[Client] Valid Zip Code Called Invalid When Purchasing RP With Card

So let me note that my zip code on my card is kind of weird, it's a usual 5 numbers, but it also has a - then 4 additional numbers added on to it. Because the store only accepts the usual 5 number zips I think my card is behaving weird because of it. I tried temporarily removing the additional 4 from my zip my card has, but that didn't seem to do anything. I'm positive my card worked fine in the past, but this was during a time when I think we put in our full address.