Regarding my first claim, I have the following (note: all emphasis is mine) -
Citation the first, from RiotLyte:
You're probably conflating your personal experiences with those of the average player. The average player reports in about 1 in 20, to 1 in 50 games, so yes, in nearly every queue the average player actually honors more than they report.
Citation the second, from RiotLyte:
Actually.. most players don't play Ranked. When you want to analyze the statistics of a population, you have to measure statistics of a population. Yes, Honors are lower in Ranked, and Reports are higher; however, Ranked isn't the majority of games.
Citation the third, from RiotLyte:
Some players believe that people just report willy nilly, but it's not true. In fact, the question is, how are you telling players what they did wrong after the game? There's a huge difference between, "you're a f*g why did you do that?" versus "Hey, we almost had it. Next time, we should buy more wards."
In fact, most players that say "reported" don't even report at the end of the game. They use the term as a threat and to frustrate people, but rarely follow through.
Happy to talk about any flaws the system might have.
My second claim is one of a rather self-evident nature - the mute button cannot "unsay" something. Therefore, no citation should be necessary.
For my third claim, I have the following -
Citation the first, from RiotLyte (a somewhat side-along approach to the topic, but relevant nevertheless):
That's just the warning system, which doesn't impact account status or apply any punishments.
Pro players will get a lot more false reports than other players, and once in awhile a report slips through and triggers a warning. However, as far as I know, no pro players are getting punishments because the systems will check chat logs and see nothing.
Citation the second, from RiotLyte:
Player behavior systems are not just based on reports. Even if a premade of 4 reported you, if the reports are false, you won't receive a penalty. All player behavior systems are backed by the Report System, which tries to validate every single report. If a report is false, the reporter loses "value" in his reports and the relevant player behavior system ignores the reports. If a report is accurate, the reporter gains "value" and his reports become more powerful. The current Reform System analyzes chat logs for negative behaviors, so it goes beyond just looking at false or accurate reports.
I don't even remember a case where a player was punished because of false reports from a premade of 4.
That should cover citation. Moving on:
[{quoted}](name=Barris Jodo,realm=NA,application-id=cIfEodbz,discussion-id=eO3YEP4K,comment-id=0000000000010000,timestamp=2015-08-10T23:46:47.641+0000)
If the "unskilled" report option worked half as well as the "omg my feelings got hurt!" options, this game would function a lot better and with a lot less toxic groupings. Put the baddies with baddies so that people who aren't licking windows don't have to suffer through them in games, and that includes in unranked games.
There's an entire system in place to handle this exact concern. Each mode (Normal SR, Ranked SR, ARAM, TT, Ranked TT, Dominion, Featured) has its own MMR, specifically to help matchmaking ensure that players play with others near their own skill level.
I'm not sure that's entirely relevant to the discussion, though. Since when has abusing, berating, or harassing others been excusable because they aren't as good at something?