Skip to content

Competitive Ruling: DT Papa Chau, ENX k3soju, ENX Impactful

Riot··3 votes·15,635 views

TL;DR: DT Papa Chau, ENX k3soju, and ENX Impactful are being penalized for Elo Boosting.

Context

On June 10, we conducted a sweep of accounts to check for Account Sharing and Elo Boosting.  On June 16, a secondary sweep was conducted that resulted in additional account bans.  The two sweeps included accounts belonging to John "Papa Chau" Le, Michael “k3soju” Zhang, and Josh “Impactful” Mabrey.  All three players’ accounts were found to be in violation of rules concerning Elo Boosting. Papa Chau and k3soju were both found to have been boosting for a brief period, while Impactful was found to have boosted significantly more than the other two players.

As defined in the Global Penalty Index, Elo Boosting is defined as assuming control of another person’s account for the purpose of raising their ranked queue rating in exchange for material personal gain.  When there is no material gain, using another person’s account constitutes Account Sharing, which carries a lesser penalty per the North American Penalty Index.

As a reminder, there is no minimum number of games required to be played, nor a minimum amount of Elo gain necessary to qualify as Elo Boosting. An attempt to boost Elo need not be successful in order to qualify as a rule violation.

Ruling

Per the Global Penalty Index, Elo Boosting carries a suspension range of 3-20 competitive months. Papa Chau and k3soju will be penalized with the minimum suspension of 3 competitive months.  Impactful will be suspended for 4 competitive months.

Papa Chau and k3soju were suspended on June 10.  They will each be up for review on September 10, 2016.

Impactful was suspended on June 16.  He will be up for review on October 16, 2016.

Given the conclusive evidence against each of these players, they were suspended immediately upon discovery while League officials sought to complete the wider Elo Boosting investigation. Now that the full investigation has been completed, the full suspension has been levied and the ruling posted.

Relevant Rules

From the CS Rules:

9.2.7 Player Behavior Investigation

If CS or Riot determines that a Team or Team Member has violated the Summoner’s Code, the LoL Terms of Service, or other rules of LoL, CS officials may assign penalties at their sole discretion.

Q&A

What about other recently banned players?

Esports rulings are only made against players who are, or are attempting to become, an official Team Member in a Riot-affiliated competition. While some of the other players banned may have been involved in Account Sharing or Elo Boosting, they will not be added to the ruling until and unless they attempt to join a team in a Riot-affiliated competition, at which point they would be further investigated and dealt with accordingly. No other professional player, either in CS or LCS, was determined to be involved in Elo Boosting.

What happens to players who were only account sharing?
All players implicated in account sharing received a first and final warning against further account sharing, the minimum punishment per the NA Penalty Index.  These warnings are listed on the CS Penalty Tracker and LCS Penalty Tracker respectively.

14 Comments

jinxedchef2 votes

Wait, is elo boosting still illegal considering you can just do it by grouping into a premade? I thought DQ made this a moot point.

TotalJerk2 votes

DAE FUCK DYNAMIC BOOST

ShadowX743 votes

This is specifically someone else using your account and you paying them to boost your account. Read.

TrollFan012 votes

Dou and premade aren't elo boosting. That's having help from better players to help you climb the elo ladder. Boosting is having others do it for you on your account.

woodvsmurph1 votes

Can people get boosted via premades? Yes. But the amount they can get boosted by is limited. Elo boosting can result in a much higher amount of boosting and hurts the boosted player's teammates regardless of if they are in a premade or not. Theoretically, each ranked match is balanced in terms of overall skill among each team. Thus one team may be 2 gold 5 and 3 silver 3 while their opponent team may be 4 silver 1 and a silver 2. While the silver 2 might be facing a gold 5 in lane and be theoretically at a disadvantage, the teams overall are balanced. When you play in a premade, this doesn't affect finding opponents whose teamwide skill averages out to be the same as that of your premade team. When elo boosting though, you could have a diamond or a challenger that is factored in as a gold or bronze because the balancing program used by the game doesn't realize it isn't the gold or silver player using their account. Thus the teams are not theoretically balanced the way they would be in a premade and the team with the elo-booster is at a large advantage. I say "theoretically" with all this because anyone who has played a decent number of ranked games knows that some matches are well balanced and others are most definitely not balanced.

If that doesn't make it completely clear, let me give you a theoretical scenario for each below (top, jungle, mid, bot, sup): premade scenario bronze 2 vs silver 4, bronze 1 vs silver 3, silver 4 vs bronze 1, silver 4 vs bronze 2, silver 5 vs bronze 3 boosted scenario diamond4 (seen as bronze 2 by matchmaking/balancing program) vs silver 4, bronze 1 vs silver 3, silver 4 vs bronze 1, silver 4 vs bronze 2, platinum 2 (seen as silver 5) vs bronze 3

Thus the silver 4 in toplane is actually at a SERIOUS disadvantage when they should have a decent advantage according to matchmaking/balancing. Similarly, the bronze 3 support is at a HUGE disadvantage when they should only have a MINOR disadvantage. That's how elo boosting differs from premades.

ElysMustache1 votes

Link broken for me.

RiotTiza2 votes

Which link? Just tested and they look fine to me.

ElysMustache1 votes

Working now on my PC. The "show more" link at the bottom of the Boards post gave me a 500 error earlier from my phone.

Smart Kitty1 votes

{quoted}

Working now on my PC. The "show more" link at the bottom of the Boards post gave me a 500 error earlier from my phone.

Did the same for me too yesterday, even when i went to the esports site and clicked on the article, it kept giving me that 500 error with gangster twitch. It is working now though :)

warpenguin5551 votes

RIP

TrollFan011 votes

They and their team lucked out they're locked out of the playoffs and won't have to worry about this hurting them.

Between now and 4 months is Worlds and then they can focus on re-qualifying for the NACS.

Loli Pleasure1 votes

What happened to their accounts?

Miror B1 votes

Not too big in terms of challenger news. ENX was already an incredibly bad challenger team, so the bans don't hurt them too much whereas Chau's 2 games (albeit good) were against the aformentioned ENX, muddling his stats.

Pessoa1 votes

How does Riot or the CS determine an Account Sharer and a Smurf Account?

I know this didn't happen to the players stated but just curious

More from Esports