With the new lore: Jayce is Mr. Fantastic & Viktor is Dr. Doom
So obvious. I mean, the name Viktor was a dead give-away before but now it is really obvious.
So obvious. I mean, the name Viktor was a dead give-away before but now it is really obvious.
Too bad Viktor Van Doom is NOT a Villain according to Stan Lee since he has ulterior goals that benefit a lot of people. He's a man with ideals and a vision, he can be an antagonist but he's not a malicious dastardly villain.
[{quoted}](name=Malicious Metal,realm=EUW,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=dBHJ2A7q,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2016-12-08T13:35:02.510+0000)
Too bad Viktor Van Doom is NOT a Villain according to Stan Lee since he has ulterior goals that benefit a lot of people. He's a man with ideals and a vision, he can be an antagonist but he's not a malicious dastardly villain.
LOL - by his deeds alone he is a villain regardless, I'd say.
But what about the girl (can't remember her name, sorry) who goes to stay with him when things get tense with the fantastic four and calls him Uncle Viktor? That's something good. Such a young person goes to him for support, and he does his best and is civil around her.
[{quoted}](name=midnight oil24,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=dBHJ2A7q,comment-id=000000000000,timestamp=2016-12-08T13:43:14.772+0000)
But what about the girl (can't remember her name, sorry) who goes to stay with him when things get tense with the fantastic four and calls him Uncle Viktor? That's something good. Such a young person goes to him for support, and he does his best and is civil around her.
That doesn't automatically make him Mother Theresa. Unless they retcon his entire history, he will always remain a villain.
He's done bad things, I'm not excusing that, but he's not a villain. For one thing, the creator said that he's not a villain. Also, there are things like the girl that show him in a better light.
Finally, Charles Xavier is a jerk who falls in love with teenagers and is a manipulative asshole. Is he still a hero?
[{quoted}](name=midnight oil24,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=dBHJ2A7q,comment-id=00000000000000000000,timestamp=2016-12-08T13:54:01.367+0000)
He's done bad things, I'm not excusing that, but he's not a villain. For one thing, the creator said that he's not a villain. Also, there are things like the girl that show him in a better light.
Finally, Charles Xavier is a jerk who falls in love with teenagers and is a manipulative asshole. Is he still a hero?
Stan Lee could've called him a carrot if he wants to, but that don't make him one.
As I said, unless they totally retcon him, Victor is a villain. Talk is cheap, retcon is not.
Guess which one matters?
Like I said earlier, despite the bad things and the manipulation, is Charles Xavier still good? Is Lex Luthor a good guy, despite his past atrocities, now that he's in the justice league? Is piccolo in Dragon Ball still a villain despite the good things about him?
But this is talking about a fall from grace or redemption. People can argue whether redemption is possible but that is different from Doom who last I checked is still bouncing around attempt to do his dastardly plots.
And Stalin loved his mother. He still killed millions, was a horrible tyrant, crushed whatever individual freedoms the USSR had, and was making plans to initiate a potentially nuclear war with the US before he died, and kill off the Jews in his territory (because if it worked for that one German guy, why shouldn't it work for him?). There is a point where we can call someone a villain while still understanding that they are human. Those two things are not mutually exclusive after all. It's closer to say that our very humanity is what brings about villainy in the first place.
Now, I understand that Stan Lee said he wasn't a villain. But, a few points, Doom has developed far beyond what Lee originally wrote at this point. And, while Stan is certainly a creative genius, the vast majority of his villains are pretty one-note stock characters. The evil scientist who just wants to rule the world, the bank robber who doesn't really have a motivation other than to create a catalyst for the hero to punch, and the Red Scare villain out to destroy America because they hate America are all really common for him. So, that's part of what makes Doom so interesting, and one of Lee's best villains is he does have a motivation other than just being evil for the sake of evil.
But, I would disagree with him that this means he isn't still the villain. Just going by what Lee had Doom doing, he betrayed people who were helping him. Planned outright murder. Nearly destroyed the world at one point. And if we get away from just what Lee was writing, we get the times he skinned an innocent alive to power some armor. The time he bombed innocents as a diversion. The time he committed intergalactic genocide. I could go on.
He is a villain by any logical understanding of the word. He's a complex villain, but still a villain.
I just feel like there's more to him than just villainy, while characters like Xavier have done horrible things but are still viewed as heroes.
Yeah. There is more to him than villainy but he is still a villain. Just a morally complex one. He's closer to Magneto than he is to the Joker. Both of them are amazing villains, but Magneto is a fully developed character while the Joker is more a personification of an ideal. Doom is somewhere in between but closer to Magneto.
Anyway, Prof X went through a phase where the writers decided to go "Hey what if we turned him into a total hypocritical asshole?"
I think people don't really think of him in those terms for a few reasons:
A lot of the times the Prof X is secretly an asshole! Stories were pretty poorly written, with a few exceptions, of course.
The characterization of X as this asshole was directly against his characterization before those stories so they don't actually feel like the old Prof X.
Most people don't actually read comics and know about Prof X from the old 90s cartoon and even more so, from Sir Patrick Stewart's portrayal. Where he may not always make the right choice but he is unilaterally good. Which interestingly is closer to what the character was originally written as.
ehhh if you read the comics Dr.Doom is only trying to take over the world because he has been to the future and seen that the only the one where he rules is the one where there is no suffering.
Crude deeds with good intentions
[{quoted}](name=Le Shenpai,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=dBHJ2A7q,comment-id=000000000001,timestamp=2016-12-08T14:25:29.001+0000)
ehhh if you read the comics Dr.Doom is only trying to take over the world because he has been to the future and seen that the only the one where he rules is the one where there is no suffering.
Crude deeds with good intentions
Still makes for a villain. It is why Batman doesn't get off scotch-free when he leaves a criminal in a coma or something.
Hitler loved dogs and animals, and the Nazis were revolutionary in their humane treatment of animals.
I was gonna write a whole mini rant on why Dr.Doom is in a way more just than alot of heros much more so than batman but it pretty much boils down to this:
Dr.Doom is working towards one united peoples and leader, he knows if he doesn't do it everyone will pretty much die. I see Dr.Doom as a walking machine of Logic that gets cocky from time to time and probably the best candidate to lead while as seen in multiple comics and movies the Heros go as far as to almost kill eachother in civil war and act on emotions too much
So yeah, perfect match isnt it?
I think Jayce sounds like a more pissed off and more jerky Tony Stark still.
More like Jayce is Tony Stark in terms of jackassery. Viktor is definitely Doctor Doom/Magneto.
[{quoted}](name=Tesla Effect,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=dBHJ2A7q,comment-id=0002,timestamp=2016-12-08T14:34:38.275+0000)
More like Jayce is Tony Stark in terms of jackassery. Viktor is definitely Doctor Doom/Magneto.
[{quoted}](name=Stars Shaper,realm=EUW,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=dBHJ2A7q,comment-id=0001,timestamp=2016-12-08T14:28:52.263+0000)
I think Jayce sounds like a more pissed off and more jerky Tony Stark still.
Stark doesn't have such a fitting arch-nemesis though (sadly, I love Doom).
Stark doesn't have such a fitting arch-nemesis though (sadly, I love Doom).
Your name, I know where it comes from (dem 18+ comics lewl)
[{quoted}](name=Tesla Effect,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=dBHJ2A7q,comment-id=000200000000,timestamp=2016-12-08T14:58:16.374+0000)
Your name, I know where it comes from (dem 18+ comics lewl)
[slayer-pantheon-thumbs]
I'm not sure where in the comic Mr. Fantastic is a MASSIVE DICK. He's a genius workaholic, but not an narcisstic jerk. I wouldn't put him into any relation to Jayce tbh.