Skip to content

Small concern over one of new GP's voice lines

Calamity Witch··10 votes·5,721 views
http://images.wikia.com/leagueoflegends/images/f/f2/Gangplank.tauntMissFortune01.ogg

So the voice line in the link is a taunt GP can say when taunting near an enemy Miss Fortune. I do appreciate having a reference to one of his old lines, but I find this line a little problematic. Mainly cause it implies that Gangplank is going to rape Miss Fortune. I honestly don't know how to feel about this. On the one hand, it would fit with GP's new character since he's a pirate and a horrible person, just like pirates in real life. On the other hand, it just feels kind of gross having this be a thing in the game. I'm not saying the line should be removed because, like I just said, I don't know how to feel about the matter. I just wanted to make this post so Riot would be aware of the issue, because I have a feeling they didn't really think this through.

64 Comments

Calamity Witch1 votes

That's why I'm on the fence about the issue, because Gangplank's new character is that he's a horrible asshole.

Matezoide8 votes

And heres the thing, since we were young, society has taught us that women are perfect beings that should never be harmed in anyway.

Thats why you are on the fence here. You were raised to believe that, somehow, killing a men is less of a sin that harming a woman. I have seen a guy saying, non-sarcastically, the he is perfectly willing to kill a man in self-defense, but would never do anything to a woman regardless of the situation. The fact i actually got downvoted for saying that "A blade in the gut solves most problems.'' is less problematic than a taunt that may or may not be a rape threat is further evidence of this.

Gangplank's lines are far more horrible than a possible implied rape, you have no logical reason to feel uncofortable with that line.

Just try to think about it and you will feel better once you realise that.

Calamity Witch2 votes

I didn't really ever think of it in terms how men and women are treated in terms of violence. I'm on the fence because it makes sense for GP to threaten to rape someone because pirates rape people. On the other hand, rape is gross and disgusting (no matter who it happens to). Something I did remember is that in Gangplank's old lore he and Miss Fortune are sort of allies. If that's the case after the rework then the taunt becomes really fucked up.

GreenLore4 votes

They are and always were archenemies.

I think MF did know GP when she was smaller and they did team up trying to defend Bilgewater,but that doesn't mean they are still on friendly terms.

Calamity Witch2 votes

In the old lore the extent of their rivalry was GP wasn't falling for MF's charms, and the disagreed on Bilgewater politics. Listening to all the other taunts this seem to be actual enemies now.

GreenLore1 votes

Miss Fortune is a bounty hunter and GP is a notorious Pirate,who most likely has a huge bounty on his head.(Not to mention that MF had a bad experience with pirates and doesn't trust them)

In the old lore they were on rather neutral terms,simply because GP wasn't an actual pirate anymore,he had to give up his pirate business to become a champion,so he was protected by the league and there was no reason for MF to go after him anymore.

NorthernDruid9 votes

Rape culture.

That's why references to rape are more problematic than references to violence.

With the scope of the playerbase there's likely a lot of actual rape/abuse victims who play the game. Not so much with murder vitcims for obvious reasons. It's easy to take threats of violence at face value in a game about over-the-top fantasy violence.

There's no problem with Gangplank threatening to feed Miss Fortune her own guts, because it's a trauma no one playing or discussing the game can relate to (at least I hope so, if i'm wrong please don't correct me, I don't want my illusion broken there).

I'm sure there are people playing league who can relate to trauma about rape however. And a by default protagonist (by being a character in a video game who you strive to make sucessful) in a video game is not someone you want to promote rape, not even simply indirectly hint at it.

It's a game about killing people, over and over again. References to and threats made by the various characters about doing so are fine.

It's not a game about raping people. And references to and threats made by the various characters about doing so are not automatically fine by the same standard.

If it is a rape threat, by riot's own judgement, then I really don't think it's appropriate for the game, even as much as it is appropriate for Gangplank, or just pirates in general.

Zarxis2 votes

{quoted}

There's no problem with Gangplank threatening to feed Miss Fortune her own guts, because it's a trauma no one playing or discussing the game can relate to (at least I hope so, if i'm wrong please don't correct me, I don't want my illusion broken there).

Is there any other champion that owns a ship in LoL? Particularly one with any connection to Gangplank.

"Prepare to be boarded" should remain among Gangplank's new VO lines, and it makes sense that it would be directed at Miss Fortune because it's quite likely that they've boarded each other's ships before. I doubt Riot would put in a direct implication of rape— they're nowhere near being that insensitive.

That line is obviously not meant to be a threat of rape. If you feel that it is, that's still no reason for it to be removed from the game. There are actual victims of physical/non-sexual violence that play this game, as well as victims of sexual violence. If we were to remove everything that could possibly remind victims of non-sexual violence of their experiences, this game would cease to exist.

There are people out there that do have a problem with Gangplank threatening to "feed Miss Fortune her own guts" because that is a threat of violence. That doesn't mean Gangplank should be castrated as a character.

DG Ashabel3 votes

Gangplank being castrated as a character is a bit overdramatic, isn't it? While that line of his is pretty iconic, it's just one line and I don't think removing it would hinder his character.

That said, I do agree that the line should stay. In my opinion, this case would be very easy to fix by simply changing the line so it's a general taunt instead of one that applies to Fortune only. That way would mean it would be around in the same context as before the VU, there would no longer be odd implications associated with applying it to Fortune only and everyone would be happy.

Zarxis1 votes

[{quoted}](name=DG Ashabel,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=BnqAaIHo,comment-id=000000000000000100000000,timestamp=2015-07-10T00:42:16.569+0000)

Gangplank being castrated as a character is a bit overdramatic, isn't it? While that line of his is pretty iconic, it's just one line and I don't think removing it would hinder his character.

That said, I do agree that the line should stay. In my opinion, this case would be very easy to fix by simply changing the line so it's a general taunt instead of one that applies to Fortune only. That way would mean it would be around in the same context as before the VU, there would no longer be odd implications associated with applying it to Fortune only and everyone would be happy.

I meant that Gangplank losing all of his lines because his constant threats of violence bother victims of actual violence would be a castrating of him as a character, not the loss of his "prepare to be boarded" line.

I'd be fine with the line being moved elsewhere, as well, but I don't think doing so is necessary because there is no credible reason to remove its currently-proposed incarnation. Assumed [incorrect] context is not a reason to remove/change content, otherwise Riot would have to do something about every single line mentioned in all of those threads in which people make random champion lines sound suggestive.

Calamity Witch2 votes

Like I said, I appreciate having one of his old voice lines be a part of his new voice over. But in the context it's currently used, it's kind of gross. I also doubt Riot put this voice line in to be interpreted the way I interpreted it. But I did, and so did others. I think this is an honest mistake on Riot's part. I'm not even saying the voice line should be removed, just that it would probably be a better idea to re-record it under a different context (GP shouting Prepare to Be Boarded while autoing or using Parrrley?). Also, the violence in League is very unrealistic. Yeah people get lit on fire and shit all the time, but the champs don't react the way someone in real life would to getting lit on fire or getting shot by a giant ice arrow, which makes it a lot easier for people to stomach, victims of violence or not.

Zarxis1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Pretzel Baroness,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=BnqAaIHo,comment-id=000000000000000100000001,timestamp=2015-07-10T00:46:14.709+0000)

Like I said, I appreciate having one of his old voice lines be a part of his new voice over. But in the context it's currently used, it's kind of gross. I also doubt Riot put this voice line in to be interpreted the way I interpreted it. But I did, and so did others. I think this is an honest mistake on Riot's part. I'm not even saying the voice line should be removed, just that it would probably be a better idea to re-record it under a different context (GP shouting Prepare to Be Boarded while autoing or using Parrrley?). Also, the violence in League is very unrealistic. Yeah people get lit on fire and shit all the time, but the champs don't react the way someone in real life would to getting lit on fire or getting shot by a giant ice arrow, which makes it a lot easier for people to stomach, victims of violence or not.

You're the one coming up with this context— it's not what Riot intended. That's like saying that Warwick's quote "it's only fun if they run" is a meant to be about rape— it's not. It's about chasing people that are running away because Warwick is hunting them. Gangplank's quote is a reference to the fact that both he and Miss Fortune are ship captains.

Also, the violence in League is very unrealistic.

If Gangplank shoots a critically-low-health enemy with his Parrrley, they die. There might not be blood spewing everywhere, but he just killed someone. That's realistic enough to bother someone who's been a victim of gun violence. Also, does "prepare to be boarded" sound like a realistic way to say "I'm going to rape you"? It should be very easy to stomach Gangplank saying "Prepare to be boarded" if you consider the fact that it's not meant to be a rape threat. The violence in League is meant to actually cause harm (even death) to other champions.

Calamity Witch1 votes

I know Riot didn't intend the line to sounds like a rape threat, but that's what the delivery of it sounds like.

I don't really have anything to say on the point of League's violence cause I don't really know what point you're trying to make.

Lastly, listen to the voice line, cause I can tell you haven't.

Zarxis1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Pretzel Baroness,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=BnqAaIHo,comment-id=00000000000000010000000100000000,timestamp=2015-07-10T01:50:41.347+0000)

I know Riot didn't intend the line to sounds like a rape threat, but that's what the delivery of it sounds like.

I don't really have anything to say on the point of League's violence cause I don't really know what point you're trying to make.

Lastly, listen to the voice line, cause I can tell you haven't.

It sounds like a rape threat to you, not to me, and probably not to the vast majority of people who will ever hear it because most people don't go about their lives hunting for anything that would potentially offend other people. If you've actually been raped, and that line offends you, I sincerely apologize for your misfortune. However, I don't think your sensitivities are any more valid than those of victims of violence— and I believe there are far more instances of violence in League that suggestions of rape.

I have listened to the entirety of Gangplank's new VO once, and I have specifically gone back to listen to that specific line two extra times. I am convinced that you are inserting false context into it, and, again that's not a valid reason to change the line.

Calamity Witch1 votes

I don't live my life hunting for things that might offend other people. i heard the line and it's delivery and thought to myself "I wonder what other people think of this, and Riot should probably consider the possible interpretations."

I started this thread on the fence about the issue, being made uncomfortable about the implication I heard, while on the other hand seeing it as very fitting for GP's new character. Whether or not anything said in this thread is a valid reason to change the line isn't up to either of us, it's up to Riot.

Also, I've been very fortunate to not be a victim of any violence, which is pretty rare for being a trans-woman. So, no need to apologize for any misfortune (I see what you did there >.>)

Zarxis1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Pretzel Baroness,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=BnqAaIHo,comment-id=0000000000000001000000010000000000000000,timestamp=2015-07-10T02:18:59.705+0000)

I don't live my life hunting for things that might offend other people. i heard the line and it's delivery and thought to myself "I wonder what other people think of this, and Riot should probably consider the possible interpretations."

I started this thread on the fence about the issue, being made uncomfortable about the implication I heard, while on the other hand seeing it as very fitting for GP's new character. Whether or not anything said in this thread is a valid reason to change the line isn't up to either of us, it's up to Riot.

Also, I've been very fortunate to not be a victim of any violence, which is pretty rare for being a trans-woman. So, no need to apologize for any misfortune (I see what you did there >.>)

Riot probably already has considered the possible interpretations of that line (they take quite some time to develop new dialogue, kits, champions, etc.), and they've dismissed this possibility because it's not their intended context. They probably believe that they can trust us to not force our interpretations upon their character. What they decide is Gangplank's reason for saying that line to Miss Fortune is canon (again, they obviously won't make rape the official motivation of the line), and they shouldn't have to change their characters because we falsely assume something about them. Consider how Taric is often assumed to be gay, and the fan theory that Diana and Leona are lovers— should Riot be forced to stomp out those possibilities completely just because homosexuality is taboo in some LoL-playing regions/countries?

I have another angle for you to consider.

What is your opinion on books with content that can be interpreted in a manner that is offensive? What if the author didn't mean for that to be the actual meaning behind his/her book? Whether that was the author's intention or not, should the book be censored, making any interpretation and values of the book ("good" or "bad") unavailable to anyone? We already know that Riot did not intend for Gangplank to insinuate rape.

Calamity Witch1 votes

Dismiss a possible interpretation just cause you didn't intend it to be interpreted that way is an incredibly arrogant way to handle things. And when it comes to censorship, it really depends on how the media is presented. The Wold of Wall Street is a fantastic movie, and yet all the characters in it are horrible people. Doesn't mean we're supposed to like them, or that the makers of the movie condone their actions, they're just telling a story. With League, including character who are assholes is kind of a tough thing to do, since we control those characters. The reason this line bothers me is I'm really excited for this rework, but with this line being a part of things, I can't help but feel uncomfortable to be playing one of my favourite champs in the game.

And saying Riot spend a lot of time developing dialogue is subjective. If they did, Ekko probably wouldn't have so many stereotypically negative lines like "I hate being responsible," "Ahhh, who called the cops?" "You're in the wrong neighbourhood."

Zarxis1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Pretzel Baroness,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=BnqAaIHo,comment-id=000000000000000100000001000000000000000000000000,timestamp=2015-07-10T03:12:58.697+0000)

Dismiss a possible interpretation just cause you didn't intend it to be interpreted that way is an incredibly arrogant way to handle things. And when it comes to censorship, it really depends on how the media is presented. The Wold of Wall Street is a fantastic movie, and yet all the characters in it are horrible people. Doesn't mean we're supposed to like them, or that the makers of the movie condone their actions, they're just telling a story. With League, including character who are assholes is kind of a tough thing to do, since we control those characters. The reason this line bothers me is I'm really excited for this rework, but with this line being a part of things, I can't help but feel uncomfortable to be playing one of my favourite champs in the game.

And saying Riot spend a lot of time developing dialogue is subjective. If they did, Ekko probably wouldn't have so many stereotypically negative lines like "I hate being responsible," "Ahhh, who called the cops?" "You're in the wrong neighbourhood."

Dismissing a possible interpretation just because you didn't intend for it to be interpreted that way is perfectly normal and reasonable— otherwise, nearly everything would have to be changed due to its possible meaning as a sexual innuendo.

By your logic about the Wolf of Wall Street, the line should stay even if it is an insinuation of rape because that would fit Gangplank's new character. You should feel uncomfortable playing him (rape insinuation or no rape insinuation) because he is a murderer, thief, pillager, despot, and likely a rapist whether that possibility is acknowledged or not.

You are the one making the connection between Ekko and real-world stereotypes. He could say all of the same lines if he was white, and they would be perfectly fitting, given his character. Riot's effectively challenging such stereotypes by forcing us to face them and simply dismiss them because Ekko is not portrayed as evil, intentionally malicious, etc. He's just a typical (other than his inborn mechanical genius) rebellious teenager growing up in close-knit group in an extremely hostile environment.

DG Ashabel6 votes

Gangplank's lines are far more horrible than a possible implied rape, you have no logical reason to feel uncofortable with that line.

I'm sorry, but what the hell?

USA has over 10,000 cases of sexual violence reported to the police per month on average. Numerous lives were destroyed those cases. For many people, even thinking about the topic makes them uncomfortable because there is likely someone they know who survived sexual violence.

There is in fact no logical reason for them to not feel uncomfortable because a threat of rape is one that can be received in real life, as opposed to threats of being stabbed by a burning cutlass, shot with magical cannonballs and shot with an antique powderkeg pistols, which are all completely ridiculous fictional experiences.

By comparing a terrible and very traumatizing crime which is perpetrated multiple times per week to something that can only happen in fiction, you are essentially trivializing it. That in itself is a very harmful gesture.

Matezoide2 votes

Yeah, being stabbed by a knife is such an impossible scenario.

Death is death, it doesnt matter the means. Getting shot by a powderkeg pistol or a regular gun changes nothing, the end result is the same.

DG Ashabel3 votes

Gangplank doesn't "stab someone with a knife," neither does he "shoot someone with a regular gun".

The key to portraying violence in fiction is in how it's delivered. By wrapping violence in a scenario that cannot happen in real life, the player is effectively shielded from the potential trauma of the experience. When the violence is delivered via impossible means, it is clearly telegraphed as "not real".

That doesn't make violence good. What it does is make violence easy to process without receiving an emotional whiplash. It's why games that are set in modern day conflict scenarios, such as Spec Ops, Far Cry 2-3 and Call of Duty are more commonly discussed among psychologists. Because unlike Quake and Shadow Warrior, they expose the player to something that could theoretically happen.

Such care in dampening the experience isn't used in this case. Gangplank is very clearly a human who is threatening to rape another human, which happens in real life all the time and lacks the dampening effect provided by his "exaggerated pirate" design to the rest of his threats.

And you are still essentially comparing rape to being shot at by magical cannonballs. Seriously, doing that is pretty bad.

NorthernDruid2 votes

Also, threatening someone with death on the Fields of Justice isn't very much of a threat, considering they'll be fighting fit again as soon as their summoner recovers from the shock.

Silents4294 votes

Are you really trying to go this direction with it.

Really.

Calamity Witch2 votes

I think it's worth it for Riot to consider it

Silents4292 votes

I just listened to his entire VO not one line sounded rapey, and these links don't play for me, so what's the quote you refer to?

Calamity Witch1 votes

Yeah my bad on the link. Let me link you the wiki pages where you can play the individual lines. http://leagueoflegends.wikia.com/wiki/Gangplank/Background Select PBE to listen to the new voice lines. It's near the bottom under "Taunting an enemy Miss Fortune"

Silents4293 votes

Yeah that's a stretch. Get your mind out of the gutter.

Calamity Witch1 votes

Saying that my mind is in the gutter is implying I'm thinking about sex. But rape isn't sex.

Silents4293 votes

Having your mind in the gutter is thinking things as obscene. Which is what you are currently doing.

There is no hidden rape innuendo in this, and current GP has A LOT more in his VO that sounds like innuendo and seems intentional to sound like it.

This is nothing more then being paranoid of something that wouldn't even have crossed more peoples mind.

"A captain telling another captain to prepare to be boarded? Why clearly he means to rape her!"

Calamity Witch3 votes

Miss Fortune isn't a ship captain, she a bounty hunter. Besides, you can't really tell someone there interpretation of something is wrong, because it's how they're processing that information. The entire point of creating this topic was to make Riot aware of potential issues including this one line in the game. Multiple people have interpreted this the same way I have, so it's probably worth it for Riot to consider how everyone will interpret it when new GP goes public.

Silents4295 votes

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-Lg4DrisMsPQ/VZz9WdfaFkI/AAAAAAAAFM8/BqjWSORDHpI/s1600/MissFortuneLoadScreen_8.jpg

Really? Because I thought someone called Captain Fortune would be captain. You know with a ship like every other pirate captain?

And who's agreeing with you? You have no upvotes on the topic and every comment is about how your wrong, interpret it how you want, but were telling you that you are scrapping the bottom of the barrel to make this appear rapey.

Calamity Witch1 votes

That's an optional skin. By using that logic, in the lore Gangplank is a Toy Ghost Sultan Special Ops Minuteman. And Cho'Cath is Deep Sea Monster Pile of Bones Prehistoric Lifeform Robot Gentleman. Skins aren't part of the lore.

As for who's agreeing with me, actually read everything that's posted here. Like, just read everything, go to the wiki page I linked in one of my replies to listen to the voice line in question, and really think about what it could mean.

Cissoid3 votes

How do you think Miss Fortune chases after her bounty in Bilgewater? She swims after them or something!?

Calamity Witch1 votes

So what if she has sex a lot? That doesn't make rape okay.

Cissoid4 votes

WTF are you talking about? She chases after her bounty on a SHIP because it's on Bilgewater, the PORT city

Cissoid3 votes

The point is that she has a ship

PREPARE TO BE BOARDED

all you keep thinking about is rape and sex get your head out of the gutter

Acolyte of Steel5 votes

{quoted}

The point is that she has a ship

PREPARE TO BE BOARDED

all you keep thinking about is rape and sex get your head out of the gutter

{quoted}

No this is you seeing what you want to see, Ms Fortune is the only character he taunts with a ship.

Get your mind out of the damn gutter.

Legit. I'm a woman, if it helps, and I didn't think of rape at all, considering GP's entire goal is to sink MF, since MF is the last person actively trying to shut down Bilgewater's pirating shenanigans, while GP wants to found a country on it. It's not about rape. It's about taking out his ultimate enemy - you know, the ONLY OTHER PERSON IN THE GAME WITH A SHIP?!

[{quoted}](name=Pretzel Baroness,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=BnqAaIHo,comment-id=000a0000,timestamp=2015-07-10T03:20:07.328+0000)

Regardless of intention, it can sound like a rape threat.

That's just as bad as a Dad chasing after his own toddler while playing tag, saying "Raawwrrr I'm a monster and I'm gonna eat you up!" oh no, Baroness you should go stop that cannibalism right away

Silents4292 votes

That's an optional skin. By using that logic, in the lore Gangplank is a Toy Ghost Sultan Special Ops Minuteman. And Cho'Cath is Deep Sea Monster Pile of Bones Prehistoric Lifeform Robot Gentleman. Skins aren't part of the lore.

Both of them have Visual Updates and reworks surrounding the upcoming event, he is referring to her ship. Even without the skin in mind she had a ship.

Why do you quote old lore? It's been retconned, this is new lore they are setting up, who cares what you might have read in the past, it doesn't matter anymore

As for who's agreeing with me, actually read everything that's posted here. Like, just read everything, go to the wiki page I linked in one of my replies to listen to the voice line in question, and really think about what it could mean.

I listened and read the lines, they don't sound even close to implied rape.

DG Ashabel4 votes

I don't see the issue with going on that direction with it. I was immensely bothered by that line as well.

I enjoyed "Prepare to be boarded." back when it was a generic and all-encompassing threat of violence against another person, because it matched his pirate character and made for decent wordplay. In the new voiceover, however, that line has been rewritten as a taunt against one very specific character, and that character happens to be the only woman he taunts. Therefore the context of it changes because it's no longer delivered as "I'm going to board and plunder this random dude," it's delivered as "I'm gonna board this woman, if you know what I mean."

Silents4294 votes

No this is you seeing what you want to see, Ms Fortune is the only character he taunts with a ship.

Get your mind out of the damn gutter.

DG Ashabel4 votes

Please tone down on the hostility. I didn't say anything to you personally, did I? I simply said it's fine to discuss the implications of that line and provided my explanation for why I think it's currently in a bad place.

The fact that multiple people have read that line in such a way still indicates that it's far too easily processed as a rape threat and is likely better off being changed, which would be easy by changing one line of code so the taunt is applied to everyone instead of just Fortune.

And as Pretzel Baroness said, rape is generally equated with violence rather than sex. Gutters aren't being involved.

Silents4295 votes

Your mind is in an obscene place, no one would have noticed until people start warping and twisting it as if it was anything like that.

As said above "A captain telling another captain to prepare to be boarded? Why clearly he means to rape her!"

It's sick people think the innocent of things must have some darker meaning to it.

DG Ashabel3 votes

No, what's sick is being abrasive toward someone who expressed discomfort with a line of dialogue, and continuing to do so after they asked you to stop with hostility. You are a very unfortunately warped person if you think that the right way to remove a person's discomfort with something is to insult them over it, and I don't think I want to discuss anything with you any further.

Silents4293 votes

See what you want to see, no one else here seems to see it the way you and OP are. (The only two so far)

Peridition4 votes

If this line were directed at a male champion you wouldn't even be minutely concerned over it.

Only Play Darius4 votes

That line is open to interpretation.

Calamity Witch2 votes

Indeed. That is why it can be interpreted the way I interpreted it.

stealthfox944 votes

Don't think that's what it's supposed to mean

More from Story, Art, & Sound

More by Calamity Witch