Skip to content

Peculiar game: Who would you report here if any?

Next is Tragic··1 votes·4,344 views

So, Riven and Sona were carrying our Ranked Game. Then Sona misplayed one situation, which caused Riven to vent: Riven called Sona "useless" or something the like. Because of this, Sona decided to not participate in the game anymore: She didn't feed outright, but she didn't do a single point of damage from then on either.

Sona - in her own words - wanted to teach Riven that no teammate is ever truly "useless" - as long as they aren't trolling. She turned out to be right: Without Sona, we lost that game.

Riven - seeing the almost certain win slowly escaping her grasp - started to flame harder: She called Sona "r%%%%%ed", "degenerate", "jew", "jehovahs witness" and wished Sona's mother to die, amongst others. In the end however, she came around and agreed to talk this out after the game -- sadly too late, we had been way outscaled by that point.

Now the thing is: In that talk in the post-game-lobby, Riven kinda agreed to not flame a teammate that is not trolling nor feeding in future games. Probably more out of fear that she might lose a game in this manner again than anything else - but still.

I'm kinda conflicted here: Who did what wrong? Who is to be reported for what? What's you guys' opinion on this?

19 Comments

Boltonator5 votes

It’s great the Riven agreed to talk it out at the end in the post-game lobby.

That being said however, some of the things the Riven said were absolutely uncalled for. As JoOo stated there is no place in this game for hate speech or lashing out at your teammates.

Sona is equally at fault for basically giving up, which falls under the griefing/giving up under the ingame report feature. Justifiable or not you cannot abandon a game because someone was mean to you. It sucks that the Sona has to deal with the toxic Riven but Sona’s absence from the game after the exchange ended up costing their team the game, or at least heavily contributed to their loss.

Both Riven and Sona should have been reported. I’m not saying Riven’s offense was worse than Sona’s, though their words portray them as as short-sighted and undisciplined, and I am not saying Sona’s was worse than Riven’s, though her actions did directly attribute to their team losing.

In the end they both broke the rules and both deserve to be reported. It may not seem fair or balanced but, as in life, sometimes it isn’t fair or balanced.

[sg-lulu]

Next is Tragic2 votes

I am not a fan of "ironclad" rules: To every rule there is an exception that makes it look ridiculous.

And as the one in front of the report button, I am basically part of the jury here: If I decide to ignore that technically the rules were broken then I am allowed to do so.

This is in line with most modern western judicial system, which were specifically designed to allow the jury to vote against the law and have their decision still be heard anyway.

So while both of them clearly technically broke the rules, I am still not sure whether I want to report them. To me they just seem like some kids duking it out. And they agreed to talk it out after all...

Maybe my threshold for toxicity is just way too high :P

Unker1392 votes

{quoted}

I am not a fan of "ironclad" rules: To every rule there is an exception that makes it look ridiculous.

And as the one in front of the report button, I am basically part of the jury here: If I decide to ignore that technically the rules were broken then I am allowed to do so.

This is in line with most modern western judicial system, which were specifically designed to allow the jury to vote against the law and have their decision still be heard anyway.

So while both of them clearly technically broke the rules, I am still not sure whether I want to report them. To me they just seem like some kids duking it out. And they agreed to talk it out after all...

Maybe my threshold for toxicity is just way too high :P

If its mild on both sides, I don't bother reporting, but this seems like it was pretty intense in game. Unless I was finding the dialog entertaining enough to be worth having my game ruined, I'd report both.

Next is Tragic1 votes

Hmm, now that you say it, I think you're right: This was unusually toxic.

My toxicometer seems to be way undertuned. Has league become less toxic in the last years? Or do I remember past league more toxic than it was?

Hmm.

Unker1392 votes

{quoted}

Hmm, now that you say it, I think you're right: This was unusually toxic.

My toxicometer seems to be way undertuned. Has league become less toxic in the last years? Or do I remember past league more toxic than it was?

Hmm.

I find that it is less toxic than the boards seem to present it. I need to report someone maybe once every 10 games or so and most of those are not extreme. That being said, the few people I know that used to play have quit due to player toxicity.

Jo0o4 votes

You report both of them. Riven flamed, and demonstrated the textbook reason for why flaming in this game is inappropriate. Sona trolled, which is against the rules no matter the circumstances. Both are immature assholes that have no place in this game.

Sleeperbat2 votes

Report them all, let RIOT sort 'em out!

Next is Tragic1 votes

I like your point: Let this get figured out by the people that get paid to do just that!

[slayer-pantheon-thumbs]

Dammit, now having worried over this seems like a waste of time. Welp.

Kei1432 votes

Toxicity is a cycle you know. The verbal toxics will cause disruptive gameplay behavior, which will lead to more verbal toxicity.

It is exactly what you described.

Some people may bring their disruptive gameplay from the previous game and take it out on the new team mates, that leads to verbal toxicity and in turn more disruptive gameplay.

Scottsc202 votes

Report Sona for sure. Trolling is a serious problem, toxicity isn't. Just click mute. No way to win with a troll. Riven just seems to actually give a shit about ranked, something we need more of.

CharDeeMcDenniz1 votes

how can you say toxicity isn't a problem WHEN IT DIRECTLY LED TO A TROLL?

how shortsighted

Scottsc201 votes

It did not "directly lead to a troll". Unless Riven hacked Sona's computer and made her troll, Sona is responsible for her own actions. I'm not saying that what Riven did was right, you shouldn't flame your teammates in any case, but most likely, Riven's behavior is tied to her drive to win and fear of losing. This type of player doesn't deserve to be banned unless they repeatedly take toxicity to the extreme. Sona, meanwhile, made a conscious decision to ruin a ranked game, not only for the toxic Riven, but for three other players who did nothing wrong. Sona could have muted and reported Riven and won the game. Riven could not do anything once Sona decided to give up. One slip up should not lead to a ban, intentionally throwing a game should.

CharDeeMcDenniz1 votes

Implying that the 2 aren't linked in any way is just silly

In this case one led directly to the other. Are both in the wrong? Absolutely. But in this case (and probably thousands of others) one would not have existed without a catalyst

hrooza dota 1 votes

both, riven can recover from a ban if she truly will stop flaming.

sona because her (teaching) harmed 3 more players, so she can learn to not make her revenge on one idiot harm 3 innocents.

Mahrix101 votes

You report Riven for Verbal Abuse, negative attitude, and possibly hate speech for her flame. You report Sona for Intentional feeding and negative attitude for her trolling and giving up.

Both players behavior in this case is completely unacceptable and will likely result in both getting slapped with suspensions.

Shonjl1 votes

You report the Riven for being a typical raging Riven player.

Sona isn't cool for trolling, but you technically are allowed to troll in this game. You aren't required to follow your team and do what they want. If she decided to split push the rest of the game, its clear what she is doing and isn't cool, but she IS ALLOWED to do that. She didn't run it down mid like you said which woulda been report worthy, but sounded like she just avoided teamfights from then on, which while blows, she is allowed to do.

People need to remember the difference of what ACTUALLY is wrong and what they want to be wrong. If I am, idk name a champ. I'll pick Kayn since I play him a lot. If I decide for some reason I don't wanna gank and just wanna farm nonstop, I am more than entitled to do such. There is no rule saying I have to play how you want, contary to how much people love to throw the "Bad jungler" Or "Blame the jungler" crap around.

Scottsc201 votes

I agree that you should be allowed to play how you want, but literally admitting that you are soft inting is not okay, and should be punished more often. Deciding to split push or power farm is one thing, basically throwing a game on purpose to "teach your teammates a lesson" is another.

Shonjl1 votes

{quoted}

I agree that you should be allowed to play how you want, but literally admitting that you are soft inting is not okay, and should be punished more often. Deciding to split push or power farm is one thing, basically throwing a game on purpose to "teach your teammates a lesson" is another.

Doesn't matter, it sucks sure, but as long as they aren't 100% going out of their way to lose a game, it isn't bannable. Its perfectly valid to refuse to group just to force the game to end if enemy is hard shoving as long as you are doing something in the meantime.

Perfect example would be the classic 2 people holding a lost game hostage. My way to counter it? I won't group. I will split push and let the enemy push 5 against our 4 which they will win since they were winning 5v5, and game ends. I am not trolling, I still was doing something meaningful. Granted I don't often run into such a situation but even if I had that happen to me every game, I can assure you nothing will ever happen to me. Contrary to what people believe. You are more than allowed to afk split all game, even if its a detriment. Regardless if its done in spite or not, its a valid tactic.

Like I said before, neither were in the right, the difference merely is, Sona has a right to do what she did, Riven doesn't. If reports were made, Riven would be the one with a possible ban, Sona never will.

Saezio1 votes

You report them if you feel like you were harassed or if you feel like they destroyed your league experience.

I believe that reports are a personal thing and we shouldn't feel like "I have to report this guy/gal because they did this even though it didn't lead to me not enjoying the game"

If they ruined your experience you report them. If they didn't you move on and let the other 2 people in the team decide for themselves too.

More from Player Behavior

More by Next is Tragic