Hextech Punishments
As many of you have probably found out by now riot is repunishing previously "toxic" players or anyone with a previous chat restriction by not awarding them with their Hextech items earned in games.
The tribunal is meant to make toxic players reform and do better by punishing them once for their "crimes". To do something like this way after the fact and after that player has corrected their behavior is just unnecessary punishment and does not encourage a player that has already been corrected. If anything it is toxic of Riot to do something like this especially since they did not even announce this new hidden (possibly permanent?) punishment