Can not have majority in one for all, 4/5 is ok but not 3/5

NorthenWolf·10/18/2015, 6:27:22 AM·2 votes·278 views

Don't think think 3/5 is fair to the other 2 players :/ I don't want to play taric all match....

And can we stop with the everyone wanting to play supports....

5 Comments

Mal the Red10/18/2015, 8:03:29 AM2 votes

3 out of 5 is a majority for the purposes of All for One.

And supports are actually really OP in this mode.

IcyPepper10/18/2015, 8:05:12 AM1 votes

What's wrong with supports? This is a fun game mode, let people be allowed to vote for who they want. It's just the same as five assassins, tanks, or mages. Nothing wrong with picking any of those, so why not supports?

Lapis10/18/2015, 8:13:05 AM1 votes

Supports are great in one for all though?? Had a game as a team of Sona. It was utter destruction. Felt sorry for the other team.

GetMariahCarried10/18/2015, 7:34:49 PM1 votes

Look, if you add teambuild to OfA, this problem evaporates. The people who want to play supports GET to play supports with people who ACTUALLY WANT to play supports as well. The people who want to play assassins GET to play assassins with people who actually want to play assassins as well. Need something more specific? Make it a champ-pick teambuild. Resolves the nonsense of 60% of the like-minded player base deciding the roles for the other 40% all the time in almost every game. All you have to do is re-arrange who is matched with who. This isn't hard.

I've suggested this elsewhere, but nobody seems to bite, and a couple people downvote. And yet I keep seeing posts like this one. Do people want this fixed or not? I know I do. But if no one has a better idea than to whine about other people's picks, we're not gonna get anywhere. This isn't a problem with the playerbase. People should pick what they want to play, not cater to the whims of the minority like us. But the minority shouldn't suffer for no reason either. It's a problem with the matchmaking process. You're not being "matched" based on anything. You're just being screwed.

Abyssphere10/19/2015, 12:52:27 AM1 votes

Well what do you want to do when it's 3/5 then? The current system just ensures you'll definitely get a definitive choice.