Skip to content

Lux's W shielding her instantly is okay in my opinion.

LordPoutine··48 votes·8,489 views

But please, don't go through those E buffs

She'll be WAY too oppressive with it, as any good Lux player will always land it correctly (even now, it's almost impossible to dodge, unless you got mobility)

Give her something if you want, like a small mana regen buff or something, but please, don't go through with that Lux E change.

111 Comments

Cindikle26 votes

The E change is to make her not so ping dependent.

If it really becomes a problem we'll probably see a small damage drop off at the edges.

RiotMeddler39 votes

{quoted}

The E change is to make her not so ping dependent.

If it really becomes a problem we'll probably see a small damage drop off at the edges.

The ping dependency change here is the big one. At present players on extremely low ping have a really reliable detonation already. Those on moderate to high pings however aren't able to pull off those same plays where the E detonates almost instantly after landing. Higher ping's already a significant disadvantage, so we'd like to diminish any unneeded costs where we can.

It is possible this will make Lux's E too reliable, since there'll be a bit of benefit here even for players with no significant ping at all. If so we'd probably look at reducing the explosion radius a bit as a result to restore the spell to its previous best case reliability profile.

LordPoutine1 votes

{quoted}

The ping dependency change here is the big one. At present players on extremely low ping have a really reliable detonation already. Those on moderate to high pings however aren't able to pull off those same plays where the E detonates almost instantly after landing. Higher ping's already a significant disadvantage, so we'd like to diminish any unneeded costs where we can.

It is possible this will make Lux's E too reliable, since there'll be a bit of benefit here even for players with no significant ping at all. If so we'd probably look at reducing the explosion radius a bit as a result to restore the spell to its previous best case reliability profile.

Why don't you increase the missile speed then?

That would make it more reliable for high pings players too, but you'll still have time to react with the short cast time.

darkdill2 votes

Then what happens when you use your E at close range and have bad ping?

Cindikle20 votes

Because that gives power to those with a good ping more than those with bad. This E change gives more power to high ping. And mostly a QoL buff to those with low ping.

If you consider it to be a pain to avoid now why would you want it faster in general anyway?

MacDthree1 votes

I'm still not sure why somebody elses shitty ping needs to effect the balance of a champ when I have perfect ping. There are so many other things we could have worked on with her. Fixing her for people that run Youtube + Netflix in the background on their toasters was not my concern really.

Cindikle1 votes

It's more of a QoL buff than a full on buff. It makes her smoother to play for high ping and a little less frustrating for a low ping player.

We're not going to see her win rate jump 5% because of this. If we do it's because a lot of high ping players pick her up because they can actually play her now.

Penguin Eclipse1 votes

{quoted}

It's more of a QoL buff than a full on buff. It makes her smoother to play for high ping and a little less frustrating for a low ping player.

We're not going to see her win rate jump 5% because of this. If we do it's because a lot of high ping players pick her up because they can actually play her now.

They could actually play her before. Most the ones complaining just think they can't because they're bad.

Akali is SO HOT2 votes

{quoted}

The ping dependency change here is the big one. At present players on extremely low ping have a really reliable detonation already. Those on moderate to high pings however aren't able to pull off those same plays where the E detonates almost instantly after landing. Higher ping's already a significant disadvantage, so we'd like to diminish any unneeded costs where we can.

It is possible this will make Lux's E too reliable, since there'll be a bit of benefit here even for players with no significant ping at all. If so we'd probably look at reducing the explosion radius a bit as a result to restore the spell to its previous best case reliability profile.

Or you could make an East Coast server so people don't have higher pings and you won't have to make these changes to any champions ever again.

Llanite2 votes

There are players from South America, Europe and Asia in NA server as well.

Same argument can be made with every server.

ChargeItDownMid1 votes

[deleted]

Llanite1 votes

SE uses a VLAN server which doesn't let them migrate anywhere, lots of SE players are still in NA, despite the high pings.

Sometimes people will stay and tolerate the pings, simply because their friends/team are NA, sometimes they like to play in English, not their local tongue.

Even if you are American playing in NA, weak internet is everywhere, in dorm/ campus/ hotels for instance.

More server is always better, but they are just band-aid, an expensive one at that.

Penguin Eclipse4 votes

{quoted}

The ping dependency change here is the big one. At present players on extremely low ping have a really reliable detonation already. Those on moderate to high pings however aren't able to pull off those same plays where the E detonates almost instantly after landing. Higher ping's already a significant disadvantage, so we'd like to diminish any unneeded costs where we can.

It is possible this will make Lux's E too reliable, since there'll be a bit of benefit here even for players with no significant ping at all. If so we'd probably look at reducing the explosion radius a bit as a result to restore the spell to its previous best case reliability profile.

Why not just add a small delay with the changes? Her reliability would be fixed and she wouldn't be oppressive for those with a low ping. Seems kinda silly to buff her and then nerf something else on her kit that isn't a problem. I'd much rather she just be left alone if that is going to be the case.

Especially since this change will be a huge buff for those with super low pings. Specifically, a competitive LAN environment. Seems like the writing is already on the wall if a simple delay is not added. I don't think a change in the explosion radius is going to make much of a difference in the competitive environment either. A delay will.

TheJinxedOne3 votes

uk, in my opinion, fixing ping is a way more reliable solution :P

GloriousKaiser3 votes

You're kind of scaring me with this. Balancing around players ping?. Maybe fix the east cost players ping? It's not like they all have bad internet. If what I'm getting at is true, the idea that east cost really does have bad ping and it's region wide overall, then you shouldn't have to balance the game around people's quality of internet. You should fix that.

MacDthree3 votes

glad I'm not the only one upset by this.

Pinkie2 votes

Delaying the explosion to .05 seconds after landing would keep the spell just as reliable as it is now for low-ping players. Nerfing the radius would have a negative effect on Lux's waveclear.

Mandang02 votes

Instead of decreasing the AOE (and with it, the upside for placing your Q optimally), why not decrease the missile speed to compensate for the instant detonation? That seems a much more direct way to compensate for a change that makes landing the skill perhaps too reliable.

Lüc3 votes

The W change is most welcome and now seems more in line with most shields.

If her E becomes too reliable why not give it the full Gragas treatment? i.e. increasing in damage as it charges to its full duration. You would lower the immediate burst power and perhaps have the fully charged version be a bit stronger than it is on live, which would relieve it's (potential) reliability issue by decreasing its poke power and solve the issue of Lux missing ~10 damage from reliable waveclear.

A radius reduction would not just nerf her poke reliabilty, it would severely hurt her waveclear. Both of which she's not too stellar at currently. If the above change isn't viable then I'd say look at the visibility of her particles next.

Rinky Dinky16 votes

The e buffs are fine holy shit

Riot said they were planning to do this.

Everyone said ok great.

Now people are crying about it.

This is why riot tends to not listen to the forums

Quality Content14 votes

[{quoted}](name=Lane Cancer,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=EKVduWen,comment-id=0003,timestamp=2015-06-12T01:20:23.709+0000)

The e buffs are fine holy shit

Riot said they were planning to do this.

Everyone said ok great.

Now people are crying about it.

This is why riot tends to not listen to the forums

The people that said yes to it were Lux players, who would be naturally biased towards the change.

Zenthon Prime6 votes

I specifically remember many non-Lux players coming out of the woodworks for that discussion, and they all said yes too. That includes me.

But seriously, all this is actually going to do is make East Coast Luxs play like West Coast ones. If you have lower than 70 ping the difference will be next to nonexistent. I have around 60 ping and I never see the circle when I detonate it, and I am by no means good at Lux (I play her once every few weeks or so in normals). The W change will actually do something, but still very little.

Borbland2 votes

I'm a big Lux player by myself, and I think she's fine already. And she will be fine after those changes, it's ofc a small buff, but it's mostly a QoL change. E was nearly impossible to miss before anyway, and the shield was extremly clunky before.

PlsTouchMeGently9 votes

The hell man? This buff is really needed for those of us who have pings in the 70-90's. And it already has a huge mana cost. I honestly cannot believe someone is complaining about Lux buffs. Just goes to show people will complain about absolutely any change.

Penguin Eclipse2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Sang Noir,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=EKVduWen,comment-id=0007,timestamp=2015-06-12T03:30:01.411+0000)

The hell man? This buff is really needed for those of us who have pings in the 70-90's. And it already has a huge mana cost. I honestly cannot believe someone is complaining about Lux buffs. Just goes to show people will complain about absolutely any change.

Honestly, it's not. I have a ping in that range. Reactivating E is a non-issue.

Changes are hardly ever reverted. If someone has concerns about the changes now is the time to voice them. Because once she is buffed if she does become OP or FotM, she will get nerfed. And it likely won't just be nerfs to counter what they buffed. Something else and potentially very damaging.

Akali is SO HOT1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Sang Noir,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=EKVduWen,comment-id=0007,timestamp=2015-06-12T03:30:01.411+0000)

The hell man? This buff is really needed for those of us who have pings in the 70-90's. And it already has a huge mana cost. I honestly cannot believe someone is complaining about Lux buffs. Just goes to show people will complain about absolutely any change.

How the hell do you have trouble landing skillshots with 70 ping???????????????????????????????? That's low as fuck for this game. I have an average of 110-150 and I can land Lux's E really easily.

darkdill1 votes

It's not so much a case of landing a hit at long range as much as it's a case of being too late to detonate it at CLOSE range. Oftentimes, that little detonation delay can cause you to die because an assassin beat you to the punch.

Borbland9 votes

As a big big Lux player, this wont change much.

You can hit it with 95% accuracy already, now you get 99%, not a big deal. It makes her less clunky, it's more a QoL then a real buff.

And for the shield, I dont understand, Lux already gains a shield direcly after the short delay. Does that mean that the delay is removed, or that the shield is applied directly at the cast and then comes th delay ? The first one is too powerful, so I guess it's the second one, that will be very useful against assassins

darkdill5 votes

It's the second one. There's been a lot of cases where you cast her W, but die to something before you get any shield. That just sucks.

OverpoweredSoap7 votes

She's not getting her mana cost on her E lowered because of it.

So IF it does become too strong, they could take away the pre-cast and lower the mana cost of her E.

I say we see how it works for like a patch or two and see if it really is going to be that oppressive, and if it is, just do the above.

Silents4295 votes

They said no to lowering it's mana cost. And choose to make it pre detonate.

Edge of Daybreak4 votes

Having seen a rioter comment on ping it makes me wonder if at their offices does talking about giving the East coast their own servers so we wouldn't need changes like this gets you fired instantly. I'm pretty sure it's a yes but I'm still curious.

lDontLiftIcarry1 votes

they will NEVER add east coast servers but they'll never say that publicly because of the backlash they'd get from us east coasters. Been on lan since its release. Fuck NA servers lol

Lord Dusteon5 votes

{quoted}

they will NEVER add east coast servers but they'll never say that publicly because of the backlash they'd get from us east coasters. Been on lan since its release. Fuck NA servers lol

"they will NEVER add east coast servers"

Said as they are literally moving their servers to the middle of the country so everyone has mostly equal ping.

lDontLiftIcarry1 votes

keep TELLING yourself lies. lol. There is nowhere in riots history saying they are going to pick up theifr fucking company and move it around the USA. NOWHERE have they stated this. NOWHERE.

Lord Dusteon4 votes

{quoted}

keep TELLING yourself lies. lol. There is nowhere in riots history saying they are going to pick up theifr fucking company and move it around the USA. NOWHERE have they stated this. NOWHERE.

http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/help-support/Ffh2dJXf-na-server-roadmap-update-south-bridge-pt-2-isp-peering

If you don't want to check the link, here's the basic parts.

"Aside from that, the next NA Server Roadmap update will focus on Phase 3 of the plan: a centralized server move. In that post we plan to cover details of this centralized move with dates, locations, and expected impact. Stay tuned!"

"Yes -- Phase 3 (the centralized server move) will happen this year. The next update you'll see from the NA Server Roadmap team will contain information and details around it."

lDontLiftIcarry1 votes

uhuh more like "we're making it so ISP's stop throttling us because we use up so much of the internet and if they throttle us we have to pay them so they earn a pretty penny forcing us to pay them and we're finally paying them"

and then "yeah we'll soon"TM" that server move.

yep. Soon TM. rofl.

Just like they'll balance mobility creep after 3+ years of this shit.

soonTM.

Lord Dusteon2 votes

{quoted}

uhuh more like "we're making it so ISP's stop throttling us because we use up so much of the internet and if they throttle us we have to pay them so they earn a pretty penny forcing us to pay them and we're finally paying them"

and then "yeah we'll soon"TM" that server move.

yep. Soon TM. rofl.

Just like they'll balance mobility creep after 3+ years of this shit.

soonTM.

So your reaction to a Red post SPECIFICALLY stating the server move will happen before the end of 2015...is to mock it and say it won't happen.

In that case, who cares about reading the red posts? After all, apparently you can ignore any progress with a jaunty and sarcastic mocking instead of actually believing the people who know what they are doing.

Also, if you actually read any of the post you would have seen that they are basically building their own route for League data to go on, and are partnering with ISP's so that the ISP's reroute data to the League nodes instead of their normal, longer route.

lDontLiftIcarry1 votes

2010/2009 beta there's always issues with beta and lag and such and stress tests and blah blah blah, can't complain too much. 2011 the game wasn't that filled up but there still was some random attempting to reconnect issues going around 2012 the game was starting(but not really) to get overloaded on players and the packet loss and lag/high ping in general was getting a bit out of hand at some points during peak teams during the higher traffic times of the year (summer when kids are on etc you know.. weekends...holidays... the time when a lot of people log on obviously) 2013 it was said they were working on it, still laggy obviously and at some points unplayable. 2014 we lagged all year still high ping on top of packet loss being so bad at some points that entire ISP's were throttling league of legends. We all know comcast issues STILL exist with league in some areas of the US. And that one other company thats located on the western side of the USA.. think it starts with C or a W for its name.. if I saw it on a list i'd point it out to you. 2015 it finally somewhat improved on NA around feburary. I obviously check the servers on NA just to see the lag every week or so and see how it feels to play. I own a diamond NA account that I switched to LAN recently to have 2 LAN accounts just because I wanted both on diamond cause why the fuck not. Got sick of packet loss being terrible. At least if I lag in florida, miama server my ping is STILL better than NA server.

for 3+ years we got the "soon tm" treatment. Words mean nothing to me. Actions speak louder than words. as soon as you visually feel improvement and less packet loss on a daily basis then theres something real to go off of.

I don't like being bullshitted.

Not going to argue, you obviously believe what anyone tells you.

Lord Dusteon2 votes

{quoted}

I don't like being bullshitted.

Not going to argue, you obviously believe what anyone tells you.

If I did that I would believe the lore retcon was doing good, that lore actually would show up in the client in some form, or that the short bios they wrote really were just short bios and not their entire lore.

No, I tend to doubt most things. When my ping has steadily gotten better and I've had much less instances of freezing? When Riot keeps us up to date on what they are doing and provide a VERY definite point and time? I believe that.

Penguin Eclipse3 votes

{quoted}

uhuh more like "we're making it so ISP's stop throttling us because we use up so much of the internet and if they throttle us we have to pay them so they earn a pretty penny forcing us to pay them and we're finally paying them"

and then "yeah we'll soon"TM" that server move.

yep. Soon TM. rofl.

Just like they'll balance mobility creep after 3+ years of this shit.

soonTM.

Spreading misinformation for a topic you clearly do not understand does not help anything.

lDontLiftIcarry1 votes

Been playing since season 1, pretty sure I know about this topic more than anyone on these boards unless they're a closed beta black alistar owning veteran as well. In which case, by all means.

tell me all about how this game never lagged and we weren't given the go around with SOON(TM) for improvements/usa east servers since the beginning of league.

I'd love to be proven wrong with real facts and logical information instead of some words on a fucking thread :D!

Penguin Eclipse3 votes

{quoted}

Been playing since season 1, pretty sure I know about this topic more than anyone on these boards unless they're a closed beta black alistar owning veteran as well. In which case, by all means.

tell me all about how this game never lagged and we weren't given the go around with SOON(TM) for improvements/usa east servers since the beginning of league.

Simply by mentioning the word "throttling" you proved you have no idea what you are talking about.

lDontLiftIcarry1 votes

And yet you provide no real rebuttle outside of saying I'm wrong. This conversation has bored me.

Gonna go play on a server that doesn't drop more packets than a drunk UPS driver.

Penguin Eclipse2 votes

{quoted}

And yet you provide no real rebuttle outside of saying I'm wrong. This conversation has bored me.

Gonna go play on a server that doesn't drop more packets than a drunk UPS driver.

Well I could say throttling didn't happen. Because it didn't. But the fact that you brought it up means you will obviously not believe me because you are just like all the other internet trolls that litter the internet boards. You probably read an opinion/editorial article on some tech news site about how ISPs are doing all these evil things. But you don't actually understand what these alleged things are. And because of that you don't actually know if they are happening or not. But none the less you are an expert on it. Just ask you.

Minrog1 votes

Some ISPs do throttle traffic. They specifically target traffic that comes from companies that provide services that rival their own services (think Comcast and Time Warner throttling anything related to online TV/music). They also charge inflated rates for co-location of servers if those servers would make a rival service more appealing than their own. Not all ISPs do this, though, only the ones that have been propped up in their government sponsored monopolies for years with little to no oversight on their activities.

As for the original trollness, yes it sounds like Riot is co-locating servers across a bunch of ISPs. It should make the ping times very fast for everyone, since the receipt of the data packets will be sub-10 ms (however long it takes to get to your ISP's data center) and the servers won't be bottlenecked on their client side communications anymore.

Caeler2 votes

Why are people even trying to get Lux buffs anyways? She's pretty much one of the safest midlaners, has long range, can zone well, has a good amount of cc and zoning ability, and has pretty good damage. She also has clearly identifiable weaknesses such as lack of mobility, high cooldowns, and high mana costs. According to champion.gg shes sitting at a 50.01% winrate, which seems to indicate she's pretty balanced. It also states she's in the upper half rankings for mid lane, which further suggests she doesn't need any buffs. What's the deal?

NorthernDruid4 votes
  1. She's no real waveclear so it's easy to percieve her as weak. Also the one ability in her kit which is the main spell for both farm and poke also has prohibitively high mana costs (30 higher than the standard for ultimates at max rank).

  2. Her comboing is clunky since it involves hitting multiple skillshots and interleaving autoattacks. Her AA range also forces her to make good use of that shield to survive.

Hence why people are constantly asking for mana cost reductions on her E. Because it's the clunkiest part of her kit, and because she sticks out among similar mages (like Orianna or Syndra) as not being able to clear the caster minions in one combination of ability use (on top of that her E costs about the same amount of mana as most similar combos, but unlike such combos (Orianna's Q+W, Syndra's Q+W, Morgana's W) fails to clear the caster minions most of the time, even with proccing her passive afterwards). Her E also doesn't carry all that much damage by itself, because while it deals a lot of damage Lux has a lot of her damage bound up in her passive, which she can't proc at E-poke range.

Overall she's probably quite balanced, her ult is fairly strong, her combo is pretty damn great when she can get it off, and she is a combo mage with an AoE shield which refreshes itself slightly after cast.


Asking for these kinds of relatively minor, mostly QoL, buffs impacting mostly her clunkiness is much more sensible than asking for real buffs (like more dmg vs minions on her E, or longer attack range to proc her passive better, or lower mana cost on her E which can't even clear caster minions).

And buffs which increase playability and clarity of play are more important to get out there than straight up balance issues.

I don't care if pre-detonating her E makes her OP, or if her shield coming up slightly earlier makes her nearly unkillable. Because at least as a player it's easier to know when your abilities go off.


This was supposed to be a short reply ;_;

Caeler1 votes

Thanks for the explanation. I'm all for QoL buffs, but I've seen several suggestions that are just straight buffs.

More from Gameplay

More by LordPoutine