lets look at the largest crit strike made by the cait that was on my team, i will pause while you look.
Now that you have looked at that tell me how many people would survive that crit strike... ill wait... (no tanks dont count because if they take that they're probably going to die shortly after)
dunder kill5 votesCait one shot a minion so ADCs are op? Lol
Toppien1 votesCait one shot a minion so ADCs are op? Lol
minion lives matter
who suffers more from champs? minions, they die by the hundreds but someone cares? only rito cares
Spideraxe2 votesEvery second millions of minions are being slaughtered for their hard earned money by cruel and thoughtless champions but for pennies a day you could give 1 minion a pardon. Give a penny, save a life. Pass it forward
RobtheFrog2 votesunless its bronze :/ They don't know how to cs
Dead flag blues3 votesIn this case, don't forget that crit against minions are also counted, so her passive makes it irrelevant. But yes, check this at every end-game screen from an average adc (let's say 
), it's not "ok" for a highest crit to reach more than 1k
dunder kill4 votesWhy not exactly? What is wrong with autoing a minion for 1k if you have shiv and rfc stacked up?
Dead flag blues1 votesWhy not exactly? What is wrong with autoing a minion for 1k if you have shiv and rfc stacked up?
Statikk shiv shouldn't deal 500+ magic damage on a crit, an auto-attack shouldn't deal more damage than a landed skillshot
Communist Toast1 votesyou ask who would survive and then purposely exclude those that would survive from it... like ok man.
but I don't see what you are trying to say anyway, that she shouldn't crit for that much? I don't see anything wrong with it tbh
Krully1 votes<erm> <erm> <erm> <erm> <erm>[{quoted}](name=High Quality H2O,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=6jEWu3Ey,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2018-04-24T20:01:52.728+0000)
you ask who would survive and then purposely exclude those that would survive from it... like ok man.
but I don't see what you are trying to say anyway, that she shouldn't crit for that much? I don't see anything wrong with it tbh
the fact that cait outplayed someone by right clicking on them? <erm>
Communist Toast1 votes<erm> <erm> <erm> <erm> <erm>
the fact that cait outplayed someone by right clicking on them? <erm>
an adc can auto attack away most health? it's almost like draven, jhin on his 4th shot, any tons of other adcs...
KS King Kench1 votes[{quoted}](name=High Quality H2O,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=6jEWu3Ey,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2018-04-24T20:01:52.728+0000)
you ask who would survive and then purposely exclude those that would survive from it... like ok man.
but I don't see what you are trying to say anyway, that she shouldn't crit for that much? I don't see anything wrong with it tbh
you dont see anything wrong with the fact that she can Literally, LITERALLY, one shot someone anyone that isnt a tank... and if she manages to get that off on a tank its only two maybe 3 more shot, assuming they arent also crits, to kill a TANK. so please reconsider your statement and come back afterwards.
Communist Toast1 votesyou dont see anything wrong with the fact that she can Literally, LITERALLY, one shot someone anyone that isnt a tank... and if she manages to get that off on a tank its only two maybe 3 more shot, assuming they arent also crits, to kill a TANK. so please reconsider your statement and come back afterwards.
an adc can 1-2 shot another adc, that is pretty true for any adc in the late game, esp if they get fed, the cait ended the game as 13/6/14. she was completely 1 item above her counterpart adc. she is by all means, fed. so yea..
Speeedy4 votesas a cait main the only way its going to be that much damage is on a small jungle creep like the last little thing of the rock things (drawing a blank right now on the name) you wont do that much to a champion ever
A full build Cait with 
as her optimal build will have about 300 AD x2.5 with crit + 160 for static + 180 for RFC = about 1100 and thats before armor so you really are doing about 1000 max per squishy champ but thats why they get deleted in about 3 autos which is pretty well known at this point. I dont think I have ever 1 shot some unless they were very very far behind coming back from a disconnection. FYI i have like 800k mastery points with cait too
Scary Door1 votesNo sense giving an explanation when people have already summed up the foolishness of hte OP.
Just gonna downvote and move on.
Devilreaper XIII1 votesadc isn't the problem, crit is .o. crit damage should be capped at 100% and crit chance at 50%, its at least a start O,O
dunder kill2 votesSo delete IE and dumpster the rest of crit items? Sounds like very reasonable changes
Devilreaper XIII1 votesSo delete IE and dumpster the rest of crit items? Sounds like very reasonable changes
yes.... 1 crit can be 2600 damage, but adc op ? you do realize crit can be build up to 250% 2600 divided through 2.5 = 1040 1300 devided through 2 = 520
so the adc actually does 520 damage..... how is the adc op????? 100% crit chance and 250% crit damage is just too much.
so 520 + 100% crit D = 1040 crit damage sounds reasonable to me tbh this way an adc can 2-3 shot someone with an basic attack. most champions have about 2500 hp at lvl 18.....
if TS would actually post build or total ad on that cait, we'd be able to judge better tbh.
KS King Kench1 votessee guys i never said ANYTHING about what should be done about it... and now its being assumed that im complaining about adc as a whole... i just said that there is a problem not what needs to be fixed... im not on the balance team so im not going to suggest that i know how to fix it just that it needs to be fixed
PhDs Nuts1 votessee guys i never said ANYTHING about what should be done about it... and now its being assumed that im complaining about adc as a whole
Here's your title again, sounds like you forgot: "(sarcasm) NOOOOOOOO there is nothing wrong with ADC's"
And then you posted a complaint about Caitlyn getting a big headshot crit on a minion or jungle monster with no armor and tried to act like she did it against a champion. Then you tried to argue your point by saying that outside of the champions that build items to counter that damage, nobody can counter that damage. But there are counters to that damage. But those ones don't count.
And she only did 1200 more damage than you with 2k more gold to spend even though you didn't even start stacking a Tear until 12 minutes into the game, which at 19 minutes was your only completed item. But I doubt the Seraphs was actually ready until 23-25 minutes.