Boards›Player Behavior

The Verdict - Episode 1

ModUlanopo·6/3/2017, 7:04:28 PM·56 votes·5,132 views

Today we are going over the first set of chat logs volunteered to us from last week. Review the logs, cast your vote, and discuss your decisions.

Ground Rules

  • Be respectful.
  • Be helpful.
  • It’s better to lift someone up than to push them down.
  • Remember, you are only voting on the volunteer’s chat.

    • Player/Teammates/Opponents

    Game 1:

    [0:18] Master Yi: invade

    [0:22] Master Yi: shut that eve down early

    [0:31] Darius: 0 cc outside of Lux q early

    [0:33] Darius: invade

    [0:33] Darius: xd

    [0:59] Taliyah: gj

    [1:07] [All] Bard: ok yi

    [1:10] [All] Bard: you rude

    [1:18] [All] Master Yi: all's fair in love and war, sweety.

    [1:21] [All] Lux: make sure?

    [1:48] Master Yi: ty

    [2:28] Master Yi: eve stole my red

    [2:30] Master Yi: big surprise

    [2:43] [All] Bard: lol Lux

    [3:03] Taliyah: gp summs

    [3:51] Master Yi: care bot

    [4:24] Darius: double f

    [4:26] Darius: i think

    [4:40] Master Yi: well they lost that trade huge

    [4:48] Taliyah: ye

    [4:52] Taliyah: good fight man

    [5:00] Master Yi: Darius basically 1v2'd

    [6:56] Darius: xd

    [7:10] Taliyah: thought youd push wave first

    [7:11] Taliyah: my b

    [7:27] Master Yi: is she stealing red?

    [7:29] Darius: hard to push a rumble tbh

    [8:26] Taliyah: holy

    [8:26] [All] Bard: lol

    [8:27] Taliyah: shit

    [8:28] Lux: gg

    [8:31] [All] Bard: best gank

    [8:40] Master Yi: there isn't much for me to gank tbh

    [8:52] Taliyah: sorry gusy

    [9:32] Master Yi: let her go

    [10:10] Master Yi: let's take this shit

    [10:33] Master Yi: eve inc

    [10:42] Darius: wait

    [10:44] Darius: he has 40 cs

    [10:45] Darius: LOL

    [11:34] Master Yi: gimme my damn refillable back

    [11:38] Master Yi: shop tried to steal it

    [12:42] Master Yi: rumble TP'd in

    [12:45] Master Yi: and all 5 of them were there

    [12:47] Master Yi: idk why

    [12:50] Master Yi: and idk how

    [13:25] Master Yi: yi's pretty good rn with BoRK being OP

    [14:19] Taliyah: take it

    [15:08] Master Yi: in out and satisfied

    [15:24] Taliyah: im getting shit on mid

    [15:33] Taliyah: i roamed way too much

    [15:40] Master Yi: doing what i can

    [15:47] Master Yi: but i'm also trying to stay relevant in farm

    [15:54] Taliyah: gp is huge

    [16:07] Darius: rumble is shit

    [16:11] Darius: like he doesnt know how to ult

    [16:12] Darius: or cs

    [16:14] Darius: or anyhting

    [16:35] Master Yi: Meditate didn't go off

    [16:36] Master Yi: again

    [16:40] Master Yi: for the billionth time

    [17:20] Taliyah: this is gg

    [17:26] Master Yi: no it isn't

    [17:28] Master Yi: chill tf out

    [17:44] Master Yi: just focus the proper targets

    [18:39] Master Yi: FUCK BARD

    [18:42] Master Yi: WTF

    [18:47] Master Yi: how did he stun me

    [18:53] [All] Bard: yipls

    [19:03] [All] Master Yi: you got lucky your stun activated by not hitting anything

    [19:12] [All] Bard: the wall?

    [19:17] [All] Master Yi: no animation

    [19:23] [All] Bard: i saw it

    [19:26] [All] Master Yi: i didn't

    [19:26] [All] Gangplank: "i was in alpha!"

    [19:36] Master Yi: zzz

    [19:41] [All] Master Yi: I just watched that actually

    [19:46] [All] Master Yi: and yeah, they haven't fixed that still

    [19:49] [All] Master Yi: shit still hits you in alpha

    [20:16] [All] Darius: ?

    [20:19] [All] Darius: the wall

    [20:26] [All] Bard: so mad haha

    [20:42] [All] Darius: what do i have to be mad about

    [20:49] [All] Darius: i shit down tops throat lul

    [21:06] [All] Bard: lol you got camped by mid and jun

    [21:15] [All] Darius: pretty sure i traded 1 for 1 when she ganked

    [21:20] [All] Gangplank: ?

    [21:35] [All] Darius: ?

    [21:42] [All] Evelynn: ok so it doesnt go off but did go off on zhonyas?

    [21:42] Taliyah: ok

    [21:58] [All] Darius: he didnt hourglass the ult

    [22:13] Master Yi: KILL

    [22:14] Master Yi: HIM

    [22:22] Master Yi: zzz

    [22:44] Master Yi: can we stop letting GP get free kills for no punishment

    [23:13] [All] Darius: ?

    [23:44] Taliyah: gj

    [23:52] Darius: my boy

    [24:05] Master Yi: damn i love this skin

    [24:14] Darius: ye its lit

    [24:44] Master Yi: i don't need blue anymore

    [25:05] Master Yi: rip

    [25:05] [All] Bard: wall

    [25:06] [All] Darius: ?

    [25:18] Darius: shoulda got mid

    [25:20] Darius: but oh well

    [25:24] Taliyah: ????

    [25:36] Darius: ?? push it get the turret is what im saying

    [25:41] Darius: is that hard to understand or

    [25:43] Taliyah: we were SUPER far

    [25:53] Darius: im saying YOU SHOULD HAVE HEADED BOT WHEN 4 WERE THERE

    [26:01] Taliyah: sigh

    [26:11] Taliyah: i mean your right

    [26:16] Taliyah: but that wasnt an option this time

    [26:19] [All] Master Yi: how about no

    [27:07] Master Yi: zzz

    [27:11] [All] Gangplank: We did it

    [27:12] Master Yi: i hate evelynn

    [27:13] [All] Gangplank: raidboss down

    [27:15] Master Yi: stupid champ

    [27:23] Master Yi: stealth is broken now that pink wards are dead

    [27:24] Darius: i need 16

    [27:30] Master Yi: i do too, my ult sucks atm

    [28:38] Master Yi: NO

    [28:39] Master Yi: WAY

    [28:40] Master Yi: NO

    [28:41] Master Yi: I LIVED

    [28:42] Master Yi: HE DIED

    [28:43] Master Yi: BULL

    [28:45] Master Yi: CRAP

    [29:44] [All] Darius: ?

    [29:46] [All] Bard: lol

    [29:51] Darius: LOL

    [29:52] Darius: exhaust

    [29:53] Darius: cucked me

    [29:54] Darius: fuck

    [29:56] [All] Gangplank: its so annoying how you guys can just auto barrels lol

    [30:06] [All] Darius: dang the only counterplay to gp is annoying

    [30:06] [All] Caitlyn: thats kinda how gp works

    [30:08] [All] Darius: !

    [30:22] [All] Gangplank: 1st time gp

    [30:24] [All] Gangplank: smd

    [30:28] [All] Taliyah: right

    [30:30] Master Yi: GP has counterplay?

    [30:32] [All] Gangplank: like Darius has counterplay

    [30:33] Master Yi: since when?

    [30:34] [All] Darius: but you have mastery lvl 4 wut

    [30:36] [All] Darius: and Darius does

    [30:39] [All] Darius: dont be a tard

    [30:44] [All] Darius: lucky for me xd

    [30:49] [All] Darius: you guys are xd players

    [30:51] [All] Caitlyn: just do a 1 part

    [31:25] Master Yi: Dar, we need you

    [31:27] Taliyah: god this bot lane

    [32:08] Darius: comer

    [32:09] Darius: now

    [32:11] Darius: they drake

    [32:12] Darius: we baaeron

    [32:17] Master Yi: it's an infernal

    [32:48] [All] Master Yi: nt

    [33:58] Master Yi: wtf

    [33:59] Taliyah: fuck this

    [34:00] Master Yi: i was in alpha

    [34:03] Taliyah: way too fed

    [34:04] [All] Bard: ?

    [34:05] [All] Lucian: gg

    [34:07] Master Yi: zzz

    [34:07] [All] Darius: unlucky

    [34:09] [All] Gangplank: gg yizus

    [34:12] Master Yi: useless Caitlyn

    [34:14] Taliyah: gg bot

    [34:19] Master Yi: literally useless

    [34:23] Caitlyn: i

    [34:26] Darius: its a group game boys

    [34:28] Darius: cant blame them

    [34:29] [All] Bard: ggez

    [34:29] [All] Rumble: gg

    [34:29] [All] Evelynn: gg

    [34:30] Caitlyn: had 4 retards bot

    What say you?
    POSITIVE
    NEUTRAL
    NEGATIVE
    Poll Maker

    173 Comments

    VoidStaresBack6/3/2017, 7:29:31 PM41 votes

    I voted neutral for this game. I don't hold the late game tilting against them because there wasn't any toxicity directed towards anyone, just frustration at game mechanics and a snide comment about GP's counterplay, none of which I consider toxic, just tilted. I probably would have gone with positive in honor of their early game attitude if it weren't for the crack at Caitlyn at the end, which was really the only thing reportable in there and imo it's not even remotely bannable. Unnecessary? Absolutely. Kinda douchey? Absolutely. Worth a report? I'd say probably not, especially given that there's a very clearly visible progression as the game slowly wears on them and they get more tilted by losing, so I'm perfectly willing to give the benefit of the doubt that they are generally a decent player who just cracked under strain.

    ˉˉˉˉˉˉ6/3/2017, 7:53:35 PM27 votes

    Why are the Teammates red and the Opponents blue?

    Is it cause your teammates are the true enemy in this game or...?

    AJStarhiker6/3/2017, 8:39:57 PM16 votes

    I would say Yi starts on the positive side of neutral, mostly stays neutral, but edges into negative with the Caitlyn cracks at the end.

    If this game came up under the old Tribunal, I would not vote punish on just this chat log, but it would make me take a closer look at any other games in the case.

    ModUlanopo6/3/2017, 11:04:45 PM13 votes

    THE VERDICT IS IN!

    http://i.imgur.com/ldFEwcS.jpg[/img]

    464 votes is amazing, guys.

    http://i.imgur.com/Rln9om0.jpg[/img]

    We also got votes from all over the world!

    It looks as though the consensus is that Yi wasn't really toxic until the very end and people don't believe a punishment is warranted..

    ModPeriscope6/3/2017, 7:59:41 PM12 votes

    I voted neutral. This seemed like a fun, positively communicating game until the end when yi calls the Caitlyn useless. I don't think this chat would warrant a punishment.

    Tribbles Foxfolk6/3/2017, 7:48:52 PM8 votes

    What are the rules for revealing who was who in this match? I admit to being IN this match, but I won't say WHO unless it's allowed.

    Anyways, I voted negative. Too much salt in that game.

    Warlord Scrap6/3/2017, 7:12:43 PM6 votes

    Id say she was neutral. While the zz's are irrelevant to the game she never flames but shes not really positive either.

    On a side note can someone explain what cucking is. I know what it means irl but it always confuses me when used in lol like the word is irrelevant to the game.

    Nidalee SO NYAAA6/3/2017, 7:54:13 PM6 votes

    I voted for neutral for this game because no one was being positive but no one was being toxic to someone. Only thing I thought was somewhat toxic was " useless Caitlyn" " literally useless." The crack on Cait was not cool but not bannable

    AzureDragoon6/3/2017, 7:34:33 PM5 votes

    For most of the match, I'd say our volunteer was positive or neutral. Nothing I'd hold against them for the most part. A bit of a salt at a failed play or two, but nothing against a player directly, and nothing really offensive here.

    Except there is one part I do note as being negative, is at the very end:

    [34:12] Master Yi: useless Caitlyn [34:19] Master Yi: literally useless

    Looks kinda like there was a bit of a pile on the bot lane in the grand scheme of things, but in the end, we're here to discuss the Mastery Yi' player's behavior.

    This overall is kinda minor, though it certainly isn't going to make anyone on the receiving end of that happy after a 30 minute game. Not something you want to make a habit of, but not anything I'd punish on its own here. Overall, I say Neutral.

    Aeszarck6/3/2017, 9:32:14 PM4 votes

    Master Yi was doing well early on but seemed to get more and more negative as the match went on.

    For example, in the beginning, Yi responds to Taliyah ([17:20] Taliyah: this is gg) with [17:26] Master Yi: no it isn't [17:28] Master Yi: chill tf out [17:44] Master Yi: just focus the proper targets which I think is a good example of encouraging the team while providing some advice. However, later on Yi starts to add negativity to the chat by complaining about bugs, what a stupid champ Evelynn is, and then directly insulting his/her teammate Caitlyn in a pretty mean way. It's mostly the insult, the bugs and the stupid champ complaints are quite minor. I think that since the chat starts off level and goes somewhat negative, I'll vote neutral, with an edge towards negative.

    Solidarius6/3/2017, 9:16:36 PM3 votes

    neutral only the "had 4 retards bot" pissed me off, otherwise would of been positive.

    Kei1436/3/2017, 9:56:29 PM2 votes

    1. How do I get you to authorize me so I can see the results?

    2. If it's just 1 game, I'm voting neutral. If there were 5 games like this, I'm voting negative. You plan on just showing 1 game in the going future? or does this mean that he was only reported once within a long while?

    themachamp6/4/2017, 2:28:24 AM1 votes

    Wow....that chat was worthy of a punishment, according to riot?????