Skip to content

LP compensation

TheTombstone··7 votes·4,781 views

I wrote this suggestion to Riot Support over Twitter, they wanted me to post it here: A suggestion, from someone climbing out of silver. If someone on your team gets banned for toxicity/feeding/or whatever, make a system that undoes whatever you lost. There are some streaks of bad luck where you just get feeder after feeder in your game.

This could work in a number of ways, the easiest way would be something like this, if banned for feeding or being toxic, then a human/smart ai/good algorithm would go through the games the player lost starting from the first report they had against them for a few days before the ban. Once it's determined if that user fed or was extremely throwing in those games, it would give LP to the players on their team that were not queued up with them. It would give at least 50% (hopefully 100%, but just to avoid the chance people could abuse this.) of their lost lp back to them, show them a nice message like, "Someone in one of your recent games was banned, we are sorry you had to deal with that here's x LP."

Games like CS:GO manage to take wins away when you're grouped with a cheater, but never added them if someone on the other team was banned for cheating, I feel like League could implement something to compensate those that lost due to someone intentionally feeding.

PS: I just woke up, so if my grammar is a little bad, I'm sorry.

Original Post on Twitter

17 Comments

Kei1436 votes

On the flip side, are you willing to not gain LP if the enemy has a toxic person? Especially if it was a hard fought game and the toxic dude only exploded in the final moments of the game after they lost the final team fight.

TheTombstone2 votes

{quoted}

On the flip side, are you willing to not gain LP if the enemy has a toxic person? Especially if it was a hard fought game and the toxic dude only exploded in the final moments of the game after they lost the final team fight.

Another reason why I suggest 50% of the lp lost or a ratio of what you lost. If you lost 15, you get 10 back, if you lost 18, you'd get 12 back. The other team shouldn't get penalized for winning. This is to help the people out who get screwed every few games. I've gotten to a few series after winning 7 games in a row, only to have 2 feeders in the game. That intentionally fed.

TheTombstone1 votes

Also, remember that something should review the game to make sure it was intentional feeding/toxic enough to get that person banned.

The Cane Master2 votes

{quoted}

On the flip side, are you willing to not gain LP if the enemy has a toxic person? Especially if it was a hard fought game and the toxic dude only exploded in the final moments of the game after they lost the final team fight.

Nah, it should only affect the friendly team. So you cannot lose the won LP, but you can have your lost LP back if the said scenario occurs.

Chermorg3 votes

That would cause LP inflation. This sort of "guaranteed no loss" system does not work when enabled permanently in a transaction based system such as this which is roughly based on the Elo system.

The Cane Master2 votes

{quoted}

That would cause LP inflation. This sort of "guaranteed no loss" system does not work when enabled permanently in a transaction based system such as this which is roughly based on the Elo system.

What do you mean LP inflation? The only thing that would happen is that a really small minority of players would occasionally get their lost LP and MMR back.

Chermorg2 votes

A system like that would encourage players to AFK/leave games as players in lower Elo ratings don't tend to keep up with the rules such as "if you leave game your premade gets loss too" or similar.

Even if AFK/leave is the same rate as it is now, you still have some players getting LP back from this sort of game - which is not super super uncommon. While it would not be the end of the world, it is still an issue that would plague the LP system if this was implemented.

The Cane Master2 votes

{quoted}

A system like that would encourage players to AFK/leave games as players in lower Elo ratings don't tend to keep up with the rules such as "if you leave game your premade gets loss too" or similar.

Even if AFK/leave is the same rate as it is now, you still have some players getting LP back from this sort of game - which is not super super uncommon. While it would not be the end of the world, it is still an issue that would plague the LP system if this was implemented.

Nope, leaver buster will always be in place, thus making you get 20 min. lower priority queue every time you dodge. It is not worth it 10 LP and some MMR, trust me, I'm speaking from the personal experience. Now every time you'd wanna play with a lower priority queue guy you'd have to wait 20 min. plus the fact that sometimes you'll have to wait additional 20 minutes:

  1. if any of you interrupts the queue
  2. mistakenly tries to use in-game client
  3. doesn't accept the queue pop
  4. you have to dodge if there is a real troll in the next champ selection
  5. occasionally it bugs out and doesn't start the queue even after 20 min.
TheTombstone3 votes

So as you can see, Riot could implement this if they really wanted to.

Fructivore3 votes

{quoted}

It's not really days and days, but they may have time to enter another game or two - even for automated punishments.

Regardless, you still have not considered that the Elo based LP/MMR systems are both transactional systems - they work because LP is "exchanged" between the winning and losing teams in approximately the same amount. If you eliminate or even reduce LP loss for a losing team for any reason you're enlarging that gap - which would lead to LP inflation across the board, moving the "average" rank from mid-high silver up to gold, or even higher than that.

Then charge the trolling player all the LP that is refunded to the rest of the team. And if someone does wind up Bronze V with -1200 LP, you know who's on the short list to be permabanned.

{quoted}

Many of the punishments for intentionally feeding are not issued instantly but sometimes hours later, even days in some cases. How do you correct for this?

Furthermore, how do you prevent people afking and taking the LeaverBuster just so their team doesn't lose LP?

Because you can see that in chat, or you can notice a player with a suspicious pattern of it. And if a player does grind up a ton of fresh level 30 accounts just to sacrifice for his teammate, Riot will just have to deal with that as it happens.

Chermorg3 votes

Many of the punishments for intentionally feeding are not issued instantly but sometimes hours later, even days in some cases. How do you correct for this?

Furthermore, how do you prevent people afking and taking the LeaverBuster just so their team doesn't lose LP?

TheTombstone2 votes

Again, people who are queued up with said person that gets banned will not get the lp back. If someone afks, then they are still causing their team to lose. That only proves more why we need this. As for days and hours later on? Give them a smaller lp ratio. If they lost 15, give them 5 if 3 days goes by, but I doubt 3 days would go by.

Also, let me be clear, you are saying that people who mass intentionally feed/get reported still play for days and days after the first report? Because that would again strengthen the point that this system NEEDS to be in place. If one person can ruin the games of 20+ people in 3 hours, and that's only one person...

Chermorg2 votes

It's not really days and days, but they may have time to enter another game or two - even for automated punishments.

Regardless, you still have not considered that the Elo based LP/MMR systems are both transactional systems - they work because LP is "exchanged" between the winning and losing teams in approximately the same amount. If you eliminate or even reduce LP loss for a losing team for any reason you're enlarging that gap - which would lead to LP inflation across the board, moving the "average" rank from mid-high silver up to gold, or even higher than that.

TheTombstone2 votes

I think you over estimate how much LP would be given back to the players. It would be a way to show that Riot does actually care for players that get fucked by griefers, which to me, needs to be in place.

It's a "Hey, we know you played with someone that threw your game, we know they did it, it's shit when you get matched with people like that, here is some of what you lost back." The amount could be based on your kill participation, kda, a fixed ratio, whatever.

Do you know how much toxicity it breeds, when you are at 99 lp, and then loose the next game because someone decided to leave halfway through the next game after feeding each lane? The person at 99 lp is probably now tilted, goes into the next game, and gets more tilted when support locks in Jax with smite. Then they feel abandoned by Riot when each game they lost was poor match making. Then they become beyond tilted and int and int and int, all the while flamming. An endless cycle. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Wu4uVh-rUrg

Campingstove1 votes

How to address people that afk or taking LeaverBuster is simple, actually punish them appropriately with a progress set of punishments leading to permanent banning. The idea of the punishment of someone afk or quitting as a lower tier queue time is laughable and insulting to the other 9 people whose time was wasted not only the 30+ minutes of the game but also the loss of LP that was not deserved.

Imperial Pandaa1 votes

Doesn't the CSGO thing only apply if you fail to kick the cheater from the game?

TheTombstone1 votes

No, and as far as I am aware it's only if you are queued up said cheater.

More from Player Behavior

More by TheTombstone