AATROX REWORK [NF]
From what I can tell, Aatrox's shtick is that he's an AD diver that you raise top lane (as opposed to Xin Zhao Jungle or Nocturne Jungle).
He jumps in, he kills a person, he dies, he comes back, he kills another person, he dies again. This is what's supposed to happen.
What ACTUALLY happens is; He goes in, he dies without killing anyone, he comes back, and dies again.
Obviously this is not intended.
AD Divers
Xin Zhao has a knockup and a knockback that gives him Armor and MR, plus some in-combat sustain. He is my idea of a perfect diver.
CC, Tank stats, and in-combat sustain. Aatrox is missing (pretty much) 2 of these things. His Q has a knockup, but it's also on the ability that he uses to initiate and is on a pretty long cooldown. He also has no tank stats to speak of.