50 Comments

Oleandervine2 votes

Well, they don't HAVE to be anyone we've seen before. Riot doesn't have to make concepts on the boards a reality, and unless the original artist posted that Poppy design, Riot is legally bound to not use it in any sense whatsoever. Also, Janna doesn't fit the theme as well as characters like Soraka or Diana.

cinomenapplebae1 votes

Janna's last skin was forecast (2013)

Oleandervine2 votes

{quoted}

Janna's last skin was forecast (2013)

Yeah, but that's not a reason to automatically include her in a skin line that she doesn't fit particularly well. Cassiopeia hasn't had a skin in 4 years, and Yorick hasn't had a skin in 5 years, but that doesn't mean that they'll get Star Guardian skins.

cinomenapplebae1 votes

But Janna wasn't just reworked

Oleandervine2 votes

{quoted}

But Janna wasn't just reworked

She wasn't. But again, a cosmic magical anime skin line doesn't fit Janna's weather powers. That, and her rework was in 2011, and she looks absolutely terrible. She may not have had any skins made because she's been blacklisted due to her immense popularity and the need to bring her very clunky looks up to modern standards.

cinomenapplebae1 votes

Ok

MavenSong1 votes

{quoted}

She wasn't. But again, a cosmic magical anime skin line doesn't fit Janna's weather powers.

And does Akali's Ninja skills mean she cant be a chef? :p

Oleandervine1 votes

{quoted}

And does Akali's Ninja skills mean she cant be a chef? :p

They're not linking the ninja to her sushi chef skin. They're linking her Asian inspiration for her character.

MavenSong1 votes

Ok... but do her skills pose any relavence?

Oleandervine1 votes

{quoted}

Ok... but do her skills pose any relavence?

No, but her theme does. Janna doesn't fit in theme or kit.

MavenSong2 votes

There are plenty of skins that dont make sense, lets just wait and see instead of conjecturing over silly details.

Oleandervine1 votes

{quoted}

There are plenty of skins that dont make sense, lets just wait and see instead of conjecturing over silly details.

All I'm saying is that from what skins people like KateyKhaos have said, they don't just cram champs into skin lines if they don't make sense in them. And I'm saying Janna doesn't make a great deal of sense in a cosmic magical anime line; there are other, better candidates that fit thematically like Soraka, Diana, and Taric. And before you bring up multiple skins in a short amount of time, they've done this in the past, earlier this year, actually. They launched Gentleman Gnar some time last year, Snow Day Gnar last Snowdown, and then gave him the Luchador skin this year. They said he got skins in that short span because he fit the themes they were going for.

Ravenhale2 votes

I'm pretty sure Janna was a poor waif that "transformed" into her otherworldly appearance because of how quickly she surrendered herself to the arcane arts.

Magical transformation is sort of a magical girl thing. Janna is not too far off the mark.

A magical girl that controls the wind isn't a stretch considering one series had a guy transforming into a magical girl wielding a chainsaw. And that's honestly the most staggering thing to accept with a magical girl theme. Pretty much nothing is sacred. While I cringe at the thought of Magical Girl Garen, it wouldn't exactly be out of bounds with his insane drive for justice.

The Last Ballad1 votes

Sailor Uranus fights alongside her partner and lover Sailor Neptune. She possesses powers associated with the wind and sky.

What were you saying now about how Janna's powers do not fit in with the magical girl line?

Cheshire Kittin1 votes

I honestly love the idea for Janna I even know how it could work. It's beautiful

The Last Ballad1 votes

I can see her shield being a light neon color of her base(whichever it might be) with streaks of white light going through it. HER ULT COULD BE A METEOR SHOWER!

Cheshire Kittin1 votes

YES!!!!! I also had the idea of star shooting out from her in the centre of her ULT

Valaran Nara1 votes

{quoted}

All I'm saying is that from what skins people like KateyKhaos have said, they don't just cram champs into skin lines if they don't make sense in them. And I'm saying Janna doesn't make a great deal of sense in a cosmic magical anime line; there are other, better candidates that fit thematically like Soraka, Diana, and Taric. And before you bring up multiple skins in a short amount of time, they've done this in the past, earlier this year, actually. They launched Gentleman Gnar some time last year, Snow Day Gnar last Snowdown, and then gave him the Luchador skin this year. They said he got skins in that short span because he fit the themes they were going for.

I think it's because it's magical girl and not "space heros".

As in, if they were meant to all just be alien super heros, then yeah. Janna wouldn't make sense; however, I can see her as some random girl that was granted magical powers to help defend the galaxy (by fighting monsters on Earth because that's how magical girls work a la Madoka Magika).

We won't talk of personality because it's completely flat. If we go strictly by her lore (which is barely relevant anymore due to retcon), she was a gutter rat in Zaun before she moved to Piltover (stupid Pilties) and gained popularity as an activist. That could possibly be translated as her being chosen because she wanted everyone to be happy and equal despite the hardships she faced.

BLACK REALM GOD1 votes

but maven! conjecture is a healthy form of stress release and we all know players have a lot of pent up stress from sitting on a computer all day after work/school.

personally i think karthus would be a pretty good candidate for the black star guardian - the manliest star guardian. we'll give him white hair and a black robe. he already has a wand and can sing and dance. he'd be perfect. we'd just have to teach him japanese.

https://1drv.ms/i/s!AnPx84txJsHshBKTYH0u5Je5BlmD

"More shall join my choir... desu"

The Last Ballad1 votes

He can be Sailor Saturn

BLACK REALM GOD1 votes

sure lol

Cheshire Kittin1 votes

It can I am positive they thought of it, even if it isn't released

Ozag the Mighty2 votes

Well I have her all star skin and she's kicking a ball but nowhere on her visual has a ball...when she ults it could be her quickly kicking a ball in your face with a follow up...but that's to much coding for a fast paced dash/face kick move.

Cheshire Kittin1 votes

Actually I think Star Guardian Janna would look amazing. Just think her tornado spitting out a trail of stars behind it, Her friend becomes a star and her shield becomes has stars flowing around it well her ULT shots stars out all through it. Plus Janna has been seen more recently and should be up for a new skin soon. Janna is a Mage just like Lux who is is also friends with so I would not be surprised if she got a new skin seeing as all of hers kinda suck. Plus how can you not see her in that outfit. That blue star could very well be Janna

Jeddy0171 votes

Actually, her last skin was the Fnatic skin (2014)

The Last Ballad1 votes

For the purpose of slotting champs for skins, they do not consider any reward skins as those are given based on the teams preferences for champs and the fact that they are not set in stone.

Ralanr1 votes

Woah woah woah, buddy. Riot can't use the exact design but the design can inspire them.

And they've turned fan creations into a reality before. Void Fizz.

Oleandervine1 votes

{quoted}

Woah woah woah, buddy. Riot can't use the exact design but the design can inspire them.

And they've turned fan creations into a reality before. Void Fizz.

They actually can't make any skin inspired by content unless it was posted by the original artist. So if you post a concept by someone else on DeviantArt, they are legally not allowed to use any shred of it in any way. Their Terms of Service covers this use of content and directly specifies that content must be owned by the poster on Riot's community sites in order to be used or inspiration for Riot.

Sexy Jack Rabbit1 votes

Honey sorry to burst your bubble but that is not how Copyright works. Just because something has been made/conceptualized does not mean it cannot be made again.
Try to do some research on copyright laws before spreading misinformation.

Oleandervine1 votes

{quoted}

Honey sorry to burst your bubble but that is not how Copyright works. Just because something has been made/conceptualized does not mean it cannot be made again.
Try to do some research on copyright laws before spreading misinformation.

This is from the Terms: "You grant us, from the time of uploading or transmission of Your Content, a worldwide, perpetual, irrevocable, sublicenseable, transferable, assignable, non-exclusive and royalty-free right and license to use, reproduce, distribute, adapt, modify, translate, create derivative works of, publicly perform, publicly display, digitally perform, make, have made, sell, offer for sale and import Your Content, including, all copyrights, trademarks, trade secrets, patents, industrial rights and all other intellectual and proprietary rights related thereto, in any media now known or hereafter developed, for any purpose whatsoever, commercial or otherwise, including, giving Your Content to others, without any compensation to you."

The need to explicitly state this would tell me that copyright law does not allow them to borrow or heavily use concepts without consent of the creator.

Actually xPeke1 votes

Riot can use any art of their own charachters lol. It's not possible to do a concept design of an already existing charachter that is copyrighted by a company and then claim it 100% yours in terms of concept, personality, design. etc

Sexy Jack Rabbit2 votes

You don't seem to understand. This means that any conceptualization made of their characters or property allows them by law to be used without consent and without compensation. Copyright law is a fickle business. If a products terms and conditions don't explicitly state whether the content can be used without permission, it leaves it up to interpretation. Just because you water-color a piece of Artwork, does not trademark or copyright it. Meaning people can use it without your consent. Riot has gone to state with their product, they may claim any conceptualization of their characters without compensation. There is no universal law in regards to product copyright, but in fact a large set and subset beyond that.

Cheshire Kittin1 votes

Janna I think fits better actually, and we just got a new soraka skin I can't see Diana as she's a darker character where as Janna is light where I think she would be better. But I can see Diana being there just like Syndra they fit well personally I think Janna,Syndra,Lulu and Soraka my reasons I posted Lulu and Syndras further up and Jannas a bit lower. Soraka I can see it because she literally is the Star Child, it would work so well with her

Oleandervine2 votes

I can't get my hopes too high due to the uncertainty, but I would love if Poppy was one of the new skins though.

TenshouSNK2 votes

Yea the leak was very upsetting. Jinx? She got a skin already last year. Quinn needs one.

paisy1 votes

The colors are blue, green, pink and purple

Ralanr1 votes

Could the green be...Karma?

Cheshire Kittin1 votes

Could be cool AF

paisy1 votes

I like that theory

DilMin1 votes

Jinx Yasuo Soraka Janna

Cheshire Kittin2 votes

I can't see jinx even though I have seen the art for it I think she is to crazy of a character for it too work mainly because she's so wild her skins tend to match her crazy personality I don't think she would work but that is my personal opinion I can't see how her guns would look but I can see how they would work. Yasup seems like a long shot judging by how it is such a girly line I think they will try to keep it that way honestly I am just praying for Syndra maybe Janna but I don't think riot will disappoint us, especially cause we have all been waiting since Sta Guradian Lux was released

The Last Ballad1 votes

Wasn't that the Time controler girl from Madoka, the one obsessed with saving the pink haired(and clothed, and eyed) one from her fate of becoming a god?!

Seriously, though, that pink haired girl was way to selfish with her wish. Not only did she become a god, but SHE NEGATED THE PRICE OF THE WISH WITH HER WISH!

Valaran Nara1 votes

[{quoted}](name=The Last Ballad,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=BNisHsdz,comment-id=0003000000000000,timestamp=2016-09-19T04:40:10.769+0000)

Wasn't that the Time controler girl from Madoka, the one obsessed with saving the pink haired(and clothed, and eyed) one from her fate of becoming a god?!

Seriously, though, that pink haired girl was way to selfish with her wish. Not only did she become a god, but SHE NEGATED THE PRICE OF THE WISH WITH HER WISH!

Pink hair is Madoka.

And Madoka's wish was selfless. It just...didn't turn out as well as she hoped.

Wolfess1 votes

[{quoted}](name=The Last Ballad,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=BNisHsdz,comment-id=0003000000000000,timestamp=2016-09-19T04:40:10.769+0000)

Wasn't that the Time controler girl from Madoka, the one obsessed with saving the pink haired(and clothed, and eyed) one from her fate of becoming a god?!

Seriously, though, that pink haired girl was way to selfish with her wish. Not only did she become a god, but SHE NEGATED THE PRICE OF THE WISH WITH HER WISH!

the pink haired girl IS Madoka. her fate wasn't becoming a god. Originally she was just a regular magical girl like the rest that just couldn't defeat Walpurgis, who was the strongest witch. After traveling through time so many times to the past, it started to affect Madoka, twisting her fate, increasing her tragedy and the power of her wish, which is what gives them their strength as magical girls, which is what Kyubei wants since that's the energy they harvest. Her wish was selfless, she wanted to prevent the young girls' wishes from turning them into the monstrosities that were Witches, though the fulfillment of the wish required her to do something extraordinary so she had to become a god-like being that could travel through ALL time and ALL alterations of the universe in order to prevent ALL magical girls in all possible alternate realities of the world from becoming Witches, therefore she is STUCK traveling through time, space, and reality in order to eliminate all possibilities of witches, forever, never stopping, indefinitely.

also.... you should watch the third movie. movies 1 and 2 are basically the re-telling of the series. movie 3 is something that happens afterwards and is trippy AF.

Cheshire Kittin1 votes

Star Guardian Syndra. Just think about it, be easy to make sure everything includes the stats especially cause every ability uses her balls, just like everything in star guardian Lux has the stars. Syndra could be the purple one. I was also looking into Star guardian lulu. Her q sends out a shot of stars pix becomes a star she turns people into stars that just fly away her W on a ally cast could shoot stars instead of flowers behind them her e could have stars on the shield and her ULT can have a beautiful effect of stars shooting up around her(similar to Luxs ULT where the stars wrap around her beam) and stars to knock people up

Horse Grenades1 votes

It was leaked on Reddit that it was Janna, Poppy, Jinx, and Lulu

with elemental lux coming behind them

Bellopia1 votes

Star Guardian Soraka is all I want.

Cheshire Kittin1 votes

I can't see it not happening in all honestly she fits it perfectly

Valaran Nara1 votes

Honestly, I don't think anybody who has innate ties with the cosmos, celestial plane or otherwise "galactic" theme should get Star Guardian. If they do, is there really that much of a change of theme for them or fantasy?

More from Story, Art, & Sound

More by cinomenapplebae