Personally I feel like Renekton right now is "ok"
Pros
He is very aggressive in lane and can bully the other lanes. No mana pool so can stay in lane if you have sustain for hp for items. Can 1v1 just about anyone.
Cons
Falls off HARD in my mind he isn't as tanky as other tops as the game goes on, and unless you have
for dmg by 25-30mins becomes useless.
The reason is when the game goes to the 25-30 mins the Hydra is good for split pushing but when the enemy team is grouped and doesn't care as the enemy Tank
they can just win a 4v5. Unless you can take down 2-3 towers at top while split pushing its a lost cause.
Most players know that
falls off Hard unless he has 3-4 items, so at top the enemy will just play safe and you will have to choose between diving them or just wait as the game goes on longer and longer = you becoming more and more uselss.
Jungle
is a mix bag for me as Jungling Renekton will delay your build as stated before even with core items he falls off so imagine jungle Renketon with less of those items. If you miss your W and Gap closer E the gank will be an epic Fail.
He is ok at objectives like Dragons and Barons and can be a terror if encountered in the river.
But Overall I would give a Renekton a 6.5 out of 10 (MY OPINION) as of right now.
Nice post and Have a Good One!