Next Support Purchase: Thresh or Lulu, and why?

Aids cuz League··2 votes·647 views

Which support should I buy next and why? Also, do you think I should wait for a new champ release seeing as the last champs they released in quick succession. Azir which was quickly followed by Rek'Sai?

16 Comments

arcinex2 votes

Lulu is easier to learn while Thresh takes more skill and decision making.

disregardable1 votes

I'd definitely argue the opposite. All you need to do to use Thresh properly is get relic shield, front line, harass with your E, and hook the ADC when they're more than half way away from their turret. Succeeding with Lulu is a bit more complicated.

arcinex2 votes

[{quoted}](name=The AFK Farmer,realm=NA,application-id=cIfEodbz,discussion-id=xnQAt0mc,comment-id=00000000,timestamp=2015-03-30T00:57:37.421+0000)

I'd definitely argue the opposite. All you need to do to use Thresh properly is get relic shield, front line, harass with your E, and hook the ADC when they're more than half way away from their turret. Succeeding with Lulu is a bit more complicated.

There is way way more to it than just that. You have your flay (push/pull) which is very hard to master IMO, lantern, and hooking and making the right decision to press q again to do your Ulti+flay combo. There is also his passive.

Lulu is a point and click champion which is why I consider her an easier champion to master.

disregardable2 votes

Yeah, it's so hard to learn to move your mouse in the way you want it to go...? Seriously, his kit is not difficult at all. I'd say the hardest part about it is putting down the lantern at the right time.

arcinex1 votes

[{quoted}](name=The AFK Farmer,realm=NA,application-id=cIfEodbz,discussion-id=xnQAt0mc,comment-id=0000000000000000,timestamp=2015-03-30T02:05:55.310+0000)

Yeah, it's so hard to learn to move your mouse in the way you want it to go...? Seriously, his kit is not difficult at all. I'd say the hardest part about it is putting down the lantern at the right time.

We have opposing views unrightfully so. If he's so easy to learn why have you won only 1 game with thresh?

http://na.op.gg/summoner/userName=the+afk+farmer

disregardable2 votes

Because I don't bring him into ranked (or main support). If I need tanky engage, I have Leona. If I need harass, I have Sona. If I need something in the middle, I have Annie. Most of the time I really don't need his kit. I probably have only played him two or three times since season reset, but I know how to play him if I wanted to.

arcinex1 votes

[{quoted}](name=The AFK Farmer,realm=NA,application-id=cIfEodbz,discussion-id=xnQAt0mc,comment-id=000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2015-03-30T02:49:16.940+0000)

Because I don't bring him into ranked (or main support). If I need tanky engage, I have Leona. If I need harass, I have Sona. If I need something in the middle, I have Annie. Most of the time I really don't need his kit. I probably have only played him two or three times since season reset, but I know how to play him if I wanted to.

See the thing is. If you knew how to play Thresh correctly you would be winning games with him.

End of discussion.

disregardable2 votes

"You lost one game with Thresh, therefore your point is invalid"

K then. You know saintvicious lost a game when his Elo was set to 1? The best jungler in the world was literally playing with the lowest ranked players, and yet he lost one game.

arcinex2 votes

[{quoted}](name=The AFK Farmer,realm=NA,application-id=cIfEodbz,discussion-id=xnQAt0mc,comment-id=00000000000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2015-03-30T04:35:40.645+0000)

"You lost one game with Thresh, therefore your point is invalid"

K then. You know saintvicious lost a game when his Elo was set to 1? The best jungler in the world was literally playing with the lowest ranked players, and yet he lost one game.

http://imgur.com/WaJT2Ix

You're point is invalid. I should have clarified that you have lost 80% of your games with Thresh. Not just one. Eighty percent.

Saintvicious is completely irrelevant in this discussion lmao.

You even had a game you went 0-10-1 as a support. A support with 10 deaths and one, ONE assist.

It seems the more a person descends the ladder the more integrity they lose in correlation. As for you, you are already in elo hell and it seems you haven't been able to climb for two seasons.

http://na.op.gg/summoner/userName=the+afk+farmer

Please do yourself a favor and stop shaming yourself and be honest about your lack of skill or you will forever be in bronze.

disregardable1 votes

Not that this has anything to do with the fact that Thresh is 100% easier to win with than Lulu, but LOL, where did you get that statistic? Did you just scroll down to the first Thresh losses you saw and take a picture? GREAT fact-finding there man.

You say that I'm shaming myself while you do THAT. That's honestly hilarious. Like I'm laughing out loud right now. You're so funny.

Tell me, what do you think about foreign policy? "Teach" me, senpai.

ShieldWriter061 votes

In my opinion, both are about equal skill. Thresh and Lulu both have hard decision making. Lulu has to decide who and when to use her abilities, which is actually quite complicated in teamfights until you are halfway done. Thresh is all about plays, and you have to be able to decide whether I should lantern now or later, pop ult to save or flay, or hook this person to save a teammate. Now to the author's question. Thresh is an all around good support, with a little bit of everything. You can only get better at him. If you have a general friendly attitude, okay team communication, and some time, thresh is quite rewarding. Lulu, is a thing on her own. She was supposed to be a support, but her solo lane potential is much higher. With the buffs for her solo lane, they kinda nerfed her support style. She is, in my opinion, a poke oriented laner. I suggest vel'koz for that, even though he is considered mid laner. She is much more complicated than thresh, but much more confusing. TL;DR: Thresh has no skill cap, and is more rewarding, while Lulu has been kinda nerfed out of the support position. If you want poke, go with Vel'koz. Otherwise, get Thresh.

disregardable1 votes

If you only want a support, Thresh is a much more consistent pick. He's does alright in most lanes, he's got some fun mechanics. You feel a little invincible when you play him. Lulu is alright as a support, but her range is short and she's not really tanky. Whimsy isn't really as useful as it sounds, and her harass can be lackluster depending on the lane. But she's really fun top! With a bit of farm, her harass REALLY hurts, and her short range isn't a problem top.

IcyPepper1 votes

Lulu. Thresh has hard engage and a sweet rescue in his lantern, but Lulu can shield (good for early trades), a poke and slow that can be aimed differently if you Pix someone (more range/different angle, it's nice), and whimsy is not too shabby for escapes or foiling ganks.

Her ultimate can be used to clutch a hard engage, and can be used on anyone (even the tank!).

bad arcade kitty1 votes

they are both ugly and with sub 50% winrate

Lost R1 votes

Let's weigh their pros and cons.

Lulu Pros:

  • Lots of utility: Speed boosts, three different slows, two of which can affect multiple targets, a heal, a knock-up, and a shield and damage booster.
  • Excellent poke; one goes through minions and the other is a direct target spell.
  • Tons of crowd control; one is an anti-cloak ability, and the other, at max rank, disables an enemy's attack for three seconds(!).
  • Incredible pushing power.
  • Versatile: Can even function as a powerful ADC, APC or even ASC.
  • A yordle.

Lulu Cons:

  • Extremely squishy: She melts to assassins like butter in Palm Springs.
  • High skill gate: To use her to her fullest extent, you need to really practice with her.

Thresh Pros:

  • Excellent displacer: Can grab both enemies AND allies.
  • Can farm without killing minions
  • A shield
  • Sticks to the enemy like industrial adhesive.
  • High damage output
  • A good tank
  • Combined with a good ADC is TERRIFYING.

Thresh Cons:

  • Average to poor lane clear
  • Relic Shield, despite him being a tank, is a terrible item on him because he can't proc the execute.
  • Very poor early game.
  • High damage requires investing in items that rarely benefit his utility.
  • His anti-escape skills work against him when HE'S trying to escape.
  • GRAB THE LANTERN!
Leblancs Boob1 votes

Thresh is a more reliable support that works well with virtually any team comp. Lulu is I'd say an average support but is more flexible a pick overall as she's an amazingly safe and reliable solo laner.

More from [ARCHIVED] Miscellaneous

More by Aids cuz League