Skip to content

Possible solution to smurfs

Dom44519··1 votes·575 views

Hello! Many of you know that smurfs are a HUGE part of new players experiences. Imagine this: you are a level 7, adc main. You are kind of getting the hang of basic controls and can competently manage their lane. However, there is someone who everyone around you knows, is a smurf. All people hear is DOUBLE KILL! TRIPLE KILL! QUADRA KILL! PENTA KILL! ... Yeah...

Because of this, people flame at Riot, saying it's their fault and pointing the finger of blame at them. For sensible players, we look at the argument, and say to ourselves,"Hey, how CAN they get rid of smurfs so new players can have a more enjoyable time?". I feel I have the answer to that. What if, all players level 20+, and who decide to make a new account, gets their new account automatically sent to a level higher than where the basic noobs are. This idea could match higher experienced players with players that can sort of manage themselves and hold their ground. It could be hard, what with how the new account can decide who the previous account was. ot probably will make the most sense to see who the person who logged in the most times on the client/boards, the future system would be able to set what the level is so the smurf wannabe can't LOL-ROFL-SMASH-NEWBS-GT-RKT the beginners. I hope that this idea could possible come into the attention of people so new players experience won't be ruined by a level 30 Diamond I.

13 Comments

Shahamut2 votes

This system would not be able to be regulated.

The big problem with ANY "solutions" to smurfs is that there is no realistic way to know that someone is in fact smurfing. Simple as that.

Im sure RIOT wants to find a solution, but Im sure they also realize that there is no way that they could honestly prove that account A is definitely a smurf for account B.

I feel for ya, smurfs are a pain when you are new, especially the ones who get all indignant and rude. Maybe one day we will be able to find a solution... but for now I doubt it.

Eleshakai1 votes

LoL Korea has basically the only solution: Identity verification.

In Korea you have to use your ID(KSSN) to create a LoL account so unless you have friends who don't ever plan on playing, you can only get one account...

Sadly, in North America, that won't work due to certain legalities.

b1TLHaKERl1 votes

{quoted}

LoL Korea has basically the only solution: Identity verification.

In Korea you have to use your ID(KSSN) to create a LoL account so unless you have friends who don't ever plan on playing, you can only get one account...

Sadly, in North America, that won't work due to certain legalities.

Luckily*, in the United States, we have the Constitution and consumer protection laws. Fixed it for you.

Eleshakai1 votes

{quoted}

Luckily*, in the United States, we have the Constitution and consumer protection laws. Fixed it for you.

You can look at it how you wish, but I'd prefer if they were able to use IDs to determine the player. Permabans would actually be perma, no more smurfs, a much more stable playing field, people having to take responsibility for their actions...

It'd make the game a better place. But sadly, outdated laws that haven't been updated or modernized in 30 years and aren't really relevent in this digital age aren't being updated as fast as they should be due to politicians who have no understanding of the current landscape being locked in power(and this applies to both the US and Canada) and thus not being able to improve matters.

b1TLHaKERl1 votes

If you love communist policies so much, then why don't you move there? Oh the hypocrisy. You're wrong, you're ignorant, and you do not have a point. There's nothing "modern" about forcing people to hand over their social security numbers to play a video game, do you even read what you write? Since you're so adamant about true perma ban, why don't you volunteer to be the first one? You're a fool, you'd be crying a river the size of California if you ended up getting permabanned, yet you're advocating for it now? Pure idiocy. Stay out of politics, never talk again.

Eleshakai1 votes

{quoted}

If you love communist policies so much, then why don't you move there? Oh the hypocrisy. You're wrong, you're ignorant, and you do not have a point. There's nothing "modern" about forcing people to hand over their social security numbers to play a video game, do you even read what you write? Since you're so adamant about true perma ban, why don't you volunteer to be the first one? You're a fool, you'd be crying a river the size of California if you ended up getting permabanned, yet you're advocating for it now? Pure idiocy. Stay out of politics, never talk again.

Um.... South Korea isn't communist. So perhaps you should fact check before you start speaking of politics.

And yes, there is something modern about making people have a persistent identity online. In fact, that is the most progressive idea I've ever heard. It makes what happens online 'real' by forcing real consequences on it and associating a real identity with it. It's a great idea if you're not planning to troll.

Now judging by the other threads you're posting, I imagine trolling is kinda your thing... so I guess it makes sense that you'd be against the concept of a true permaban. But if you really think about it... if Riot HAD the ability to truly permanently ban a person, they could make meaningful punishments out of temporary bans. a 1 week, 1 month, or 1 year ban would become a REAL punishment for someone who loves the game... so people would be less likely to troll others. But I'm not afraid of being permanently banned. I haven't received any sort of punishment in any online video game I've played in the past... 7 years... ever since I grew up and stopped being a spoiled brat. And even that last punishment was only a 3 day suspension in WoW, and I absolutely deserved it.

It's a very progressive and very modern idea... whether it's good is kind of hard to say. There are pros and cons. I mentioned some of the pros above, but others include easier account recovery - since all you'd have to do is provide your SIN/SSN to verify your identity for them to return your account to you...

As far as cons go... they'd have to be a LOT more sure about punishments to avoid false positives which would absolutely slow down the process, and putting a SIN/SSN in more places online would increase the fear of identity theft....

Personally, I feel the pros outweigh the cons... but its up to each of us to determine how we feel on the subject.

But I doubt you'll read this, you'll probably read the first 3-4 words and then form some trolling reply and probably call me a 'kid' since calling people a 'kid' is kind of your thing.

b1TLHaKERl1 votes

I'm flattered that you're that butt-hurt from the other thread that you came over to this one to try and prove your worth.

No it's not progressive to force people to hand over their social security number for a video game, it's controlling and a violation of consumer protection laws, then again, you're the controlling type to be advocating massive ban waves for trivial arguments in the first place, so no surprise there. The reality is, you're part of the problem. Luckily Lyte has indicated a shift in policy lately, despite you desperately clinging to bans, Lyte recently posted that massive ban waves actually hurt the community and there are better solutions such as chat restriction and low priority queue. Oh, but your argument is all that matters, keep pretending I guess. ;) Fizz

Eleshakai1 votes

{quoted}

I'm flattered that you're that butt-hurt from the other thread that you came over to this one to try and prove your worth.

No it's not progressive to force people to hand over their social security number for a video game, not much more to be said there, your entire post is one big filler once again.

Ah the fallbacks of those whose arguments have no legs remaining to stand on.

Twisting facts: I was in the thread before you so I didn't 'come here to prove anything' Ignoring the content and being dismissive: "Your post is one big filler" Insults: "You're that butt-hurt"

And no actual points.

Yes, it is progressive. Progressive implies forward thinking and recognizing of a modern environment... forcing a person to maintain a permanent identity on the internet is a VERY progressive idea. Whether it's a good idea can be debated absolutely... but it is ABSOLUTELY a forward thinking and technologically aware idea. That's not even something that can be argued.

b1TLHaKERl2 votes

Your post implies we don't have social security numbers in the U.S., we do, we just don't force people to hand them over for trivial things such as video games, because it's sensitive information, that is forward thinking, not asking people to hand over sensitive information for every little thing. Oh I forgot, your argument is all that matters. Keep pretending. ;)

Eleshakai1 votes

{quoted}

Your post implies we don't have social security numbers in the U.S., we do, we just don't force people to hand them over for trivial things such as video games, because it's sensitive information, that is forward thinking, not asking people to hand over sensitive information for every little thing. Oh I forgot, your argument is all that matters. Keep pretending. ;)

.... I never implied that. You're just too stupid to understand what I'm actually posting...

You have no understanding of the definition of the words you use... 'the way things have been for decades' isn't forward thinking. It might be successful and the best way to do things, in some vcases... but it isn't 'forward thinking'.

b1TLHaKERl1 votes

You mentioning that they have SSN and that it's forward thinking to provide that information is implying that we don't have SSN, we do. Again, it's not forward thinking at all to hand over your most sensitive information for a free-to-play video game.

The reason you don't understand is because you've given away the fact that you're too young to have even used your social security number for anything yet. Let me tell you kiddo, SSN in the wrong hands can ruin your life. Do you really want to be handing out your most sensitive information for a free-to-play video game? Obviously you don't comprehend that point, but you'll assume for the sake of your argument. ;) Fizz

Eleshakai1 votes

{quoted}

You mentioning that they have SSN and that it's forward thinking to provide that information is implying that we don't have SSN, we do. Again, it's not forward thinking at all to hand over your most sensitive information for a free-to-play video game.

The reason you don't understand is because you've given away the fact that you're too young to have even used your social security number for anything yet. Let me tell you kiddo, SSN in the wrong hands can ruin your life. Do you really want to be handing out your most sensitive information for a free-to-play video game? Obviously you don't comprehend that point, but you'll assume for the sake of your argument. ;) Fizz

No it's not... I mentioned that using it as an online ID is progressive. Because it is. EVERY country has some form of social ID because it makes more sense to register people as a number than a name since the numbers are unique while names usually aren't.

It's absolutely forward thinking to use the only piece of unique ID as a method of identifying people to ensure they have a persistent online ID of some variety. Whether it is a GOOD idea can be debated... but it is forward thinking. The two ARE different. Forward thinking and 'good' are not mutually inclusive... and if you'd actually read my earlier posts I even STATED that the increased threat of identity theft is a negative of this type of thing. But you don't actually READ the posts you reply to, as I mentioned above, so I didn't really expect you to.

b1TLHaKERl1 votes

{quoted}

Hello! Many of you know that smurfs are a HUGE part of new players experiences. Imagine this: you are a level 7, adc main. You are kind of getting the hang of basic controls and can competently manage their lane. However, there is someone who everyone around you knows, is a smurf. All people hear is DOUBLE KILL! TRIPLE KILL! QUADRA KILL! PENTA KILL! ... Yeah...

Because of this, people flame at Riot, saying it's their fault and pointing the finger of blame at them. For sensible players, we look at the argument, and say to ourselves,"Hey, how CAN they get rid of smurfs so new players can have a more enjoyable time?". I feel I have the answer to that. What if, all players level 20+, and who decide to make a new account, gets their new account automatically sent to a level higher than where the basic noobs are. This idea could match higher experienced players with players that can sort of manage themselves and hold their ground. It could be hard, what with how the new account can decide who the previous account was. ot probably will make the most sense to see who the person who logged in the most times on the client/boards, the future system would be able to set what the level is so the smurf wannabe can't LOL-ROFL-SMASH-NEWBS-GT-RKT the beginners. I hope that this idea could possible come into the attention of people so new players experience won't be ruined by a level 30 Diamond I.

There are smurfs because people get banned, so they make a smurf account. Want less smurfs? Ban less people, use chat restrictions instead of banning people for trivial arguments, as we can see, it hasn't worked.

More from [ARCHIVED] Miscellaneous

More by Dom44519