I never said late "comps". That is an entirely different discussion.
Having a discussion about an entire comp that is playing nothing but scaling champions is pointless in solo queue because you have no control over what your teammates will pick. That said, we have to focus on the effectiveness of a scaling champion in a typical solo queue comp. We also have to talk about their effectiveness in each rank. That is why I specified low elo in the first comment because their games are typically longer due to them not knowing how to close a game out. That is also another point that I made in the first post. You can't seem to comprehend it though.
,
,
, and
, have the highest win rates respectively in the ADC role once you remove Heimerdinger and Mordekaiser. Their play rates are so small that mentioning those two is probably irrelevant. Miss Fortune would be the only one in the top 4 that is a early game champion (Though she is still effective late game with her ultimate off of CD).
The next three ADC's on the list are
,
, and
respectively. So in the top 7, we have four scaling champions even in platinum+. Lucian definitely has the highest efficient win rate since his play rate is absolutely insane. Quinn probably isn't even worth mentioning like Heimerdinger and Mordekaiser, because her play rate is lower than both of them. She has the 2nd lowest play rate right behind Corki in the ADC role.
Now.... If I am in low elo and I know that my ADC is unskilled at the game mechanically, then we have a much higher chance of winning with any of the top scaling champions. The reason? Because when all they have to do is right click to blow up 5 people, it is significantly more valuable to have than to see a Bronze-Platinum player try to play Lucian in a late game team fight. His range is extremely short and he is single target focused. It is also better for low-skilled players to have brainless and quick wave clear.
It is also funny that you use
as one of your examples, when she has one of the highest win rates in Bronze, Silver, and Gold. She also isn't even a scaling late game monster who blows up an entire team with minimal effort. Her poke isn't even that great. She is mostly a zoner who can hold a lane down for an extremely long time.
Isn't really a scaling champion. He is an early-mid game champion who can be very oppressive with a lead.
Is a scaling champion. I agree with you about this one because the skill of the player matters. You need to blow teams up with minimal effort but Gangplank takes a lot of effort by the player to turn him into a hard carry.
Same as Gangplank, but a little easier to use that Gangplank. Although, seeing Ezreal picked on my team is a pet peeve of mine when every other teammate picks tanks or utility. When you put all of your eggs in the Ezreal basket, you need your Ezreal to be HIGHLY skilled to match the hyper carry ADC's that require minimal effort to carry.
is bad across the board. Sure he is probably the strongest scaling hyper carry control mage in the game.... BUT he relies on a skilled player and 5-6 items before he can truly become that threat. Again you are right about this one because it takes Azir WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY too long to scale in the hands of a lesser player.
Complete trash garbage azz champion in lower elo even after she scales. Takes her about as long as Azir to scale but her range is so short that no player in lower elos will be able to properly pilot her in big fights. She is even worse than Azir at low elos.
is extremely powerful in low elos. In a lot of cases, all it will take is the right support and the rest of Kog's team comp doesn't even matter.
is without a doubt one of the strongest champions in low elo. She can bully many lanes AND scale at the same time. Not sure why you listed her. Kayle has one of the best win rates across all elos in Top AND Mid. I am sure once you get to mid and high Diamond, she will probably start falling off. However, from Bronze all the way through Platinum+, she is statistically one of the best champions in the game in two roles.