I gave plenty of alternatives but no one wants to be a trailblazer and put in the work.
Because people make inconvenient excuses as to why "we want people to be in la-la land!" (dreamworld).
-
DISABLE MOST/ALL ABILITY TO TYPE IN CHAT EXCEPT VIA parser COMMANDS to party members or friends. (this isn't hard). commands to /party would be unlimited, as well as whispers, etc. VERY limited ability to type in normal chat (strict limit, even stricter than current "Chat Restriction" punishment).
(benefits: can't be toxic, can't make death threats, can't go around blaming the jungler and bot lane for them tilting, blah blah).
-
REVAMP and EXPAND the smart ping system, to prevent a) toxic ? spam, b) no death timers on teammates allowed except YOURSELF, enemy timers are a go. c) greatly enhanced parser to allow much more information, like a Baron submenu: "let's secure Baron" "enemy has vision around Baron", etc, and a Dragon submenu.
Other submenus like "Let's push down mid/top/bot", "Ward and take control of enemy jungle", "Enemy has control of our jungle", etc.
You get the point.
Allow certain of these smart pings to be set on hotkeys for quick access or modifier+hotkeys.
Prevent spamming by having a VERY strict limit on the amount of phrases that can be typed.
Drawback: cuts down on "social" random interaction.
Cuts down on some of the fun of meeting very friendly players.
Counterarguments to proposed system "drawbacks":
- Discord is a thing now, which wasn't a thing when League came out; back then we had to deal with MSN Messenger/Skype, Teamspeak and Ventrilo. Really want teamwork and to make friends? Go on discord. Pregame and post game chat is unlimited.
- You can still use the text parser to whisper to friends and premades in whispers, without a chat limit (/msg, /whisper, /w, /r), as well as the /party system.
- By preventing people from being toxic (Unless they REALLY went out of their way somehow to get in some toxicity in a very limited system), now Riot has full resources freed up to deal with actual GRIEFING and problems with in game play, intentional feeding, and excessive toxicity in post game or pregame, by cutting out a LOT Of data flowing through the system.
So what about this doesn't make sense? Or is it just too much of an "Inconvenient truth"?