It's ideal for people with two roles, but what about those with only one role? Or, more likely, one role they are really good with and then one mediocre role? It's a 50% shot at getting the role you want. Before, you had a way better chance, regardless of you position. (Unless, of course, you were last. Then you were screwed. But you had a 1/5 chance of being last, so still pretty good odds.) The reason I say that you had a better chance getting what you wanted is this: before, if you were first, you always got your role. If you were second, you had an 80% chance of getting your role. And so on. The odds were just better. Now, you get 50%. No matter what. That, coupled with the extremely long wait time makes this new select somewhat problematic.