One of your bronze teammates is 1 win away from promoting to silver. more or less seems like its fair for him to be in a s4 game.
But
One of your bronze teammates is indeed a weak player. Looks like complete deadweight for his teams in his current MMR this season due and I expect they will keep losing until they are low bronze or high Iron.
That players starting point is not in bronze thou, I expect they had a silver MMR because of the soft reset, having been silver 3 and 80ish LP last year. They have some champions they can play decently enough to not be losing teammates a majority of games but the dudes not playing them. Not good enough to climb but enough to not cripple their team like they are right now by maining champions they underperform on constantly.
So it looks like the opposite. he was not in that game because he is climbing the ladder but because he is actively sinking from his prior season.
Also... its harder compared to other years to try and grade skill comparing last season and the current one because Riot made changes to the Tiers and Ranked system this season which kind of fked everything up. Now its my opinion that they downgraded the ladder by overlapping old tiers with new ones. Theres 27 options for a "title" starting at B5. This year there is also 27 options for a Title. Starting at I4. A title is rank and division, its got zero meaning until its accurate off enough points of data but overall the entire LP systems a distraction to make players engage in the game more and feel better about the rating system.
Part of Elo and MMR systems is they expect to be wrong. There is no way around this. It requires data so low # games on an account mean it is basically just in a calibration period where you see the results from it vs your average players and move them around in response. Thing is... still the best system because its objective and will properly sort players by skill. The reason its solid is its dam hard to manipulate. The benefit for players is that it will Always aim to self correct so if you get better your raiting improves. If you get worse it goes down... and in a game like league with constant patches and balance adjustment. Some times a player gets worse, not because their skill dropped but their champions power has decreased. Or been removed completely from the game via a rework and they now have to learn a new kit that they might not be any good at. Why I don't recommend being an OTP, better to be able to adapt.
There's going to be some awful one sided games. Players need to not use Titles to gauge skill because its not inherently going to provide good expectations for a match. To be blunt...Its pretty fucking frustrating when you get back to back garbage allies. But that RNG luck is never going to cripple any ones ability to climb because the odds are skewed to favor you to win form mismatched baddies then lose. 9 other players. 4 slots for your team 5 for the enemy RNG distribution will put baddies on the other side more often.
Its difficult to remove yourself from the equation some times. I want to ask you if it would it really be a fair system if it only put you vs a lane that's equal or superior to you? Is it fair your opponent only have to vs some one equal or weaker then them? What impact should that make on teammates and how should it be sorted? Which players deserve to only get equal or weaker enemy's and what ones need to fight equal or stronger?
Imo,it needs to be universal for all players to be fair and that means not giving a dam about any individuals experience. Blatant manipulation of MM is never going to be healthy imo. RNG is frustrating but it is fair, just ask Thanatos.
I am a huge nerd, I really like Arpad Elo's Elo system and all its MMR derivatives thou I don't always like Devs implementations of it. (Riot's Duoing is something I hate.) They are made of probability theory and self correction which are things I find awesome. I have Tried to not go off to much on the topic because my post tends to be about double the length of this wall when I do.
Feel free to hit me up if you wanna learn more about them. Or alternatively if you just wanna chat about playing league and are looking for help improving. Id say add me but we are not on the same server. Your
looks solid btw.
Please feel free to box quote anything I said you need clarity on or you disagree with then show your logic. I can/have be/been wrong and enjoy the opportunity to adjust my viewpoint.
TLDR. One players making bad calls on their picks and losing hella. Had a higher starting MMR. The other looks to have started off badly, but has a low # of games and is currently correcting their start and closing the MMR deficit they have. Neither has enough games for me to treat their current division or rank as accurate.