Skip to content

So Knights Vow...... Explain.

xXZiluenXx··2 votes·7,418 views

so explain to me how Knight's Vow, an item that is meant to mitigate damage from one single targeted ally until used on another ally is anywhere remotely good, i mean sure the health, armor and max health regen is ok and the extra armor and movement speed when moving towards them is alright, but nothing good enough to be really better then mediocre, and the thing that is holding it back is the 12%true damage you take out of the damage your partnered ally takes is the thing that makes it bad.

Sure your partner,(when close enough), can heal you for 12% of the damage they do but if you compare that with the true damage your taking its not even healing half that damage at all.

From all the playing i have done with it, i have noticed that in order for it to be effective, Knight's Vow needs to be the first item you build if your support even over a sightstone or your support item and you need to be ahead of the opposing bot lane to have any impact with it.

redemption is a much better item for support in everyway since you get mana regen instead of armor and an active heal/true damage ability that even works when dead.

i can kinda see how Knight's Vow would be useful on some top laners for early game plays to try and get snowballed using it on other players for bug plays, but how would it be anywhere useful in the late game since the true damage would be the thing that would stop any tank from pushin with 10 fully built players at level 18.

honestly i think Knight's Vow should be taken back to the drawing board, since its a worse version of bond of stone,(you know that keystone mastery).

62 Comments

ph1234k5 votes

Worse version of bond of stone? How? It offshoots more damage and actually heals you depending on the partnered damage.

Also, it isn't true damage. You just aren't allowed to apply resistances twice.

xXZiluenXx2 votes

{quoted}

Worse version of bond of stone? How? It offshoots more damage and actually heals you depending on the partnered damage.

Also, it isn't true damage. You just aren't allowed to apply resistances twice.

actually it is true damage, re-read it i had to and found out that it was, and it deffintily is a worse version of bond of stone, even though it heals as well as redirecting damage it is no where near as mush as you think it is, seriously knight's vow isnt even good at all

TehNACHO4 votes

No, you're still misunderstanding.

The true damage dealt to you is equal to the damage your carry took after their resistances. It's to avoid double dipping in armor values, not to increase damage dealt to you.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

No, you're still misunderstanding.

The true damage dealt to you is equal to the damage your carry took after their resistances. It's to avoid double dipping in armor values, not to increase damage dealt to you.

actually to contradict you 12% healing does not equal 12% true damage even if it was reduced first, your still taking 8 % give or take worth of damage that is not being healed off, still not a good support item.

Mecha MaIphite3 votes

It doesn't have to equal it? Either way, damage is being reduced, or at least redirected effectively.

If your ADC takes 1000 damage and you reduce it to 880 by taking 1000 yourself, that's still 1000 damage between the both of you; and it's better that you take it, because you're tankier.

Even if in the same fight, the ADC only heals you for a measly 100 health, that's still 100 health you pretty much got for free. That means the net HP loss is 900 instead of 1000.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Mecha MaIphite,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=AeJNsTWI,comment-id=00000000000000000000,timestamp=2016-12-20T00:29:04.657+0000)

It doesn't have to equal it? Either way, damage is being reduced, or at least redirected effectively.

If your ADC takes 1000 damage and you reduce it to 880 by taking 1000 yourself, that's still 1000 damage between the both of you; and it's better that you take it, because you're tankier.

Even if in the same fight, the ADC only heals you for a measly 100 health, that's still 100 health you pretty much got for free. That means the net HP loss is 900 instead of 1000.

normally that would be true but you have to look at it with the outside sources of damage, in the same way if your adc takes 1000 damage, and you reduce it to 880, then your taking 1000 on top of other forms of damage being directed on you.

the point im trying to make about it is that the amount of healing is not suppose to equal but make enough of a diffence to turn a fight, which it does not since your being healed by the adc for 12% but your taking the 12% plus 60% of the focused damage atleast if not all of it.

so by your math your saying that even if you get out alive, the both of you, you got out taking 48% total damage plus the 12% of true damage before getting out minus the healing effect which is no where near enough to matter, making your total health less then half making you need to back and probably loss a turret, inhibitor or the game..... its not an effective item at all

Mecha MaIphite1 votes

The damage you take from other sources, you were going to take anyway. You can't really factor that in when considering the effectiveness of this item.

Even if we removed the healing, just redirecting damage from your ADC to yourself is enough of a benefit. Ideally, you want to be taking most the damage, being a tank, but realistically, they're not going to focus you. So even if there was no reduction of damage overall, redirecting it to yourself still has more benefits than harms.

Just think of the healing as an extra sort of gimmick.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Mecha MaIphite,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=AeJNsTWI,comment-id=0000000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2016-12-20T00:51:05.054+0000)

The damage you take from other sources, you were going to take anyway. You can't really factor that in when considering the effectiveness of this item.

Even if we removed the healing, just redirecting damage from your ADC to yourself is enough of a benefit. Ideally, you want to be taking most the damage, being a tank, but realistically, they're not going to focus you. So even if there was no reduction of damage overall, redirecting it to yourself still has more benefits than harms.

Just think of the healing as an extra sort of gimmick.

actually that is exactly how you have to consider the effectivness of any item, how it stacks with opposing forces of damage

Mecha MaIphite1 votes

Well, no. That's like saying, having a Jhin take 1000 damage and having a Braum take 1000 damage is the same. If you had to choose, you would try to redirect as much of the damage on Jhin over to Braum as possible.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Mecha MaIphite,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=AeJNsTWI,comment-id=000000000000000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2016-12-20T00:54:23.386+0000)

Well, no. That's like saying, having a Jhin take 1000 damage and having a Braum take 1000 damage is the same. If you had to choose, you would try to redirect as much of the damage on Jhin over to Braum as possible.

well taking damage regardless of who it is, is the same because its unmitigated to begin with.

even if you were to pair off and say of hey you take 1000 and i take 1000 and i redirect 12% of that to me making the 1120 damage so you dont take as much, you both took the same percentage wise regardless of health totals.

880 health damage off of jhin is the same percent of health braum would take taking 1120 health damage from a percentage stand point and im guessing that is what riot was thinking with KV as an item

Mecha MaIphite1 votes

Not really. 880 health off of Jhin is around 40% of his health, whereas 1120 off of Braum is closer to 20-30%, if he builds correctly.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Mecha MaIphite,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=AeJNsTWI,comment-id=00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2016-12-20T01:05:11.530+0000)

Not really. 880 health off of Jhin is around 40% of his health, whereas 1120 off of Braum is closer to 20-30%, if he builds correctly.

actually 880 health and 1120 health about around 35% each give or take the correct build on either of them

xXZiluenXx1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Mecha MaIphite,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=AeJNsTWI,comment-id=0000000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2016-12-20T00:51:05.054+0000)

Even if we removed the healing, just redirecting damage from your ADC to yourself is enough of a benefit. Ideally, you want to be taking most the damage, being a tank, but realistically, they're not going to focus you. So even if there was no reduction of damage overall, redirecting it to yourself still has more benefits than harms.

Just think of the healing as an extra sort of gimmick.

honestly depending on the point in the game and the match ups, if your a tank support using this item, then yeah you going to be the focus because your an easy kill if you have to deal with range and you wont beable to escape easy enough

ph1234k1 votes

{quoted}

actually it is true damage, re-read it i had to and found out that it was, and it deffintily is a worse version of bond of stone, even though it heals as well as redirecting damage it is no where near as mush as you think it is, seriously knight's vow isnt even good at all

Ok, let me clarify the true damage thing because it is exactly how this should work and I need to explain it so you understand that this is perfect for the mastery. An enemy deals 100 physical damage to your partner. You partner's resistances (armor) apply to it, the mastery doesn't affect this at all. Let's say that means your partner will take 90 damage. Now we have physical damage that has already had armor deducted. This may as well now be true damage as nothing else will deduct any more of it. WHatever label you give it, it is already damage that has applied resistance checks so it won't be reduced any further.
Only now does the mastery apply. This means your partner will take 88% of the damage which is about 79 damage and you will take 12% which is about 11 damage. This HAS to be applied as true damage since resistances have already been applied. If it was the same type as originally applied that means your resistances would proc again which means that instead of redirecting 12% of damage it would really take 12% damage and reduce it to some other number (9% for example) then apply it to you which would be broken as well as make the item incorrectly phrased.

Knight's Vow also heals you (for exactly as much as you think) for 12% of the damage your partner deals.

In this example that means if your partner also dealt 100 damage to your enemy and let's say they had no armor that means you heal now for 12 which puts you at higher health than before the enemy attack. This is the main reason why it beats out BoS, if your partner deals more damage than he takes, the damage he takes will never really affect you.

Then there are further differences. BoS takes no item slots (benefit). BoS has damage reduction as well. KV has 400 health and 20 armor as well.

KV is superior to the BoS in just about every way imaginable.

King of Demons5 votes

You are supposed to keep the AD alive. This item does that. It also heals you from his damage. Where is the problem? The supports that would build it are simply not that popular atm.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Taku of Rivia,realm=EUW,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=AeJNsTWI,comment-id=0005,timestamp=2016-12-19T23:59:45.997+0000)

You are supposed to keep the AD alive. This item does that. It also heals you from his damage. Where is the problem? The supports that would build it are simply not that popular atm.

so you get 12% healing from your partners damage, the true damage nullifies that easily and out damages the healing

Akenero1 votes

That's why the tanks go in first and get healed by the adc

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

That's why the tanks go in first and get healed by the adc

yes that is what i suppose to happen, but again if the tanks go in and are taking too much damage for the adc to help at all with then what is the point

personally redemption is always the better option out of the 2 and even if it is nerfed it will always be a better option

Dolasaur3 votes

yes that is what i suppose to happen, but again if the tanks go in and are taking too much damage for the adc to help at all with then what is the point

You have two options here. Without KV, you go in, take X damage, and that's it. With KV, you go in, take X damage, and also heal for Y health based on the damage your ADC does. This is strictly better than not having KV if you're the one tanking.

personally redemption is always the better option out of the 2 and even if it is nerfed it will always be a better option

Well, I sure hope your carry never dies in 2.5 seconds. Because Knight's Vow is more useful in the first 2.5 seconds of every fight you're ever in. KV is also helpful when the enemy has zone control that would make it a bad idea to stay in the Redemption area (e.g. Anivia QWR, Ziggs QWER, Viktor WER, Vel'Koz QWER, Annie running up with 5 stacks, fed Illaoi/Darius comes up and decides to stand in it... you get the idea).

I'm not saying KV is always the best item ever. But saying Redemption is and will always be better than it shows a lack of understanding.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

You have two options here. Without KV, you go in, take X damage, and that's it. With KV, you go in, take X damage, and also heal for Y health based on the damage your ADC does. This is strictly better than not having KV if you're the one tanking.

Well, I sure hope your carry never dies in 2.5 seconds. Because Knight's Vow is more useful in the first 2.5 seconds of every fight you're ever in. KV is also helpful when the enemy has zone control that would make it a bad idea to stay in the Redemption area (e.g. Anivia QWR, Ziggs QWER, Viktor WER, Vel'Koz QWER, Annie running up with 5 stacks, fed Illaoi/Darius comes up and decides to stand in it... you get the idea).

I'm not saying KV is always the best item ever. But saying Redemption is and will always be better than it shows a lack of understanding.

i sure hope you get an adc that knows how to position well becasue that is what make redemption better, and i would rather have the healing from redemption the try to engage and die becasue i took way too much damage to get any sort of benefit from KV

Dolasaur1 votes

The general strategy for ADC is to "stay alive and hit whatever you can safely, without accidentally getting in range of anything that can hurt you". Redemption is simply a bonus on top of that.

Because of that, ADCs that aren't insanely fed generally have poor zone control. You use Redemption, which puts the big circle on the ground. All the champs I mentioned earlier now have 2.5s to ensure that being in that circle is a terrible idea for your ADC.

Of course, your team will simultaneously try to make sure it's a good place to be. But it's not guaranteed unless your team is already dominating. And most items are good when you're ahead, so it's a weak discussion at that point.

Elite4Runner1 votes

{quoted}

so you get 12% healing from your partners damage, the true damage nullifies that easily and out damages the healing

As a tank, you will most likely have double the health of your ADC

So even if your ADC gets 100 to 0 that is only 6% of your maximum health.

That is nothing.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

As a tank, you will most likely have double the health of your ADC

So even if your ADC gets 100 to 0 that is only 6% of your maximum health.

That is nothing.

well if your adc dies that fast then knight's vow would never help anyway to mitigate any damage and even if the tables were turned normally i would say thats ok, but its not since your math is off, because i have had double the health that they had and lost more health then that when they died even with the healing and that was supporting for a fed adc that was doing more damage then the opposing adc.

like i said the healing is clearly nullified but the true damage

Elite4Runner1 votes

{quoted}

well if your adc dies that fast then knight's vow would never help anyway to mitigate any damage and even if the tables were turned normally i would say thats ok, but its not since your math is off, because i have had double the health that they had and lost more health then that when they died even with the healing and that was supporting for a fed adc that was doing more damage then the opposing adc.

like i said the healing is clearly nullified but the true damage

... so you took damage from other sources, ....

My math isn't "off" that is literally how it works.

If you and your partner have the exact same amount of health, they are then killed from 100 to 0 by enemy champions who do not touch you, the absolute MOST amount of damage you will take is 12% of your maximum health.

Elite4Runner1 votes

Aso, if your ADC dies that fast, they are out of position and you are not peeling for them.

So this whole point is moot because you and your ADC are getting outplayed.

At that point, it doesn't matter when items you buy.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

Aso, if your ADC dies that fast, they are out of position and you are not peeling for them.

So this whole point is moot because you and your ADC are getting outplayed.

At that point, it doesn't matter when items you buy.

that may be true, but its more the hypothetical if you think about it, put it this way

Knights vow is one of your items as a support, you and your adc engage, being positioned well and make good move, and say you are slightly ahead in your lane with your adc a few 10 cs up and 2 kills up.

so the 2 of you engage4 seconds in you notice your health at about 50%-58% and you decide to back off and repostion and try to outplay them.

your adc see you backing off and backs off with you and notices you want to out play, getting poke along the way as well as you the support are, your health now 45%.

you get to turret and you turn to make a big play, abilities go off and both you and the adc take damage, the adc less the you becasue of knights vow, leaving you with around 28% health after all that, so you retreat trying to get behind turret being poke to death, your adc attacking and trying to help, only to watch you die from them and then they get a double off the adc under turret before leaving barely alive.

i would say that sums up every game i have player with knights vow

Elite4Runner1 votes

{quoted}

that may be true, but its more the hypothetical if you think about it, put it this way

Knights vow is one of your items as a support, you and your adc engage, being positioned well and make good move, and say you are slightly ahead in your lane with your adc a few 10 cs up and 2 kills up.

so the 2 of you engage4 seconds in you notice your health at about 50%-58% and you decide to back off and repostion and try to outplay them.

your adc see you backing off and backs off with you and notices you want to out play, getting poke along the way as well as you the support are, your health now 45%.

you get to turret and you turn to make a big play, abilities go off and both you and the adc take damage, the adc less the you becasue of knights vow, leaving you with around 28% health after all that, so you retreat trying to get behind turret being poke to death, your adc attacking and trying to help, only to watch you die from them and then they get a double off the adc under turret before leaving barely alive.

i would say that sums up every game i have player with knights vow

The whole scenario you just described is completely arbitrary.

Lets say the exact same thing happens, except instead of you both losing, you turn the battle and win with less than 100 hp remaining.

Now it sounds like Knight's Vow solely won the fight for you.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

The whole scenario you just described is completely arbitrary.

Lets say the exact same thing happens, except instead of you both losing, you turn the battle and win with less than 100 hp remaining.

Now it sounds like Knight's Vow single solely won the fight for you.

well that could happen as well, but it would be unlikely to happen in a dire situation when it turns bad

LongHair Fox1 votes

Well if you have a semi potent adc and you yourself actually are worth more than a caster minion when it comes to peeling that adc is going to deal more damage than he takes... Meaning you will heal more. It is simple maths, even with GW on it only takes a bit better peeling from you.

SchmidttyGames3 votes

It works well with Tank Supports. Especially high health ones like Sion, Alistar, and Leona.

xXZiluenXx2 votes

[{quoted}](name=RAMP Schmidtty,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=AeJNsTWI,comment-id=0001,timestamp=2016-12-19T23:53:40.122+0000)

It works well with Tank Supports. Especially high health ones like Sion, Alistar, and Leona.

again, that only works well until late game when you would end up taking too much damage

Titanium701 votes

Especially in Late it's amazing - Leona is a great example. She gets super tank stats for 2,4k Gold. And who cares for DMG you take, make your carry survive! IF you manage to get through the first burst, you'll be nearly unkillable due to massive heal this item offers.

BTW: Ever seen a Carry with item 3046 item 3812 item 3109 ?

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

Especially in Late it's amazing - Leona is a great example. She gets super tank stats for 2,4k Gold. And who cares for DMG you take, make your carry survive! IF you manage to get through the first burst, you'll be nearly unkillable due to massive heal this item offers.

BTW: Ever seen a Carry with item 3046 item 3812 item 3109 ?

let me know how that works our for you since you clearly havent done that yet

Titanium701 votes

lol???... w/e...

You dont like it - we got it. Still, I consider it an amzing Item and got to directly after sightstone on TankSupps like Leona Braum Thresh IF they can focus on peel instead of engage.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

lol???... w/e...

You dont like it - we got it. Still, I consider it an amzing Item and got to directly after sightstone on TankSupps like Leona Braum Thresh IF they can focus on peel instead of engage.

the concept of knights vow wasnt a bad thought but the way it was implemented was terrible, like i said if they were to take it back to the drawing board and fix it some, im sure they could make it a toss up for any support player to pick between it or redemption

Elite4Runner3 votes

The whole idea is that you will protect your ADC so that they are able to deal damage.

You protect them = they don't take damage or they take very little damage = YOU take little damage (from the item)

As long as they are able to continue to effectively deal damage, you should be healing very effectively.

You get ADC level lifesteal as a tank!

Skias1 votes

{quoted}

The whole idea is that you will protect your ADC so that they are able to deal damage.

You protect them = they don't take damage or they take very little damage = YOU take little damage (from the item)

As long as they are able to continue to effectively deal damage, you should be healing very effectively.

You get ADC level lifesteal as a tank!

lol at adc level lifesteal.

Elite4Runner3 votes

{quoted}

lol at adc level lifesteal.

What I mean to say is that the 12% lifesteal scales on the damage output of an ADC, as opposed to the damage output of a tank support.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

What I mean to say is that the 12% lifesteal scales on the damage output of an ADC, as opposed to the damage output of a tank support.

not only do i know that but it matters not when the same is said about the enemy adc scaling in damage as well........ again it is only useful if the 2 of you are far enough ahead that they cant do damage

Skias1 votes

{quoted}

What I mean to say is that the 12% lifesteal scales on the damage output of an ADC, as opposed to the damage output of a tank support.

Ah. Well you have to remember, you're also taking your own damage as well as a ton of damage transferred over the item. That healing doesn't generally make up for it. The base stats of the item suck too hard for it to be a priority purchase. Especially when Redemption is around.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

Ah. Well you have to remember, you're also taking your own damage as well as a ton of damage transferred over the item. That healing doesn't generally make up for it. The base stats of the item suck too hard for it to be a priority purchase. Especially when Redemption is around.

thats my point, the health and health regen are all that matters on the item really

redemption has the health slightly less health regen, mana regen and cooldown... if you dont count the passive and active its still a better item all around

Skias1 votes

{quoted}

thats my point, the health and health regen are all that matters on the item really

redemption has the health slightly less health regen, mana regen and cooldown... if you dont count the passive and active its still a better item all around

Not really. The armor value is pretty bad and it could be argued that frozen hearts attack speed reduction could protect your ADC with an aoe DPS reduction to opponents without taking more damage and having better armor

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

The whole idea is that you will protect your ADC so that they are able to deal damage.

You protect them = they don't take damage or they take very little damage = YOU take little damage (from the item)

As long as they are able to continue to effectively deal damage, you should be healing very effectively.

You get ADC level lifesteal as a tank!

you take more damage from it then the lifesteal will heal by alot, again its true damage you take so your taking unmitigated damage which even if your suppose to keep the adc is a bad thing when you have to run from alot of engagments because of it

Elite4Runner1 votes

{quoted}

you take more damage from it then the lifesteal will heal by alot, again its true damage you take so your taking unmitigated damage which even if your suppose to keep the adc is a bad thing when you have to run from alot of engagments because of it

Not of your carry is dealing more damage than they are taking.

If you are peeling and they are positioned properly, they will deal a lot more damage than they will take.

Flaherty2 votes

How is keeping the carry alive longer not a good thing? And what's stopping anyone from building both redemption and this item? Usually the role of the support is to keep the carry alive and the item essentially gives the carry 12% damage reduction which is pretty significant and definitely stronger than bond of stone. The supports that should be building the item are going to be very tanky and should be building for more hp to counteract the true damage and are getting healed from the damage the carry is doing.

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

How is keeping the carry alive longer not a good thing? And what's stopping anyone from building both redemption and this item? Usually the role of the support is to keep the carry alive and the item essentially gives the carry 12% damage reduction which is pretty significant and definitely stronger than bond of stone. The supports that should be building the item are going to be very tanky and should be building for more hp to counteract the true damage and are getting healed from the damage the carry is doing.

i was never saying keeping the carry alive was a bad thing, but as a support main and i love my tank support, i find my self have to fall back more often using the item, unless we are so far ahead of them that it doesnt matter, the amount of damage im taking because of knight's vow is way too high

Flaherty1 votes

If you're building armor and mr exclusively then of course the damage you're going to take is going to be too high, the item gives you armor when you're near the ally so it encourages you to build more HP which helps against the true damage

xXZiluenXx1 votes

{quoted}

If you're building armor and mr exclusively then of course the damage you're going to take is going to be too high, the item gives you armor when you're near the ally so it encourages you to build more HP which helps against the true damage

more health is not normally the best option since knight's vow encourages more health the armor and mr then your just a big target that gets melted in seconds with out any sort of armor and mr other the the item.

Flaherty1 votes

Jesus dude you obviously don't JUST build HP and nothing else, you just build more than normal. Like if your normal build without knights vow had frozen heart which is all armor and no HP you build sunfire/dead mans plate instead of it if you're building knights vow because the extra armor you would have gotten with frozen heart isn't needed as much as the extra HP the other items give you. Is this really that hard to grasp?

Dafertotta1 votes

Will test it on top Nasus summ.rift duo (triforce,visage,kv,thornmail,frozen mallet?/some hp item if needed) with jungler dmg shyvana (but somewhat tanky shyvana : rageblade,bork,titanic ,gArgoils,cleaver,bloodrazor, fervour 18/0/12 It can be good,while the Armor reductions amd slows and much aoe And my duo p. Loves movespeed,so its nice , want to make kv happen ! Some silver maining shyv. Farming jung. I think on 2 tanky champs its interesting to consider buying it, while the dmg reduction,will wright results. 80%+wimrate solo q. shyv. With build ,so kv it might get higher if nasus or sg can build it. We will take down baron regardless ..

More from Gameplay

More by xXZiluenXx