Witch hunts and sharing stories of toxic players with names should be encouraged.
The boards shouldn't have this policy. Irl, if someone tells me to kill myself and talks about how they raped my mother, I will be like "Woah guess what this crazy guy named Bob Saget said to me today! Here's a video of him doing it!"
These deplorables never actually get banned and are in every single game, so not being able to share how ridiculous they are is just giving more power to them.
Edit: I bet 100% of all downvotes are toxic players that like getting away with being deplorables every game.