Why doesn't Riot try to create Assassin Items for "melee only"?

goalgetter666·6/22/2017, 8:39:10 AM·47 votes·2,019 views

Problem with Lethality items at the beginning of the Season was in my opinion that certain ADC's (Jhin,Varus) abused these lethality Items which completely blocked off bot lane diversity. Why wouldn't Riot consider making "melee only" items? (Crit problem in Season 6. could've prevented certain things as well)

57 Comments

Kubuś6/22/2017, 9:00:23 AM19 votes

Instead of melee only, even 50% effectiveness for ranged would be good. We dont necessarily need to completely restrict them.

Skorch6/22/2017, 3:37:16 PM13 votes

Because its a dumb way to balance things. If all the assassins items were melee only, then why not make all range-happy items ranged only? Why not make tank items only for champions with a certain base resistances? Why not make Mage items only for champions with X amount of AP scalings?

Why not just have every champion have a list that them and champions like them buy from? Assassins buy from the assassin itemset, ADCs buy from the ranged item set etc...

Because its a cheap solution to a problem. Riot wants to encourage multiple build paths, and seeing "50% effectiveness" will just make any ranged champion less likely to pick it when there are as many 100% effectiveness items.

Dextix LT6/22/2017, 2:04:48 PM13 votes

Because that would mean weakening the adc's, and they cant have that...

Melledoneus6/22/2017, 8:20:34 PM6 votes

The problem with making melee-only assassin items is that certain playstyles and future designs will be limited by a huge band-aid fix issue to an overlaying problem with itemization and certain champions abusing them.

Simply put, if Riot wants to make a ranged AD assassin in the future, they wouldn't be able to. Same thing for reworks.

The Yetii Rider6/22/2017, 6:21:06 PM2 votes

Twitch Quinn Vayne Nidalee Leblanc Ahri are all ranged assassins. That's why.

AirKingNeo6/22/2017, 4:34:09 PM2 votes

Because then Miss Fortune wouldn't be viable and other ADCs who need Lethality, like Jhin.

korg0236/23/2017, 7:58:24 AM2 votes

And what if they decide to release ranged assassin? They should make special items only for him/her. Makes zero sense.

Aatrox Mid 1v56/23/2017, 12:49:35 PM1 votes

{quoted}

Problem with Lethality items at the beginning of the Season was in my opinion that certain ADC's (Jhin,Varus) abused these lethality Items which completely blocked off bot lane diversity. Why wouldn't Riot consider making "melee only" items? (Crit problem in Season 6. could've prevented certain things as well)

so just fuck you to Jayce and Quinn?

Keylight XD6/24/2017, 4:35:32 AM1 votes

They do. @ravenous Hydra

But there could be more options.