Since they're not made of water they might not excrete, use nutrients, or respire.
Magic might just imbue things with awareness and mobility because maaagic rather than a system of interrelated organisms/cells/organelles creating chemicals like amino acids, proteins and enzymes, which is the scientific definition of life. Or in other words, the Vastayan can be robots imitating all the visible, psychological and practical capabilities of a human.
Declareas5 votesThe scientific definiton of life on Earth. And we aren't on Earth in league. Also, I fail to see the difference between the "robots" and living beings in a pragmatic sense. Obviously they're not human, but they're stated as being directly related to humans through cross-breeding with their ancestors. So yes, I think it's pretty safe to say the Vastaya are alive, and even if they were just "maaagic" I still don't think you can say they aren't living beings.
midnight oil243 votesThis is really well written. Props to you.
Declareas2 votesThank you! I do try, although I still need to get used to the boards formatting. [slayer-jinx-wink]
midnight oil241 votesWell you did a pretty damn good job for someoen getting used to it.
midnight oil242 votesReminder that this is league of legends, where you can be considered alive if you're a tree man. I'd say they count as living beings.
Also, just because they use magic instead of water doesn't mean they're not "living." As Declareas said below, you're limiting your thinking to just things on earth, instead of thinking about how other species might work.
In addition, we have no actual confirmation that they don't have things like cells and amino acids. Remember that we have water yet still have those things. Who's to say that the Vastaya don't just have magic doing the same thing as water to us and still having cells and amino acids and all that stuff?
Rebonack2 votesThe scientific definition of life goes more or less as follows. A living thing must be able to:
Despite being made of weird stuff, the Vastaya can do all those thing.
ThePikol1 votesSince they're not made of water
Where did you get that info from?
midnight oil242 votesIt was said by a rioter that magic to them is like water to humans. Yet we aren't fully made of water, we've still got things like the cells and amino acids he mentioned, so odds are it's like that with the Vastaya too.
ThePikol3 votesmagic to them is like water to humans
I would understand this as they can't live without magic as we can't without water, that is essential for their existance
Zelorxon1 votesWow now... That's sexist.
Tesla Effect1 votesThe definition of living being is very different from what real world definition would be, cause the laws of this fantasy world are different due to the presence of the very fantastical element of magic.
Otarie531 votesracist...
