Frostblade Irelia Ice Shards look like plastic toys from the dollar store.
I'm late to this argument. I saw Riot said this:
We’re seeing some negative response to this decision, but we still believe that making her this frozen warrior slashing with giant ice shards will be an awesome skin for her.
What I want to know is: Where are the giant ice shards? Those things DO NOT LOOK LIKE ICE even thematically. They're just dark blue oblong plastic things. They're ugly and awful and I will demand a refund if they go in like that.