Quoting numbered lists doesn't work as expected when split in quotes

1. An item
2. Another item
3. A Third Item
4. A Fourth Item

Quoted:

1. An item
2. Another item
3. A Third Item
4. A Fourth Item

Quoted with comments:

1. An item

I like item 1.

2. Another item

Item 2 isn't so great.

3. A Third Item

Okay, this is getting ridiculous.

4. A Fourth Item