is a terrible idea. Nothing else to say about it. Most AD would be useless on champions who are primarily based on auto attacks like Vayne, Udyr, and Ashe.

Papa Slothy2/2/2017, 4:09:10 AM1 votes

this is a pretty bad idea, almost every adc and fighter would become dogshit. Auto attacking isn't inherently broken and all this would do is mess up the meta to some crazy unfun place

Dirty Bastard2/1/2017, 3:44:20 PM1 votes

Noodle fight!

Awesomedude88882/1/2017, 5:13:34 PM1 votes

How would someone like Jhin be played then? His passive revolves him dealing more damage on his AAs because he cannot get more AS.