Shen no recall animation?

KeyLimePies··92 votes·4,668 views

Not sure what board to put this in, but as Shen is getting a VU, shouldn't he get a recall animation? I'm not sure if Rito has said anything about this, or if anyone has the same complaint, because I haven't seen any. I just think he should get one.

35 Comments

Windi22 votes

just recycle the ult animation gg

Nahara3 votes

While I think said animation would be totally appropriate, I can't help but feel some people might cry "clarity" or something.

Probably someone salty who blew his flash to "stop Stand United" only to realize Shen was just trying to recall...

Ironclad Dragon14 votes

There's no glowing purple though. VFX are a big thing, so I think it's permissible.

Nahara4 votes

Never underestimate the power of a stupid person.

But yes, I agree, it should be permissible.

Gapybo11 votes

They don't give recall animations to champions who get partial VU (model and texture update). Shen is the same as Fiora, Alistair, Kassadin, Maokai and Miss Fortune were. They just update the existing model and animations, unlike complete relaunches, like Poppys, who get a complete fresh model and everything.

I also find that a bit silly, there is nothing actually limiting them from giving these champions recall animations. So it feels a bit half assed on their part. It's not like these champions will see another update in years to come considering all the backlog of outdated champions. Why not do it while you are at it and be done with it, right? I feel their approach to this could be more throughout. If only they added animations for Shen's joke and recall plus a new VO, then he would be completely up to date.

ModKnightsKemplar3 votes

I don't disagree with you, but that also delays the amount of time they have to work on other things. It's not like they can also just up Shen's recall animation for free. Those things take time.

You aren't wrong, but I feel like I can argue both ways. I understand them.

Solerian8 votes

I'm disappointed by this too, as I would have loved Miss Fortune to receive one herself. I feel like these animations should be standard at this point, at the very least on the default skin.

PeponiPoro1 votes

I too agree with this, but it is unfortunately Riot's selling point on the newer champion. This is ridiculous to me, but I think they believe the champion with the highest prices should have the best animations.

KaisadiIIa4 votes

Poppy and Sion cost 1350 IP (in fact I think Poppy costs 450 IP but I'm not sure).

Stop calling RIOT greedy because RIOT can make a lot of errors, but they are definitely not greedy. If they were greedy, they would have raise full-reworked champions' like Sion cost to 6300 IP, because "it's a new champ actually".

RIOT gives recall animations when they do large-scale visual reworks, like Karthus. They don't give them new animations for visual updates, like Shen. With Shen they've just upgraded the quality of his visuals, but he's the same.

PeponiPoro1 votes

I never called them greedy. When did I say that? I love LoL, however frustrating it may get. I understand that they only give them recall animation if it is a full rework. Just wish that wasn't the case. At the time of writing my comment I may have been slightly frustrated.

Unpaladin7 votes

He didn't even get a Joke animation. It's kinda sad.

Virgin Ray1 votes

Well technically he is the Eye of Twilight. According to lore, the eye of twilight doesn't have emotions. Its apart of the job.

Knightwing86101 votes

HE DIDNT EVEN GET NEW VOICE LINES!

Nixzilla5 votes

He does have one, its just so fast you cant see it. [slayer-jinx-catface]

Weiner the Pooh3 votes

hes not getting one, if he gets one then so should Fiora and MF as both got VU's w/out a recall

Captain Aishi2 votes

riot's animation team feels really inconsistent... katarina's rework gave her a recall animation, garen's VU gave him one, so did master yi, soraka, sivir, nasus and twitch

meanwhile champs like annie and renekton didn't get one

the difference between both categories is that in the 1st one, the champions got updated animations for the rest of their kits. walk and attack animations too.. meaning that shen should also fit in that category

DemiluniS1 votes

riot's animation team feels really inconsistent... katarina's rework gave her a recall animation, garen's VU gave him one, so did master yi, soraka, sivir, nasus and twitch

Actually they are pretty consistent depends on the scale of the VU. katarina, garen, master yi, sivir, nasus, twitch, tristana, recieved a full scale VU, with new VO, new emotes etc

Sona, Renek, MF, Maokai, Singed etc Just recieved new models

I understand that a recall animation is a nice addition but it's not a "must have". They'd rather put those resources somewhere else

btw, annie does have a recall animation

Magic Star2 votes

I feel like it wouldn't take much to give him one

PeponiPoro1 votes

Seems like that should be the case. They should hire some interns that just come animate older champions. SO MANY of the older champions additionally don't have joke or taunt animations that are even noticeable compared to the never champions.

Thund3r Ang3l1 votes

Yeah.. but they said it wasnt a Complet VU, I mean comon riot.. You're working on shen.. why report this for later Lol.

Pyrodinium3 votes

Because the time that would be spent in creating a Recall animation is best used at creating skill animations for other VUs, or on new champions.

Igotlazy1 votes

It's seems to be an extremely small scale VU akin to Kassadin and Alistar. Model upgrade and a couple of new animations to give it that fresh feel. The other two didn't get recalls either.

Kieferr1 votes

They haven't given recalls animations to Kass, Alistar, MF, Ryze... every one of the champions with visual updates. No clue why, it just makes so much sense and makes their players VERY happy. They said they wanted to modernize all the champions, but how can you do that without giving just a simple recall animation?!?

DemiluniS1 votes

It seems simple because you're not the one doing it. They'd rather spent those resources on more important stuff

Kieferr1 votes

We're talking about a billion dollar company with tons of resources, time, and staff... but can't multitask? If you can elaborate further that would help. I dunno why you downvoted me as well, I'm not asking for fucking LeeSin buffs.

DemiluniS1 votes

We're talking about a billion dollar company with tons of resources, time, and staff

Do you really think Riot got like 100 animators? They got 10 max if not less, and those have to work on new skins, new champs, relaunches and so on. If they aren't giving recall animation for every VU they probably don't have all those resources you thinking of. And up to me if to downvote you or not, it shouldn't bother you at all. I just hate the mindset that Riot have to serve you everything on a silver plate, just because... The lack of appreciation for the things they doing is disrespectful. I mean Shen got a model update, just be thankful for it, some champions didn't get even that.

Kieferr1 votes

If they're working on giving an update in the first place, it is reasonable to expect that they would go the extra 1 mile just for a little animation. If they clearly cannot and it is a trend that will continue, I'm fine with that, I understand. I still dunno why, I basically echoed what everyone on this particular thread wanted, yet you wanted to downvote and reply to me only? This isn't disrespecting them either, I only questioned them from the perspective of a gamer like myself. I also have a right to question a stupid fucking downvote from someone like you. Why don't you downvote everyone else in this thread as well and ask them to be grateful?

DemiluniS1 votes

Because they didn't add a recall animation to any single champion who recieved the same scale of update, ever since they started with those updates, why shen should be an exception?

makes their players VERY happy. They said they wanted to modernize all the champions, but how can you do that without giving just a simple recall animation?!?

Repeating myself, it's simple just because someone doing it for you, to make YOU happy. You're not taking into account that it takes time and hard work without getting any payback other than a "thank you" from the community. And they can modernize champions just by making them look up to date, recall animation isn't mandatory.

You're the only one who said that it's "just a simple recall animation" . Riot are lucky that people like you aren't asking for "simple voiceover"/"simple face animations"/"simple butt muscle moving "

SlyTactician 1 votes

I was wondering about this myself. It seems like such a shame to finally update Shen; yet, the poor ninja didn't receive a recall animation. Heck, his joke animation for his first taunt still has no animation oddly enough...

While it's great to see one of my mains updated, I'm sure all of us Shen mains would like to see an animation or two for the joke and recall sequences. Whether it be something as simple as him spinning his spirit blade or striking a simple; yet, neat and graceful pose - anything would be good at this point to go along with the release of the updated Shen.

Scrimshäw1 votes

kassadin no recall animation?

Scrimshäw1 votes

Alistar no recall animation?

Scrimshäw1 votes

what makes shen so special, exactly?

Arakadia1 votes

Yeah. I agree, but his ult should change 2. It's literally just the first old recall painted purple... Makes me cri :(

captainbits1 votes

yessss

More from Story, Art, & Sound