What do you think of the REMAKE!? EU LCS (GIA vs FNC)

D1egend·Jul 2, 2015·2 votes·3,405 views

I'm casting the matches in the form of Live Play by plays: MakeThePlays.com

I'm curious as to how the community feels about this pause/remake.

16 Comments

KillnYallJul 2, 20153 votes

I feel that the ruling was a bit to late. There need to be a time limit on a remake of the game. I feel 10 min should be how long you have to get the remake when there is a champ select mistake. I remember there was a game in the EU LCS where the players didnht get the champ swap in time and they had to play the game out with those champs. But after the game it was found that there was a bug with the swap button. The team ended up losing badly but didnt ask for a remake even tho they had the right to do it.

GIA, should have had to play that game out, because if they were winning there would be no remake. The remake came after a fail team fight that lost them a lot of map control and that is when they wanted the do over. Riot needs to word the rules on a remake more clear and with time limits with a user error issues.

D1egendJul 2, 20151 votes

i completely agree with you, its not fair for FNC for that to happen. if the bug happens in champ select, it shud be dealt with in champ select, if it does not get fixed, then sorry I think they have to deal with it.

xXKUR0S4K1XxJul 2, 20152 votes

I didnt even understand why they remade it

D1egendJul 2, 20151 votes

They said it was because Nocturne was an error pick, but I don't know why it was remade 15 minutes later. It's like if a red card was called on a foul 15 minutes later in a soccer game. Sounds kind of iffy.

KilkinJul 2, 20153 votes

Yeah, I get that. What I want to know is why it took so long to fix the problem. I mean, from how it looked, Giants knew they made a mistake, but held on to the reset in case Nocturne failed. item 3070

xXKUR0S4K1XxJul 2, 20152 votes

Ok that reasoning is ridiculous and you are totally correct. If they fail to pick the correct champ then they should probably have picked that champion 1 second earlier. And there is no way it takes 15 minutes to communicate to remake it. It should be an immediate pause and then a remake. In the first place it should be your own fault if you pick the wrong champion.

YOU SO BADJul 2, 20152 votes

There is nothing to think?

Rules are Rules.

They miss clicked and picked noc.

The coaches took awhile to Communicate this with riot.

Hints the 15 min restart.

Dont see why anyone is complaining the rules have been this way sense the LCS started.

They have to fallow them for competitive integrity.

Not the first time its happened.

Wont be the last.

SaryxJul 2, 20152 votes

Champion pick are champion pick After it's easy to change :" ho oops i failed my champs "

SaryxJul 2, 20151 votes

It's easy to lie too Like SKT VS FNC remake ? No they played fair

D1egendJul 2, 20151 votes

YEAH i saw that Sej jump/Flash bug/fail, and THAT shud have been an instant like fix

YOU SO BADJul 2, 20151 votes

The rules state:

If there is a bug its on the players in game to call for a pause and investigation.

D1egendJul 2, 20151 votes

I thought they said this happened in champion select and told riot this? I just feel like this and other sport, you can't call a "foul" 15 minutes later really. if there was an error pick in champ select then they should have stopped it then, there shouldnt be a 15 min response time. like i told someone else, in Soccer you cant call a red card after 15 minutes and bring the ball back and rekick it from there. i feel like that rule should be the same. both were good games tho regardless. I guess i enjoyed it XD

DestructoDaveJul 3, 20152 votes

I'm pretty sure they said that Giant's told the Ref's during champ select it was an error.

This seems more like an error on the Ref's part.

What it sounds like, and why it took so long, is they told them, but was told to play, so they did, but someone looked the rule up during the 15 minutes of play, and relayed it, and thats why we had the delayed restart. They were given the restart they asked for in champ select.

Again, this is speculation, but I'm pretty sure this is similar to how it went, with the failure being on Riot's part for even allowing the game to play for 15 minutes in the first place.

Because I doubt they would let them say Oops 15 minutes later and get a remake.