Skip to content

Does MM system keep certain players trapped in a specific MMR?

Genet1c0··3 votes·2,671 views

Just wondering if there is anything in the algorithm causing this. It's frustrating when you constantly lose cause of your teams my match history more or less proves it and I've shown people it and they think it's funny how unlucky I get. Take note of this first exhibit.

38 Comments

Rasv3 votes

Instead of posting one screenshot, post 100 screenshots from consecutive games where you perform well each game. If you can do that, I will bet that you win at least 55 of those games.

Genet1c01 votes

{quoted}

Instead of posting one screenshot, post 100 screenshots from consecutive games where you perform well each game. If you can do that, I will bet that you win at least 55 of those games.

I would like you to know I have posted a large string of game data. As you can see. I am not in the proper tier. There is something capping me. I get afkers or baddies quite freqiently. I have that 1 in every 10 games I play piss poor yes. Please take a look at all the recent results.

Ice Weasel X2 votes

{quoted}

Just wondering if there is anything in the algorithm causing this. It's frustrating when you constantly lose cause of your teams my match history more or less proves it and I've shown people it and they think it's funny how unlucky I get. Take note of this first exhibit.

No it doesn't. You cherry-picked a game from 4 days ago that showed you with a much high KDA than your teammates. That's not a standard loss in your history. Most of your losses are not examples of you outshining your team.

Should Ezreal in this game feel like you're the reason he's not climbing the ranks? He was 14/8/4 and you were only 4/9/3.

Should Garen and Kha'Zix in this game feel that you're the reason they lost? They were 13/8/4 and 8/7/6 to your 6/10/4.

In this game, everyone on your team except your support ended with more kills than your lane opponents. Is this loss still entirely their fault and not yours?

In this game, you had the highest death count of your entire team, and tied for lowest kill participation with a single kill. Was that your team's fault?

You had the most kills in this game, but you also died the most. 15/13/10. That's a lot of deaths fed to the enemy where you were either baseline or bonus value from a killing spree.

The system isn't trapping you at an MMR. Its goal is to find your MMR. There's nothing about it that intentionally gives you weaker teammates. If you think you're not a factor in these losses, then you're going to find it a lot harder to climb since you're not focusing on improving your shortcomings.

Genet1c01 votes

[{quoted}](name=Ice Weasel X,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=4qsfuVPz,comment-id=0009,timestamp=2015-03-06T21:11:43.014+0000)

No it doesn't. You cherry-picked a game from 4 days ago that showed you with a much high KDA than your teammates. That's not a standard loss in your history. Most of your losses are not examples of you outshining your team.

Should Ezreal in this game feel like you're the reason he's not climbing the ranks? He was 14/8/4 and you were only 4/9/3.

Should Garen and Kha'Zix in this game feel that you're the reason they lost? They were 13/8/4 and 8/7/6 to your 6/10/4.

In this game, everyone on your team except your support ended with more kills than your lane opponents. Is this loss still entirely their fault and not yours?

In this game, you had the highest death count of your entire team, and tied for lowest kill participation with a single kill. Was that your team's fault?

You had the most kills in this game, but you also died the most. 15/13/10. That's a lot of deaths fed to the enemy where you were either baseline or bonus value from a killing spree.

The system isn't trapping you at an MMR. Its goal is to find your MMR. There's nothing about it that intentionally gives you weaker teammates. If you think you're not a factor in these losses, then you're going to find it a lot harder to climb since you're not focusing on improving your shortcomings.

What about the recent screenshot i added of 12 games?

Ice Weasel X1 votes

{quoted}

What about the recent screenshot i added of 12 games?

That doesn't change what I just said. The links in my comment go directly to several of those games. Your Match History is publicly available.

FHMarshy1 votes

All the games he linked are recent matches.

You can get unlucky, i agree to that, but generally if you are better than the majority of people in your rank, you will climb.

Genet1c01 votes

[{quoted}](name=Ice Weasel X,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=4qsfuVPz,comment-id=0009,timestamp=2015-03-06T21:11:43.014+0000)

No it doesn't. You cherry-picked a game from 4 days ago that showed you with a much high KDA than your teammates. That's not a standard loss in your history. Most of your losses are not examples of you outshining your team.

Should Ezreal in this game feel like you're the reason he's not climbing the ranks? He was 14/8/4 and you were only 4/9/3.

Should Garen and Kha'Zix in this game feel that you're the reason they lost? They were 13/8/4 and 8/7/6 to your 6/10/4.

In this game, everyone on your team except your support ended with more kills than your lane opponents. Is this loss still entirely their fault and not yours?

In this game, you had the highest death count of your entire team, and tied for lowest kill participation with a single kill. Was that your team's fault?

You had the most kills in this game, but you also died the most. 15/13/10. That's a lot of deaths fed to the enemy where you were either baseline or bonus value from a killing spree.

The system isn't trapping you at an MMR. Its goal is to find your MMR. There's nothing about it that intentionally gives you weaker teammates. If you think you're not a factor in these losses, then you're going to find it a lot harder to climb since you're not focusing on improving your shortcomings.

Could you take a look at my large data collection of my recent ranked matches I provided and tell me why I stay in this low elo?

S H A Y C 01 votes

"If you think you're not a factor in these losses, then you're going to find it a lot harder to climb since you're not focusing on improving your shortcomings."

EXACTLY!item 3028 Cheers!

Kãtãrinã1 votes

It isn't always your "team" it is also your own decisions. When you lose there was obviously something YOU could have done better to win it. But yes your team has some influence on the outcome of the game but carrying and being able 2 close the game is a skill to learn. Sometimes if I'm super fed ill sole kill 2 of them and make it impossible 2 lose the team fight since it would be 3v5. Stuff like that, pick enemies off and such.

GundayMonday1 votes

It's both luck and skill. Looks like you got outplayed by a good Yi player this game though.

Volt Cruelerz1 votes

Any single game is luck, but MMR works on strings of games. The only common thread in all your games is you.

Nomad Wanderer1 votes

nah. the common thread in bronze, is you have a decent chance of getting an AFK or someone who has nothing to lose, and doesn't GaF.

throw that random in there, and you need to not only play well, but ALSO get team mates that don't want to throw the game/afk.

That's the point. There's not a drain hole to empty out the IDGaF ppl. They sit at the bottom, and add an additional element to the equation. An element that does NOT exist in in silver 3+..

Volt Cruelerz1 votes

True, but if you care, then that means that on average you'll have more people on your team that care.

That's not to say that I would oppose adding in lower brackets to catch problem players though. Idk, you could add in, say, Wood Tier for players that just genuinely SUCK and perhaps create second group that's only for problem players. Then at least bronze players would shut up about the trolls and "elo Hell"

ModKnightsKemplar1 votes

It's both. You have to have a big enough sample size to know what your actual rank is. Keep playing, keep improving, and you will keep advancing. Simple as that.

Genet1c01 votes

I added my recent match history. The game where I went 1/10/1 as jinx I played very poorly and I take the blame. The game where I played jinx and went 1/9/0 had a dc mid laner. I didnt play to well but it was another mental blow. Please take the time to look at my teams scores in these games as well.

Apex Khazix1 votes

Yes, they're called "Gatekeepers"

Genet1c01 votes

Interesting, the flaming stops when I put up legitimate proof.

Sailor Mint1 votes

For someone who was a "Gold Ahri main" in Season 4. You die way too much, period.

You're playing against Bronze players and are on your way to demotion. Either wake up and prove that you are the better player or keep blaming your team as you sink to the depths of Bronze.

Genet1c01 votes

[{quoted}](name=Devi Freak Mint,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=4qsfuVPz,comment-id=0008,timestamp=2015-03-06T21:09:39.098+0000)

For someone who was a "Gold Ahri main" in Season 4. You die way too much, period.

You're playing against Bronze players and are on your way to demotion. Either wake up and prove that you are the better player or keep blaming your team as you sink to the depths of Bronze.

Did you look at my teams scores in those games? I die because in order to carry you have to die. If I kill 3 and die and my team can some how get it together I win.

Sailor Mint1 votes

You can't really justify dying more than 3-4 times per game. Past a point it's failing to recognize that you can't pick a fight and dying for your sins.

You're either making poor calls, trying to be a hero or simply refusing to learn (if something fails twice, it probably won't work the third time).

Why are you, the S4 Gold player, following Bronze players to their death?

Linthe1 votes

Hard to see how you lost that game. And ironic that Lucian is calling out Poppy.

S H A Y C 01 votes

Im just trying to be objective here...but in most of the games that youve won in the match history screenshot you do very well and in a lot of the matches you lost...you didnt do so well. Seems to me you win when your hot and you lose when youre not, yes it rhymed...enjoy every second of it.DrMundo

Genet1c01 votes

[{quoted}](name=ToiletteOfDoom ,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=4qsfuVPz,comment-id=000b,timestamp=2015-03-06T21:15:45.964+0000)

Im just trying to be objective here...but in most of the games that youve won in the match history screenshot you do very well and in a lot of the matches you lost...you didnt do so well. Seems to me you win when your hot and you lose when youre not, yes it rhymed...enjoy every second of it.DrMundo

Probably had more to do with having a competent team in the games I won.

Ice Weasel X1 votes

{quoted}

Probably had more to do with having a competent team in the games I won.

Think about that.

If you require a team of people who can perform well to do well yourself in most games against players at the same general MMR, then you aren't truly better than that MMR. If you can still do reasonably well even in a team that is not doing well, then you might be able to argue that you should be higher. That's still no guarantee, because KDA scores are worth nothing if you don't know when to push objectives.

But still, if you are doing just as badly in most cases, you're right where you should be.

Genet1c01 votes

[{quoted}](name=Ice Weasel X,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=4qsfuVPz,comment-id=000b00000000,timestamp=2015-03-06T21:23:00.118+0000)

Think about that.

If you require a team of people who can perform well to do well yourself in most games against players at the same general MMR, then you aren't truly better than that MMR. If you can still do reasonably well even in a team that is not doing well, then you might be able to argue that you should be higher. That's still no guarantee, because KDA scores are worth nothing if you don't know when to push objectives.

But still, if you are doing just as badly in most cases, you're right where you should be.

isn't LoL a team game?

Ice Weasel X1 votes

{quoted}

isn't LoL a team game?

Of course it is. But you still need to carry your own weight. Even if the other lanes all feed, that doesn't mean your lane opponent is immediately stronger. You still have a chance to win your lane before teamfighting makes you feel the consequences of the other lanes' losses.

Genet1c01 votes

[{quoted}](name=Ice Weasel X,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=4qsfuVPz,comment-id=000b0000000000000000,timestamp=2015-03-06T21:30:40.835+0000)

Of course it is. But you still need to carry your own weight. Even if the other lanes all feed, that doesn't mean your lane opponent is immediately stronger. You still have a chance to win your lane before teamfighting makes you feel the consequences of the other lanes' losses.

Some are actually do to that. Why don't people expect faker to win everygame? if he is the best? clearly team has influence more so than skill.

Ice Weasel X2 votes

{quoted}

Some are actually do to that. Why don't people expect faker to win everygame? if he is the best? clearly team has influence more so than skill.

Yes, the team overall should be the major factor for a game. Faker probably wouldn't win every game if he played a smurf account from Gold to Diamond. What he would do is perform extraordinarily in comparison to the other players, even in games where his teammates fed hard. You won't see him with a 1/9/0, even in Challenger games. He wouldn't win every game, but he would still climb. He'd do well enough that he could partially make up for teammates' shortcomings.

The way the MMR system works, you have to show that you can do that. Can you partially make up for teammates' shortcomings consistently? Be enough of a factor to nudge your team to victory. You might ride coattails for a game or two, you might be completely unable to carry some, but consistent performance above your current MMR's average will eventually promote you.

Linthe2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Ice Weasel X,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=4qsfuVPz,comment-id=000b000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2015-03-06T21:39:47.458+0000)

Yes, the team overall should be the major factor for a game. Faker probably wouldn't win every game if he played a smurf account from Gold to Diamond. What he would do is perform extraordinarily in comparison to the other players, even in games where his teammates fed hard. He wouldn't win every game, but he would still climb. He'd do well enough that he could partially make up for teammates' shortcomings.

The way the MMR system works, you have to show that you can do that. Can you partially make up for teammates' shortcomings consistently? Be enough of a factor to nudge your team to victory. You might ride coattails for a game or two, you might be completely unable to carry some, but consistent performance above your current MMR's average will eventually promote you.

This. Major upvote. Look up some of Bjergsen's challenger results. iirc he went 21-4 and LOST. Impossible to carry hard enough.

S H A Y C 01 votes

I think the point he was making is that, if you can only do well if everyone is doing well than you aren't being held down by the mmr system. If you are truly better than everybody in your mmr, the majority of your losing games will still look pretty good.

example: win 20-5-9 loss 9-4-5

if your losses look more like 1-9-5 as a carry champion (support is a whole other discussion) and we are talking about averages or "most" of your games, then we can say that you are at or possibly below the mmr your being matched at.

if your kda is really good in both your wins and losses, then the issue is a combination of failing to take objectives (not neutral objectives, just the ones that win the game "towers, inhib, nexus") and your team mates playing poorly AND failing at objectives.

But it isnt the mmr that makes people not understand the game. You can only directly control YOU. So win or lose, the only thing you should be analyzing is your own performance. Continue to improve yourself and you will get good enough to carry 4 turds and advance.

you referenced faker. Faker could open an account today and purposefuly tank his promos and carry his account to plat/diamond in a month or so. Why is this? shouldnt the mmr system match him with 4 morons and prevent him from advancing because its a team game and if 4 people suck super bad its their fault and you can never win...right? Well, it appears that you can get good enough to carry yourself and your turd team until you are matched with more competent team mates.

so the answer to your question is....its on you dawg

Nomad Wanderer1 votes

They can't have it both ways.

Either League is a Team game, and a single player cannot make a significant difference in winning or losing. or League is a game where an individual can make a significant difference in winning or losing.

I think it's the latter. BTW.

But that also means that if nasus goes 3/16/6 by 20 mins to akali @ top lane, there is very little you can do.

Here's my match history of almost 99% ranked games.
http://matchhistory.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/#match-history/NA/342741

I just had a game where the capt afk'd in the lobby, missing a ban. Intermittently he would just sit at the tower afk'ing.. In total the other 4 players died 16 times in 14 mins. While, my first death is @ 13 mins to a gank from a fizz who already had 3 kills.

It is not possible for a single person to over come that.

**What's your answer? just a bad game move on? **

It's more than just play better. it's also hoping you get players that care.

Bronze is full of people who can't fall any further/have nothing else to lose. It's full of people who DGaF, and say 'just a bad game move on.. 99% of the time'.

that random element of getting 4 other players on your team that don't afk, don't rage about blue being taken by mid and throw the game, don't rage abut kayle's ult saving the ADC vs the tank, that's the random element that keeps people stuck in bronze...

**it takes a long time to consistently draw enough players who care, to win series to get to players who care more often. **

MigYalle1 votes

You can't keep blaming your teams. Once it's mid-late game your decision can decide the entire match. (Currrently trying to climb out of Bronze. Started Bronze V this season, now in Bronze 2, just won promos.)

Genet1c01 votes

Here is my most recent matches literally just finished playing them today. I finally got to a series and then the first game I got camped super hard which shut me down pretty hard which also resulted in a less than stellar play by me. The rengar jungler was horrible as 2 other people in that game agreed. The other loss was single handedly lost due the hecarim. There was a team fight over first dragon happening and he sits mid farming for minutes while the team is contesting dragon. This ultimately led the enemy team to getting 5 kills and the dragon and our team getting 0 kills and nothing. On top of that my lane was the only lane doing well... Anyone sure there isn't something that caps peoples mmr? Both loss results can be found at the top of this post.

Genet1c01 votes

And how is this game winnable?

Genet1c01 votes

Clearly this loss is not at all due to the lux with clarity not mentioning her kda...

Genet1c01 votes

To prove my jinx capabilities here is a game from a few days ago where I had to 1v2 a bot lane with no support and won. Again this was only winnable cause of a competent team.

Nomad Wanderer1 votes

Feel Free to look me up.

http://matchhistory.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/#match-history/NA/342741

In bronze, there is no way to go lower. People AFK all the time. (Just had 4 afk's in a row, 1 game was a double afk), of those 4, 2 games had the same exact player afk. We all reported him, and he just requeued, and afk'd again.

People rage and quit over having their blue taken by mid, people say "it's my time, I can spend it 100% in top lane all game if I want to"

it's a complete mess.

There is no penalty, not recourse... There is no Tin league. So you get teammates that dont bother ...

whats the worse that can happen? there is a limit to the amount they can be penalized...

@ the bottom of b5, people should be forced to win 3 coop vs ai games before they can requeue.

Genet1c01 votes

So check out much LP I lost from this 4v5. Leona quit the game before minions ever spawned!

More from Gameplay

More by Genet1c0