Replies make comments very confusing :(

dubyaa·8/24/2015, 10:55:17 PM·4 votes·1,734 views

When someone is replying someone else, it just looks like a regular comment on my screen. This can make reading comments (especially to discussion/AMA threads) a huge hassle, trying to figure out who they're talking to and what the topic originally was by scrolling and re-reading, sometimes through multiple pages. I usually just give up. :( This is especially true for Red posts.

I'm assuming people using the Reply feature does it to notify the individual, but won't include the original post (in case it might be huge) to save on forum space. Is there a way you could link the replied post somehow in the reply feature? Reading replies to specific comments are so confusing without a way to link them.

16 Comments

Angry Monster8/25/2015, 11:39:12 PM2 votes

the use discussion view. Riot need to ditch chronological at this point. The 2 systems are not compatible and is causing problems.

Meriipu8/25/2015, 11:36:09 PM1 votes

I wish the forums force-inserted a reference to the post discussion-view-users are replying to that can be accessed for chronological-view-users

that way chronological-view-users can access the same tree structure as discussion view users via linked posts, while still seeing the newest posts at the bottom.

Sortof like pointers I guess.

Meriipu8/26/2015, 12:18:54 AM1 votes

okai I think I get how the comment-id works now

it is 0000-FFFF for root level posts

and xxxx0000-FFFF for replies and quotes to root level posts, where xxxx is the id of the root level posts

and xxxxyyyy0000-FFFF for replies and quotes to replies to root level posts

and so on

so it could totally be done with userscripts just too bad I can not into javascript

AMYS GRAVE8/26/2015, 12:43:39 AM1 votes

Show in Discussion View