Wow I completely disagree on the farm dependent. He, to me, isn't any more farm dependent than any other champ. I never feel the need to have to farm constant to make him effective. I do play him mid more than anything and I don't recall one time having a major issue due to lower cs. Sure more farm is a good thing but isn't it for most? I think this game became so kit and stat specific that even players can't see outside the box any more.
It isn't so much about thinking outside the box as thinking about what is actually effective.
You can't just say ''X champion has Y attributes that make them good at Z role'' you ALSO have to compare them to their competition. In this case, what does Karthus bring to the table?
Poke : A Sona or Soraka would be better at poking because of their ability to inflict damage as well as restore health. Lux can poke as well as set up her carry nicely for more poke AND shield herself and her ally from enemy poke. Zyra pokes very well too.
Engage : Leona, Braum, Alistar, Morgana, Sona come to mind when thinking of supports that can engage and they outperform Karthus by a very wide margin.
Peeling : Zyra, Morgana, Alistar, Nami all do it way better than Karthus ever will.
Global Presence : That's the one thing Karthus has going for him and although I'm loathe to compare Soraka and Karthus because they do opposite things, from a purely numerical standpoint Soraka outshines Karthus once again (when taking into consideration MR).
So, why pick Karthus support?
I mean I could do the same thing I just did with Morg, but I feel like she has enough scaling to justify funnelling farm into her, whereas Karthus lacks non-scaling and is therefore a poor choice for support.
Also, about Karthus being farm dependant : With a lot of money, Karthus becomes one of the scariest mofos in the game. He's tanky, he can turn invulnerable while still doing damage and once he's finally dead he still deals massive AoE damage. Without money or levels, he's not much of a threat. There's a reason people say Karthus is a shitty laner whose only redeeming quality is his ability to farm from afar.