A Mercurial for AP users.. Why or why not?

Not Katarina·8/19/2015, 4:22:21 PM·2 votes·606 views

An idea that's recently crossed my mind is having a item 3140 that builds into an item 3139 but instead of AD stats, gives AP?

a quick FAQ: "Why not get a item 3102 instead?"

Should I find myself running into more AD than AP on the enemy team and if they carry a lot of cc, I'm either wasting 1/2 a slot by never upgrading item 3140 or buying item 3102 and not necessarily benefitting from the itemization. Also, being able to choose what CC you QSS can be really important as far as lategame teamfights are concerned. I don't see this item being an early-game/mid-game rush, but it gives mid-laners a purpose to buy QSS for later, instead of knowing they're temporarily blowing gold they'll probably have to sell for Banshee's or a late-game AP item.

The only reason I can see this not having been made already is perhaps that people want CC to be the way to immediately shutdown midlaners such as Cassiopeia or Viktor, who are naturally immobile in exchange for damage output. But, people want that for their adc marksman too, and with the same idea of putting out damage and being squishy I'd really like to have a way for an immobile midlaner to to defend oneself, just as I'd buy QSS if I wanted defence as an immobile adc marksman.

The only way to do so currently is to take summoner 1, which doesn't even take off as many forms as CC as item 3140 and for a summoner spell slot, that really feels lacklustre.

I'm looking for opinions on how the community feels about it and why/why not this would be a positive/negative addition, so please feel free to speak your mind! Turn your downvotes off, boys.

I'd totally understand if this was just one of those things they wanted to keep exclusively just like item 3157 is for mages, but I was just curious as it bugs me every now and then, being unable to save myself from instant death.

A/N: I have not included a poll as I want opinions on why/why not you would agree with the addition of an item like this, instead of just yay or nay.

Thanks!

9 Comments

umbraˉ8/19/2015, 4:25:11 PM2 votes

I'm ok with this as long as we get AD Zhonyas OR Armor pen boots.

EndlessSorcerer8/19/2015, 5:28:24 PM2 votes

People have been suggesting this for years. I am quite happy that it has not been implemented.

There are a few issues with an AP item building out of Quicksilver Sash, mostly around the fact that would let many champions rush it:

  • It makes Malzahar pretty much obsolete in lane since his opponents won't really lost anything (except maybe CDR and/or Mana Regen) by rushing QSS against him.
  • It can shut down champions who depend on CC quite hard (i.e. Twisted Fate)
  • It would remove much of the risk of CC junglers ganking (i.e. Sejuani, Amumu, Warwick, Skarner, Nautilus) since they could immediately remove the CC and run.
  • It may make mages too safe (with both Zhonya's and the QSS item), meaning that it's hard to focus them, burst them, or catch them in fights. It also lets them QSS the CC so they can activate Zhonya's or remove silences
EndlessIsolation8/19/2015, 5:37:35 PM1 votes

wont happen. zhonyas.

pripustas8/19/2015, 6:38:25 PM1 votes

Remove QSS, make AD zhonyas. It's unfair that ADs can't have that, and APs can.