Garen Plz
After around 500+ games with Garen, These are my thoughts
Why are some champs so bad? Garen makes no sense to me...all his abilities scale from AD and his e from Crit... Ok, so if you build damage/crit you can farm a bit but you die in 3 hits from like anyone and without a real engage you cant get to someone and kill them.
But then you have his passive that benefits from HP/Spirit Visage. So i build tank, i cant farm worth a poop and its really hard to kill me with "w" active but without any CC or Real engage he just becomes a wall, upon which everyone punches to death
Oh i can jungle with him? Hes super duper slow and how do you itemize him?
But the best part is his R. Yes it CAN hit hard but its magic damage (It really needs to be true damage) and really never does much than killing a mage/adc is your lucky. IF.
Most of the time ill build him tanky so i don't die and can do something for the team but what always happens is a fight breaks out and by the end its me alive vs enemy team....
He fits no role at all, and how his abilities scale you cant even use half of them either way you build..... If hes is going to fit a tank-ish role His Q is fine His W is fine His E Needs to scale differently OR add a slow effect to affected enemies for some CC that be desperately needs His R needs to be True damage flat and magic bonus so he can actually kill low HP ADC/Mages (as of now they literally need to be lower than 250HP to die it seems) His Passive is Fine
If he wants to Fit a damage role.
No, just no nothing makes sense for him to deal damage without a complete overhaul.
Can the man get something done about him, he does not need to be meta but at least can he playable......he isn't even playable. I've never seen him used in Pro games and i think i've seen him maybe 5 times on various streams and i'm sure most of those were ARAM
All IMHO

and have fun with the rest of your build because just by standing there you will see your health rise and you can hop back in to the fight. for being a no mana champion, he's really mean top laner. just by some armor and a stack of health pots and just stand in lane. he's just ridiculous if you ask me
Pick one or even two of these three. Then grab whatever boots you want.
Fill out the rest of your build with these and watch the enemies cry because the moment you get in range they are boned.