Compensation for downtime was a positive thing. . .
Now I'm not going to make this sound like a greedy kid who just wants something for nothing. 'Tis a free game, and I have spent my fair share of money getting in game stuffs, and am only 5 champs away from owning them all. Ip really would go to runes for the most part for me at this point, so it doesn't really bother me. What bothers me, is not being able to play because of the servers. I feel like the compensation Riot gave in the past was a positive thing, and here's how:
It gave Riot incentive to keep their servers maintained. I'm not going to pretend to know the complexity of the system, or say I can do it better because I can't. I will say that if Riot puts out IP compensation or IP boosts for down time, it made an increase in the community's overall IP. This of course would mean a decrease in RP purchases. Not by a lot, and again I'm not going to say I'm a professional, but enough. If they don't want that to happen, then server stability should be a primary concern, and I'm sure it is regardless. By taking away the compensation, to the community it feels like Riot is saying "We're expecting our servers to be faulty", and they know they can't compensate for it every time.
Like I said, not trying to sound like the greedy kid going "Gimme gimme gimme" because all I want is to be able to play when I'm done with a long day of school/work, and I feel the compensation was a good incentive.
Just an opinion.