@Riot, If An Overwhelming Amount Of The Community Opposes The Retcon, WIl You Undo It?

Impetual··6 votes·1,384 views

_edit: To be clear to those people that didn't understand this, I am asking this question hypothetically.

To rephrase a question that I don't think needs rephrasing: Riot, how would you hypothetically deal with an overwhelming amount of the community that opposes the Retcon?_

I'm really curious about this. Any Rioter who can give a concise answer, please respond!

I wanna find out how much community feedback can actually shape this games narrative direction!

Despite the outcome, RIot's answer will tell us a lot about where they stand as a company in terms of community feedback being important.

In the old days, Riot used to keep us pretty informed about who was working on what when it came to pretty much anything.

For some reason staff members in certain disciplines have become a secret so that we can talk directly to developers anymore, which used to be Riot's strength. Why throw away one of your strengths?

We could ask questions to those people and actually get direct responses! That was really cool, and Riot certainly was the best company at the time to have that kind of community interaction!

And not only did Rioters interact with their playerbase quite often, they would actually adjust their decisions based on community feedback.

Now Riot, you've Retconned Runeterra, and sadly it may forever remained retconned, but I ask you:

Is it possible for community feedback to change your decision?

If an overwhelming amount of the community is against a retcon, will you reverse it?

I'm not asking if it is probable, I'm asking if it is possible!

What say you Riot?!

20 Comments

Tesla Effect6 votes

Again, speak for yourself. A small community of displeased fans is not the majority of the community. The community ether doesnt care, likes the retcon, dont know jack about the lore or just hate changes for hate sake.

Impetual3 votes

I'm just asking Riot what their response would be in a "what if" situation!

I'm not hating here, I'm just asking Riot what they would do in a "what if the community overwhelming opposed the retcon" situation.

This isn't about opinion, or what players actually think. This is a hypothetical situation.

I thought that was pretty clear in the thread title.

Ariaflux4 votes

There's nothing wrong with your topic, it's just that the community is tired of hearing about the retcon. There were many discussions about it in the past and Riot did communicate many times their ideas and plans (yet people keep on saying that they don't). People have moved on, either by leaving the game, or by accepting the feedback that Riot gave to us (no, they are not going to reverse the retcon), and try to make the best out of it.

If you are strictly talking about a what-if situation, then if everybody in the world boycott LoL if Riot doesn't reverse the retcon then sure, Riot will do it. But the chances of that happening is close to zero and it's not interesting to discuss.

Impetual2 votes

Lol, you don't seem to remember things accurately.

Riot never accurately described their future lore direction. They gave us a very broad lore philosophy that they were going to try to follow.

For some reason, Riot refused to answer most of the critical lore questions that surrounded the retcon.

For example: What's the deal with Jax's lore?

powerbats2 votes

This isn't an attempt to bash you but point some things out.

{quoted}

Lol, you don't seem to remember things accurately.

Riot never accurately described their future lore direction. They gave us a very broad lore philosophy that they were going to try to follow.

For some reason, Riot refused to answer most of the critical lore questions that surrounded the retcon.

For example: What's the deal with Jax's lore?

So because they gave broad outline of what their ideas are and not some in depth tell all you've basically become the complainer in chief is what it looks like. Also you may not have been attacking Riot in this thread but the same can't be held true for some of your other posts.

{quoted}

Borked to the point where they can't even change text on certain pages?

Sounds like they've screwed things up pretty badly.

This next ones passive aggressive in anture and just because a thread is highly upvoted doens't mean anything since the small trollish group of the old gd used to upvote some of the worst most toxic threads out there aboutr rape/incest etc.

{quoted}

There are many highly upvoted "best" rated threads in the Story and Art boards that have seemingly been ignored by RIot for quite a long time. Rioters may have read these posts, but they have certainly declined to interact with the community in any way whatsoever in many of these topics. Why is this?

Firstly, I thought that the whole point of the forum revamp was to make the more popular threads more visible to Rioters, so that they could respond to them.

Secondly, I thought that it was supposed to be a better way to tell Riot what the player=base actually cares about so that we could have better discussions with RIot about what is important to us.

So...why is Riot ignoring some of the most highly upvoted threads on the Story and Art Boards? And why does it seem like most of the threads that are being ignored are ones that seem to be against the retcon?

Just saying, I really miss the old Riot that actually defended its position on controversial issues, and was willing to discuss stuff with the player-base.

You did in that same thread have some good comments about it all and you kept it polite and neutral, something that sadfly some of your others posts don't do.

{quoted}

Lol, I doubt Riot pays their lore writers minimum wage, but based on their performance, they probably should.

{quoted}

I've made the same point before, albeit much less eloquently.

It does seem pretty weird that a "tech issue" would prevent Riot from putting text where they want it to be for several months.

Unless their technical team is completely incompetent, there's most likely something else going on.

Considering the perceived turn over that the lore department has gone through in the last year, it wouldn't be surprising if Riot was just trying to stall for time while its new team got its shit together.

Don't know why Riot isn't just being honest with us though. Their current explanations seem pretty fishy.

Unless you work for them or have some inside knowledge of the situation your claims are pretty baseless and why would Riot respond afte all the crap that's been thrown their way everytime they do respond it's never enough.

{quoted}

Well, Riot has seemingly formed a foundations department recently. Assuming they still have a narrative department, and a lore department, I think it's high time Riot gave us a decent explanation about all of their story related departments and how they interact with one another.

This I can agree with but remeber those people might not be allowed to tell you anything. Those orders are probably coming down from 1 or more division heads higher up. I've dealt with enough of those people when I was managing a department ina wafer processing facility as a lead. In this case a polite thread asking @riot moobeat or @riot jinx for some clarification on said departments might help and get you a better understanding of how each department works.

{quoted}

My issue isn't so much with their lack of reading the stuff posted, but their lack of responding to it.

Riot used to be very player focused, and it would discuss LoL with us to a great extent.

I feel that that was one of their greatest strengths that helped LoL become as popular as it is today.

I don't want Riot to lose sight of that, especially when it comes to their lore.

Really now, us players don't really have much of an idea about what Riot is thinking! That's a big part of the problem!

Here I ahve to agree that the community has gotten spoiled by how open Riot has been adn perhaps there's a reason for all this secrecy it could be compteitors or a change in department heads or soemone from higher up saying stop talking. But unless and until Riot decides to tell us the bashing of them for not responding to each and every thread where they only get flamed anyways is pointless. It's far better to post once a week and ask for an update while realizing you threads get buried by all the nerf x champ etc threads.

{quoted}

The problem is that the Rioters that usually comment on lore pretty often say they can't tell us anything of substance since they aren't from the right department.

Hearing that gets old really fast.

BTW, I think you are awesome Ironstylus!!! :)

This happened a lot in the old TBI forums where we actually had a Riot Kiddington from their network services department come in and try and help but couldn't really tell us much. He did try and help as best he could and got toehr rioters involed who could help us. NMost rioters will try and help out even though they're not from teh same department.

@Riot, Let's Drop The Bullshit Reasons For Lore Stagnancy. Let's Actually Talk About Stuff!

Ok this thread title and what you put in it was totally uncalled for and is why you don't get any responses, if I was leading that department I wouldn't respond to this either and I'd tell my crew to do the same.

{quoted}

Rioters, I know you guys must be bound to some kind of code that disables you from talking to us about certain things.

That's the only reason I can I can come up with to explain your silence over the last few months about giving us any details about Riot Narrative lore direction.

@Riot Narrative, Your absence in many threads has made it pretty clear that the narrative team has very little desire creating lore for the community that it serves.

Some of the ridiculous reasons that I've heard that Riot can no longer take fan input into account concerning champions and lore is troubling. We need someone to teach us about these issues.

We need a narrative team member who can talk to us about what their limitations are, so that we can better refine our posts to educate them on our opinion.

Riot Please, Listen to your player-base again... especially when it comes to lore!

TALK TO US!!!

{quoted}

Not to disrespect the narrative team, but if your reasoning is correct, then they need to grow some balls and start doing their job.

Again uncalled for.

{quoted}

Which is why constructive criticism is needed. If they aren't doing the job as well as the old crew, the playerbase should tell them what they're doing wrong so that they can improve.

It's called Player feedback.

It is necessary for League of Legends to become a better game.

Constructively critical posts are helpful to Riot, not hurtful.

People that blindly defend the stupid decisions that Riot makes hurt this game more than anything. It leads to Riot believing that bad decisions are good ones.

If I see Riot creating/posting bullshit, I will call it bullshit, and I consider that my way of telling Riot what I think from a player perspective.

Riot wants that kind of information. Telling them how you really feel gives them something to work on, while being forcefully positive when they are doing a bad job is just misleading them into creating bad lore.

Your opinion that it's bad doesn't make it so and saying that people blindly defend Riot without actually finding out their reasons is pretty bad when you claim to want constructive dialogue yet opppose it in the same post by stating people are blindly following Riot. You make some good points and then proceed to put your vitrual foot in your mouth and defeat yourself.

continued next post.

Tesla Effect2 votes

{quoted}

I'm just asking Riot what their response would be in a "what if" situation!

I'm not hating here, I'm just asking Riot what they would do in a "what if the community overwhelming opposed the retcon" situation.

This isn't about opinion, or what players actually think. This is a hypothetical situation.

I thought that was pretty clear in the thread title.

But you attack Riot way too much and way too often. Pretty much hate at this point.

Impetual3 votes

I don't think I've been attacking Riot at all in thread. I've just asked them a hypothetical question that I think would think we'd all be pretty interested to have answered.

If you can fish up some actual hate that I've posted in this thread, then do it (disagreement is not hate). Otherwise I think you're a bit delusional, but by all means go ahead and try.

While I don't think I've ever made an outright Riot hate thread/comment on these boards, I definitely don't think there is anything remotely close to an unproductive hate post made by me anywhere in this thread..

If you're going to comment here, please refrain from posting un-constructive straw-man arguements and actually post something of substance.

If you disagree with me, make an actual constructive argument about the thread topic, so that we can have an actual discussion.

Impetual2 votes

I'm asking a question here, I'm not speaking for anyone! Learn to read!

Narasimha6 votes

It would have to be an overwhelming amount of the ENTIRE community, not just the board lurkers. And that's just not a feasible feat.

Sharjo5 votes

Exactly. We're a FRACTION of LoL's playerbase. Not even an easily visible fraction either.

Impetual3 votes

While I agree that we are just a fraction of the community, I would argue we are the MOST visible fraction!

We are the players that post on the boards and make our opinions known to Riot. We are the players that care enough to tell them what they might not want to hear.

Sure, most of the player base will accept whatever crap they're are given regardless of the quality, but that doesn't mean that the players who want to hold Riot to a higher standard shouldn't speak up about it!

The whole point of posting on these boards is to give Riot feedback so that they can make their game better!

I don't understand why so many players have adopted this defeatist attitude, that players can't influence Riot's decisions based on player feedback!

Building on player feedback has always been one of Riot's founding philosophies!

If you don't like the direction of this game, voice your opinion so that Riot can take it into consideration!

Silent acceptance gives them nothing to work on!

Constructive criticism is a good thing for both Riot, and Players of League of Legends.

Helmight5 votes

Impetual, I think at this point it's time to let it go. I'm just as upset about the retcon as you are, but Riot isn't going to undo this just because a few lore buffs got pissy on the forums. Very rarely does Riot reverse their decisions, especially on matters of story. The best we can do now is to gather our thoughts, accept the retcon, and do what we can to make it as good as it possibly can be.

It's pointless to keep whining for things to return to the way they were before, even if things are bad now. Sorry, mate.

Impetual3 votes

There's a difference between whining and constructive feedback.

I'm gonna give Riot constructive feedback when I think they are making stupid decisions....if you agree with/ accept those decisions without wanting to give them any feedback, that's your decision.

Don't hate on me for disagreeing.

Helmight1 votes

I am hardly hating on you, mate. Trust me, if I honestly thought that raising enough of a stink would revert the retcon, I would be here every hour making a thread. I also completely understand giving constructive feedback. That was basically the gist of the first post I made here.

The only issue I had was with the thread title, which you've now said is meant to be taken hypothetically and not seriously. And regardless of the fact, Riot wouldn't change their decision. I think that's become clear over time, given their current attitude towards lore and such.

Jeddy0173 votes

Let us remember that large portion of the LOL playerbase probably doesn't care about the lore or have knowledge of it.With Riot treatment of said lore,lore fans are probably a minority in the playerbase. I don't know that for sure though,just how I think the situation is.I would like to be proven wrong & told that many LOL players care about & know of the lore.

powerbats2 votes

Oh yes another vocal minority post rearing it's ugly head claiming to represent the majority of the playerbase. Now given the fact that the vast majority of the player base never even visits the forums let alone knows they exist we can safely dismiss this as yet another puff my chest and hear me roar type of post. You and you vocal minority don't nor have you ever nor will you ever represent the majority of the playerbase so stop pretending like you do.

Riot and the majority of the forum goers don't care about your rants or your claims of majority status otherwise you'd have several thousand posters agreeing and upvoting you and not the same small group.

GreenLore2 votes

If such a large amount of the community opposed the retcon(which is basically impossible as others pointed already out),then they'd probably still continue with the retcon at first to see the communitys opinion afterwards and if the community then opposes the new lore again,then they might react to it. However its likely they would still keep the retcon and merely add summoners and the league back in a way that doesn't interefere that much with the world. And if the community spoke up against that AGAIN,then they MAYBE they'd go back on it completely.

Notice however that there is basically zero chance for this to happen(even the first step has basically no chance of happening) and even if this happened they would probably still retcon individual champions and it would be a major setback for the lore team resulting in even less new lore for us.

Angry Monster2 votes

They already said NO. please stop.

powerbats1 votes

{quoted}

I'm sorry, but in my eyes the lore team has really let players down over the last year.

The lore quality is questionable.

The lore quantity is undenyably lower.

And worst of all, the narrative team refuses to talk to its player-base.

I'm sorry, I love Riot and all, but we should not be giving them a pat on the back for getting worse at what they do.

That's just encouraging their lore team to keep failing to produce lore up to the old standard.

We want things to get better, not worse.

Again your opinion that it's worse and you should state that it's your opinion as in I feel it's worse not state it as fact.

{quoted}

Are you an undercover Rioter trying to make sense of this nonsense retcon? It kinda seems like it due to the amount of bullshit.

It really seems stupid that a company would assume that a player-base should innately understand how an entire games lore changes due to the removal of one of the central institutions without any additional information provided.

It's akin to telling us that the holocaust never happened but everything is somehow is same as it would have been if it did...bullshit!

Riot, you can't just say "Pretend everything happened the same way except one of the major power of the world never existed".

That's stupid, and is a really** lazy **way to re-write lore!

Riot If you are going to destroy Runeterra in a retcon, with the removal of the Institute of War and Summoners, Then you should actually take the time to write new lore without lazily filling in wholes with the old stuff that doesn't make sense anymore!

The hyperbole and sublte riot insults are pretty bad and using the holocaust as an example is not only tasteless but asinine and you could have the cure for cancer but you'd lose any credibility with that reference.

{quoted}

Sorry If once or twice a week I try to lobby for Riot to produce the kind of lore that they used to during their early years. (Season 1 and 2)

If some people that prefer the current lore release rate/quality to the older ones (That were delivered every two weeks and had actual story development for Runeterra and its champions) Then so be it.

But really, If you actually ever cared to read and try to actually discern the intent of any my posts, then bravo, you actually have some intelligence.

AdHominem attack on someone and then using that to congratulate them if tehy agree with you is pretty sad.

The fact of the matter is, I LOVE RIOT GAMES!

Seriously, I'm not a hater of Riot. I love them and I love their game.

I just think they made a major mistake in retconning their lore, and _I'm sharing my opinion on that. _ Now see ehre you actually state your sharing your opinion and not stating it as fact.

I want them to fix what I think is their biggest mistake!

I WANT RIOT TO BE SUCCESSFUL! I JUST THINK THEIR CURRENT LORE DIRECTION WILL LEAD TO STAGNANT CHARACTERS WHO DON'T HAVE ANY REASON TO FIGHT! ** RIP the Institute of War! **

Their current lack of written lore and excess of sloppy uninformative video based lore troubles me.

Was the Institute of War sometimes a silly reason for champions to fight one another? Sure, but it was a reason nonetheless.

Now champion seems to exist in a vacuum...which feels horrible from my perspective.

If you can't handle a player like me sharing their opinion once or twice a week on these boards then you should get your sissy ass off them!

Way to once again put your vitrual foot in your mouth, you could've elft alone adn let your opinion do the talking.

{quoted}

Have you seen the content of those responses? They are mostly bullshit responses that seem lore related, so that Rioters can say they responded, but contain little to no actual information.

If I see a bullshit response, I'm going to call it one.

Have you realized that the majority of responses to narrative threads lately have not been made by members of the narrative team?

It seems like Riot is trying to give us Red Responses from people who don't know what they're talking about in order to satiate us. It's kind of underhanded.

Again you make a statemnt as if it's fact the responses are bullshit because you don't agree with them, opinions don't make it so.

I'd post more examples but you should get my points now, stop bashing Riot and claiming your opinions as fact or that you repesent a majority or w/e. Simply state you feel there needs to be some changes and for fkcs sake keep it polite and avoid the personal attacks, Ad Hominem attacks etc. Also relaize that you've probalby made it so that no one in those departments will respond to you based upon the examples I've already shown.

Now the one piece of good advice I can give you is hop onto Twitter and nciely ask Moobeat for some clarification since he might be able to ehlp but if you go bashing anyone youre never going to get a response at all. Remeber it's all in the delviery, you could ahve the greatest lore idea for all time but it will get nowehre if your delviery is poor and is comprised of the things I pointed out.

powerbats1 votes

So hopefully if you're nice you'll get a Rioter response but if you don't than take that as a lesson to watch what you say.

More from Story, Art, & Sound

More by Impetual