Update on Yesterday's Capsule Pricing Error

RiotRiot KenAdamsNSA·1/12/2019, 1:36:57 AM·1 votes·153,407 views

Hi folks,

Yesterday an error in League's in-game store briefly made some expensive content available for Blue Essence. We want to explain a little more about what happened and how we'll prevent similar errors in the future.

What happened?

At 10AM PT on January 10th, the new Blood Moon capsules and Prestige Points went on sale. Because of a configuration error that resulted in PBE content making it to Live, you could purchase individual Prestige Points as well as individual Blood Moon capsules for just 1 BE apiece.

The error was live on the store for 14 minutes. During that time, a few thousand players across all regions were able to take advantage of the situation and buy both Blood Moon capsules and Prestige Points using BE. In many regions, fewer than 100 players were able to take advantage of the error.

Yesterday I announced on Twitter that we'll be reverting and refunding all BE-purchased Prestige Points along with the Aatrox Prestige skin.

**But what about the capsules? **

For reasons I'll explain here, we won't be able to revert or remove the free Blood Moon capsules that players were able to purchase using BE. Lots of you have pointed out that this feels unfair, so we want to explain why we decided to do this.

It's not too complicated of a process for us to manually remove most items from your inventory if we need to. If it's a single skin or a champion, we have tools to remove those quickly and effectively.

However, it gets more complicated when we talk about capsules and other loot items, because it's a lot harder to track what players have done with the capsules after they open them. You can disenchant skin shards into orange essence, or reroll them using other skin shards you already owned (including ones you earned legitimately). Instead of reverting a single item, we'd have to revert potentially thousands of transactions made in the loot system. This would take us months to undo, as it’s a very manual and delicate process to ensure we don’t wipe out legitimate transactions accidentally. Additionally, it could revert perfectly normal actions, like LP gains, Mastery tokens, and more.

Since we don't keep easily reversible backups of an earlier version of your account's state, properly reverting the capsules purchased using BE yesterday would be nearly impossible and come at the expense of other features we’re working on for players. For this reason, we're choosing to only take away the Prestige Points and Blood Moon Aatrox Prestige Editions that were obtained with BE.

We're already taking steps to prevent this sort of mistake from ever happening again.

Our first action will be to make internal test prices reflect Live prices for store content. This way, if content that shouldn’t be on Live accidentally makes it way out, it won’t be exploitable or priced incorrectly.

In the long term, we're going to continue to explore the work needed to address issues like this in the future. In the off chance this happens again, we'll be able to respond quickly and appropriately.

Thank you so much for your patience.

693 Comments

Marksmen Player1/12/2019, 1:44:08 AM366 votes

Just cause you explained it doesn’t make it feel any less unfair. Literally the same day I spent around $75 on capsules trying to get content and these people just get it for free and get to keep it after they effectively break terms of service abusing an error. I understand that you may not be able to revert this but it still feels awful to us players who spend what little spare money they have (and worked their ass of for) on capsules only to have others get it by chance for free.

Zebs1/12/2019, 1:49:07 AM205 votes

It looks like Riot hates the players who actually spend REAL money on the game. What a joke.

Skunkie1/12/2019, 1:56:14 AM194 votes

So basically you're saying you don't want to manually do anything to fix it because it would take a lot of resources and time to be accurate, and you wont do anything across the board because it could affect things like peoples LP gains? In pre-season mind you? This is kind of a load of bullshit and I'm still refusing to spend more money on riot until they do something satisfactory about this.

Old Man Riven1/12/2019, 1:40:45 AM171 votes

Then you need to do something to make this right by those of us who didn’t bullshit and take a bunch of free stuff. I bought capsules with RP and it’s kind of bullshit that people got 10 times as many or more than I did and didn’t pay a cent.

I’ve been playing since 2010 and I have paid a pretty good penny to Riot in good faith - pretty much tells me to never spend money on this game again where you aren’t willing to even do anything for those of us who didn’t grossly abuse your error, but instead did things the way you are supposed to - pay for what you want.

Xaytah1/12/2019, 1:44:41 AM156 votes

cant say im not going to be a lot more hesitant on buying RP from now on.

Slamtastic1/12/2019, 1:57:47 AM117 votes

this is COMPLETE** bullsht.** people getting what those of us who have supported Riot for over 10 years, spent $1000 of dollars on... for free??? In the blink of an eye. You need to make this right Riot, or go the way of Blizzard. This is beyond disappointing, it's insulting and humiliating. Those of us who paid were fools.

Mettalknight1/12/2019, 1:54:00 AM117 votes

Can you give us some numbers on how many people abused this and how many capsules they purchased? As someone whos spent over 3000$ on league I am completely OK with players getting a couple of capsules for free. Bug happen. What I am not ok with is people getting 100+ capsules for free. Why do you guys not just go after the players that got a ton of free capsules and leave the players that only got a few alone?

Maddened King 1/12/2019, 2:00:36 AM91 votes

If you cannot revert then ban them until they can pay for the amount of stolen content. I don't see what the problem here is. You either do that or I don't pay.

Another solution if you don't want to do that is to provide us paying players a Reward tier system so that the amount of money I have spent on my account gives me more value over others. Exclusive skins, exclusive Icon borders, exclusive icons, etc and tier it all the way up to the person who has spent the most money on the game. Stop wasting resources on that dude who levels up.

Diar1/12/2019, 1:44:18 AM90 votes

just give players free stuff who didn't get anything

Settless1/12/2019, 2:10:45 AM80 votes

never spending money on this company again

WaxLS1/12/2019, 1:51:25 AM80 votes

This has put me off spending money on RP to be honest, will probably consider it only during sales (like Your Shop) if I REALLY like a skin from now on, for those fortunate enough to get these capsules I envy you, you probably won't have to spend another dime on this game again!

Naphal1/12/2019, 2:12:44 AM71 votes

ok so a couple of thousands accounts did it... decide on an acceptable limit (like 10 capsules or something) and who goes beyond that should get the account locked and sorted out, you dont need to make it perfect, just get rid of most of the gemstones, and clear out a certain amount of hextechshit.

OHNO IT MUST BE PERFECT!!! no it does not, you can just get rid of some stuff, and yes it means work, re-earning trust means work.

Think of it like this, you have been massively lazy with Quality control multiple events the last 12 months, and now you get to work that much harder for it, you mess up, you make it right.

John Wíck1/12/2019, 2:28:41 AM66 votes

This was an exploit. Typically, a game company makes a mistake, people exploit the unintended behavior, and they often get banned or at least lose what was obtained via the exploit. What amounts to inaction from Riot on this makes me sad.

When I saw moobeat tweet that the new skins were available yesterday, I logged in to obtain them and noticed the error. I assumed it was a bug, and I feared repercussions to my very valuable account with every skin. I feel that nearly everyone who abused it had enough common sense to also know it was unintended.

I didn't do it though. I could've bought tons of these capsules and received every new skin for free for years. Now, I'm hesitant about even playing or buying RP because this is the first time in multiplayer games that I've been the one heavily punished for refusing to abuse what was very obviously a bug. It hurts. To make it even worse, this one has real money value of potentially thousands of dollars.

Regardless, I guess this is just the reality of this situation since it sounds like this is the final word we'll get on it. I love you, Riot, but this resolution is extremely disappointing.

The Lane Police1/12/2019, 4:57:32 AM62 votes

####~~GUESS WHO'S NOT GETTING ANOTHER CENT FROM ME? ~~

OneManTerror1/12/2019, 2:05:57 AM62 votes

I can believe riot on this on as someone who spent alot of money on this game letting ppl who abused this keep the skins is unfair to anybody thats been supporting this game.

Dynikus1/12/2019, 2:24:14 AM57 votes

This is probably actually the worst possible decision you could have made to address what happened. I don't really need firecracker Vayne, I have enough skins for her already, as well as any other champ I play. I genuinely hope other people follow through with not purchasing RP as a result of this decision as well, becuase I definitely see no reason why I should.

The Lane Police1/12/2019, 4:06:31 AM55 votes

Good luck on seeing another cent from me ! After 8 years, and $ 2000 + , I'm officially done.

This is f#$king outrageous.

Xuroshi1/12/2019, 2:50:50 AM55 votes

Disgusting. On all levels.

Even if they choose not to revert the capsule incident, it's really sad that they're trying to justify it by talking "resources". We are all aware of where you stand with the money, Riot. With your resources and ToU ALONE, you could've dealt with this in an hour tops. Your support staff can literally check out anyone's ENTIRE Purchase History (which, from what I saw, still recorded BM capsules for 1BE), and you can surely revert them ever existing on that person's account.

But whatever, you lost a customer. I know you won't cry about it - trust me, I won't neither. Hopefully you fix the game at some point in future, because.. yeah, you just awarded a bunch of "lucky" individuals a lifetime supply of Orange Essence and hundreds of skins.

Cheers, I guess.

Noxian Pride1/12/2019, 3:22:39 AM55 votes

So let me get this straight

As someone who saw this, but didn't take advantage for fear of a ban, all I get is a sense of pride for 'doing the right thing'? Meanwhile others who saw it and were greedy were essentially rewarded for their greediness?

That's not good enough

Compensate those who didn't take advantage, or ban those who did. Or both. At least one of those things should happen. This is a blatant case of the system being abused and it's going to leave a sour taste in the mouth of anyone who wasn't there to be blinded by greed.

Namor1/12/2019, 2:40:04 AM54 votes

I won't spend any money on this game anymore.

Thank you for your patience.

BLIND AS FK1/12/2019, 2:24:17 AM51 votes

This is a slap in the face to anyone that has actually paid for content. What about the people that actually paid for Blood Moon capsules? After this news I doubt many people are.

my nama jeff1/12/2019, 3:21:24 AM51 votes

This is untrue, I asked for a support member to undo my purchase of the snowdown pass(because there was a typo in it's advertisement), and they easily undid the purchase, including all hextech loot transactions that I had made, within minutes

Ferrinova1/12/2019, 1:46:11 AM50 votes

who is downvoting everyone...?

Sindoray 1/12/2019, 3:42:19 AM50 votes

From a technical stand point , your response is outrageous from a company with resources such as riot games. A more accurate assessment would be calling it pathetic. I have a grad degree in economics and yes the cost of the labor/resources would most likely be higher than taking the loss of $400,000-$500,000 (based on the numbers you provided) that was the direct revenue lost from the capsules Stolen. It's also worth mentioning that you wouldn't consider all that lost revenue since the majority of those players weren't going to spend close to the amount of free stuff they took. Would be happy to do a more in depth statistical analysis of how much money was moved here if someone likes. My personal issue is regarding the decreased value of the items as a result of this. I'm a collector so every time there is an event I drop a decent amount of money on the capsules mainly because I enjoy it and find it fun to collect the rare skins. On the same note , despite the new AAtrox skin being underwhelming ; I didn't mind the $150 price tag. Skins are cosmetic and you don't have to buy them. However, after this and your utterly unacceptable response to the community ; I won't have any desire moving forward to spend any money whatsoever. From what I've seen on Reddit and other places, I know there are others in the same boat. In the end, Riot is losing out on all the future possible revenue due to their mishandling of this issue.

BeardedLuchador1/12/2019, 2:57:20 AM50 votes

Oh fuck off. There should be a few courtesy capsules provided to everyone with an active account who did not exploit the issue. I basically got punished for working for the money I use on my League of Legends account. That seems fair.

It's not enough that Blue Essence is a stupid concept to someone with all the characters unlocked, or that I have to wait until random times of the year for the heavens to part, revealing an "essence emporium", affording me the PRIVILEGE to purchase texture swaps for skins I've already bought as opposed to a year-round shop. Glad to know some jobless neckbeard bought thousands of the only thing that's still useful to my account across the entirety of League of Legends just because he didn't have to be at work before 9am.

Especially after I just spent $20 on boxes last week.

Luxanna Magica1/12/2019, 2:59:10 AM48 votes

if you don't give a shit enough to fix your mistake, maybe consider compensating those of us who actually pay for the content we receive with a couple of capsules and maybe we'll consider spending money on this game again

[sg-lux-2]

Tsukymaru1/12/2019, 3:47:11 AM45 votes

This is so unfair. Even if you must revert this, each capsule, one by one, you should do it.

It's called Corporate responsability.

I'm done with Riot. Ty for giving me another reason to leave this game.

bobby bling1/12/2019, 4:55:22 AM43 votes

Startup founder here. I see many commenters here and on reddit/twitter saying the players that did not have the opportunity to exploit the bug should not be mad because it does not affect them or something to this effect. What these commenters don't understand is that this does not matter in the slightest.

At the end of the day, all of league of legends is for the enjoyment of the whales, people who spend orders of magnitude more on the game than the regular player. If Riot makes a mistake that hurts the whales and they do not adequately make up for it, the whales will walk away.

The more you have spent on this game, the more this pricing error will hurt you, and the more likely it is that you'll either stop buying RP or stop playing the game entirely. Even worse, it shatters the fourth wall. People are beginning to realize that the true value of a skin is 0, and that they're paying sticker price only because Riot, the sole seller, is asking them to.

I personally have only spent $40 on the game in the past year, but I see many alleged whales on reddit who are demanding a revert and some courtesy capsules for their trouble. I personally predict Riot will take a noticeable hit to their revenue in the coming months and that whoever did the damage control for this debacle will no longer have the word Riot at the beginning of their username in the near future.

IISiroII1/12/2019, 2:02:31 AM42 votes

Small indie company Riot Games. They can't just do like every normal company when got things like this: giving compensation chests, orbs, whatever. Only vague explanations.

Ferrinova1/12/2019, 2:01:53 AM41 votes

Give us free capsules riot, you owe us. Consider it compensation for the last couple of patches we had to go through.

2Charmnot2Charm1/12/2019, 2:01:32 AM39 votes

Then give something to everyone that didn't abuse the exploit? Especially to those that throw money at you when they don't need to because this is a FREE TO PLAY GAME BTW.

Klette is taken1/12/2019, 2:22:56 AM38 votes

So you ban people for typing one word in chat, but you don't ban people who exploit an obvious bug in a way that costs you heavily per user and also inflates RP value for those that paid for their RP legitimately.

It's hard to say this with how Blizzard is currently performing, but in this case, their policy is clearly superior, as they ban exploiters, ranging from days to weeks to permanently, and I honestly think that that would be the least you can do.

Badmagick1/12/2019, 4:06:40 AM35 votes

As a player that has spent thousands of dollars on League of legends products over the years (be it on in game items, or from the merch store,) I'm done supporting Riot because of their odd choice of action, and insane inaction. The fact the reverted the Aatrox skins but not the capsules is ridiculous. I get that there are technical limitations, but that doesn't mean you do absolutely nothing. I simply don't know if I can stop myself from buying an future skins for my 2 mains, being Ekko, and Teemo, but I'm done buying anything else. No more Event passes, no more skins for champs I don't use even though it's on sale and I think it's really cool. No more capsules during events to get bonus tokens for rewards. Riot is getting none of that shit from me again since apparently I might get lucky one day and get it all for free. This is how you lose a previously happy customer.

Meanie401/12/2019, 2:49:24 AM34 votes

Riot values all past purchases of hundreds of dollars of RP at about 50 BE.

Message heard loud and clear Riot.

19491/12/2019, 4:04:10 AM31 votes

damn, allowing players who exploit the system to keep what they took hurts me. i honestly think its either riot reverts transactions (even they claim that it will be too complicated) or give compensation for the players who didnt exploit the system. ive been reading the comments below and somehow i agree with them. i would be thankful enough if the compensation was just 5 capsules. in my opinion, its unfair how nothing is done for this situation besides reverting prestige points and prestige blood moon aatrox. im not even going to get started on the issue with prestige skins. item 3070

Rathar Dashing1/12/2019, 2:19:40 AM31 votes

This is such bullshit. I spend a couple hundred dollars a year on this game and now people who didn't spend a dime get ten times what I have in 14 minutes. I can handle your inability to balance the game, I still enjoy playing it, and I even put up with your stupid sexism at Pax, but this is the last straw as far as I'm concerned.

Urahara1/12/2019, 11:18:02 PM28 votes

I feel like you just fucked on me. On me and my hard work. I have 895 skins for now and I've been working to get them since season IV by playing many tournaments and paying whole lote of money. Now people are getting something I've been working on for so long I dont remember the exact time but I believe it was season II or III, there was a similiar bug in the store. I got permabanned for "stealing" 1000 RP. I lost 15 skins that time and I never managed to get them back. Except that I lost some summonersicons which showed that I was a veteran, I mean the beta icon. I don't want any punishment for those players but I really remember this ban. When I saw tbe chests for 1BE I was afraid if I was gonna get banned again or if you were just gonna piss me off saying you cannot do anything for 1000RP. I lost my account with really rare skins when they weren't punished for stealing 300 000... And Aatrox which you take back from them can be simply rerolld When the packs were available on the server I didn't buy them because I was afraid that I was gonna loose my account again.And I could get skinshards which would provide me new skins till the end of season 15 actually Sometimes you don't want to give me another skin for the one I already have from the chest for another one Where is the fairness?