A Low Elo PLayer's Auyofil Experience (+gripes and solutions)
Before I start, let me say that most of the information from this post will be from my personal experience and those around me. I simply cannot speak for higher ranking players because I have no experience in that field of play. That being said, here are my issues with the (relatively) new autofill system.
AUTOFILL DECREASES THE COMPETITIVENESS OF RANKED PLAY: I have lost many a game due to having to play a role that I am not comfortable to play with. When a team has a player who is not competent or ready for there role, it gives a advantage to the other team. This decrease the competitiveness of the game because one team is given a handicap from the very start.
AUTOFILL INCREASES QUEUE TIMES: In an ironic twist of events, and in many cases, autofill increase your queue time due to dodgers. Many people. including myself, would rather dodge queue then play role we aren't prepared for in a ranked environment. It is now commonplace for me to go through 4-5 queues before finally finding a game. Sure not all dodges are because of autofill, but I have noticed an increase. Not to mention there is always someone complaining in champselect about how they got to support. Personally I'd rather wait the time to play a game as my roles than have to spend 25-60 minutes playing a role i neither enjoy nor are prepared to play.
SOLUTIONS? First of all, I don't think a full removal of the system is a good thing. I know that at higher rankings, the queue times can be atrocious, but at the lower ones with more players. its really not a huge deal. One thing Riot could do is revert it back to the way it was last season, where autofill only impacting higher rankings. Autofill can stay in norms, but it doesn't need to be in a ranked enviroment.
P.S. Bonus pole for fun