New Legendary Skin Standards

Shadowkirby14·9/10/2019, 9:29:29 PM·3 votes·4,210 views

I've read through Zeanix's thread about older champions deserving Legendary skins than the most recent champions, and after thinking about it, I highly agree.

Let's go over the champions that earned Legendary skins.

Zed got his Legendary to match with the Odyssey skins (Galaxy Zed). He's been in LoL since 2012 and hasn't received one since his launch. It's refreshing to see him finally get one after all this time.

Pyke got his Legendary Project skin, but it doesn't feel warranted, like it felt too soon. Odyssey Kayn's an exception because Riot genuinely felt he'd fit perfectly for the Odyssey skin-line, and he does! Not only that, but Odyssey Kayn got NEW ANIMATIONS, unlike PROJECT: Pyke. So Riot shouldn't be making this excuse when Kayn got a Legendary skin a year later with the full package. Also my initial thought when I heard Warwick's getting a skin is that there's a chance that Warwick's finally getting a Legendary skin, but no. It's Pyke.

Star Guardian Xayah & Rakan has already gotten a lot of flack because of how it felt undeserving. People have already complained that older champions should've guaranteed that spot, but Riot seems to be focused too much on them that they kinda forgot others existed.

So... what does this have to do with anything?

Xayah and Rakan were released in 2017, while Pyke was released last year and they all got Legendaries. The reactions of them getting Legendary skins so soon are from mixed to negative reception. There are opportunities for other champions to shine with new VOs, VFX, SFX, and new animations, but instead Riot goes for favorites and granted "recent" champions Legendaries.

I personally believe that Riot has forgotten what makes Legendary skins "legendary" and what champion qualifies for one.

So here's the new standards for champions getting Legendary skins should be among the following:

  • Must not be a recently released champion (Sylas, Qiyana, Neeko, Yuumi).

  • Must be a champion that's been in the roster for at least 3 years.

  • Must have at least 4 skins.

  • Must not be a champion due for a rework (Nocturne, Shyvana, Dr. Mundo, Cho'Gath, Shaco, Volibear, Fiddlesticks, Corki, Udyr).

  • If the champion's reworked, it must wait for approximately two years to get one. If they already have a Legendary skin, then they're qualified for one but still have to wait (Galio, Nunu & Willump, and Kayle).

  • Must not be a champion that already has a Legendary skin; exceptions are champions that have more than one Legendary (Legacy) skins back in the early days of LoL (Annie, Twisted Fate, Olaf, and Kog'Maw). Fiddlesticks and Draven are still qualified for a Legendary because those are made for the fans.

Through these will grant older champions a stronger chance to shine out of the fog of obscurity and be brought back into the spotlight. This should also be stricter on which champion deserves to earn a Legendary and not towards favorites. These new standards should give the indication that older champions should deserve a Legendary skin instead of giving it to newer champions that just came out.

Here are the older champions that need Legendary skins (based on my new standards):

Aatrox Akali Alistar Annie Azir Blitzcrank Braum Cassiopeia Diana Draven Ekko Elise Evelynn Fiora Fizz Galio Gangplank Gnar Gragas Graves Hecarim Irelia JarvanIV Jax JayceKarma Karthus Kassadin Katarina Kennen Khazix KogMaw Leblanc Lissandra Lulu Lux Malzahar Maokai MissFortune Nami Nautilus Nidalee Nunu Olaf Orianna Poppy Quinn Renekton Rengar Ryze Sejuani Shen Singed Sivir Sona Soraka Swain Syndra Talon Taric Trundle TwistedFate Twitch Urgot Varus Velkoz Vi Viktor Warwick MonkeyKing Xerath XinZhao Yorick Ziggs Zilean Zyra

Champions that got reworked and are in queue:

Fiddlesticks Kayle Mordekaiser Morgana Pantheon Volibear

Champions that need at least 4 skins:

AurelionSol Bard Camille Illaoi Ivern Kled Kalista Kindred RekSai TahmKench Taliyah Velkoz Zac

Champions that needs to be in the roster for 3 years:

Kaisa Neeko Ornn Qiyana Sylas Yuumi Zoe

Champions that needs a rework for a Legendary:

Amumu Chogath Corki DrMundo Malphite Nocturne Quinn Rammus Shaco Shyvana Udyr

4 Comments

Chembaron Yamada9/10/2019, 11:10:18 PM3 votes

Tbh, I don't think it would be such a great idea to implement these rules. It would limit creativity for Riot.


Many legendary skins are not stand-alone, but get released together with an entire set of the skin line. And quite often, Riot tries to tell a story with these skins.

If one champion, who does not "deserve" a skin according to your rules, just makes perfect sense for that skin line and the narrative they are aiming for, then this champion should get the skin. They shouldn't be forced to shoehorn a less fitting champion in this rule, simply because they match the checklist and the other doesn't....

mrmeddyman9/11/2019, 12:02:49 AM1 votes

Ahri Anivia Ashe Brand Caitlyn Corki Darius Ezreal Galio Garen Heimerdinger Janna Jhin Jinx Kayle Kayn Leona LeeSin Lucian Lux MasterYi MissFortune Nasus Nunu Olaf Pyke Rakan Riven Rumble Sion Sona Teemo Thresh Tristana Tryndamere Udyr Vayne Vladimir Xayah Yasuo Zed

List of Champs with Legendary and Ultimate skins for completeness

LordRedStone Nr19/11/2019, 6:43:55 AM1 votes

I like your usage of the voting function. Most people just put "Do you agree Yes/Yes", "Should this guy be banned", "Should Riot improve/fix this" where it's Impossible by design to vote No. Yours looks like you could actually take a "Thumbs Down". (Even though I agree)

Zoli Ben9/11/2019, 7:01:27 PM1 votes

Reworked champions with legendary shouldn't get another one IMO since they are effectively turning that old one into a new one.Nunu Galio are also very niche so it'd be unlikely for Riot to even consider these champions.