These Star Guardian skins weren't worth wasting the Xayah and Rakan legendary skin slots over.

Imperial Pink·8/28/2019, 1:58:59 AM·6 votes·3,677 views

When it comes to consideration for legendaries Riot, please never do this again.

I am absolutely in love with my bird. Favorite ADC of all time, no cap, no second best after her. She is the most fun to play champ for me and was there for me after Irelia got gutted post shit show and has given me the best plays and time of my life.

And she deserved so much better than this.

If this is some make up for the whole worlds skin debacle which I really didn't care about - I kinda knew from the jump that Rakan would always be the first one to go solo - you didn't in the slightest. I'm sure many, many, many X/R players would have loved to wait to get something better because a much smaller group of people like star guardian than say, K/DA or even Battle Academy. This was so not worth putting a legendary price tag on because of how many players of the champions it will alienate, and it feels bad that their special, all out skins, their legendary, were wasted on this. Freaking kill them both and make them projects, I would have died over them and gone broke. But you gave them frillier, fluffier cosmic skins and expect us to be happy they're getting a almost, repeat skin? And everyone knows that it'll a cold day in hell before any champ - leona was a special case - gets more than one.

Ahri legendary Star Guardian? Perfect. Love it. Star bitch with a purpose. If this one had gone to Zoe? Great. She's legit bubbles, stars, and glitter and everything SG embodies and would've been perfect when amped upon steroids. It's something I liked on other champs. Not the way you have done it with these two. Especially when I noticed from the get go what price point they were gonna hold.

I would have been ecstatic if this slot was saved for a legendary set of Immortal Journey where the subliminal message of their every move and action could have been 'Yes, for one world's series we were apart, but our love is Immortal' and decked them out in the silks, gold, and jade accents and all the good things and made them look undeniably beautiful. No stars. No glitter. Just them, in their world finally full of magic and...happy. No bar fights, just music. No struggle to live, just an endless dance for them and them alone.

Not only would it have pushed well with their background of being Ionian champions, it would have been an amazing opportunity to make Xayah a little flowier while still maintaining her signature edginess, and make Rakan more extravagant and out there and amping up his ever present effervescent personality and polishing all his peacocky elegance. Yin and Yang at it's highest aspect. Her night to his day.

Instead we get...this. An alienating, wrong feeling, thematic that only one fits well into while the other is shoe horned in to fit in one specific aspect. Xayah is made to seem like an even bigger bitch than she is, while Rakan graciously and unnecessarily gives his last light away to her. Leaving her alone. Forever.

I really hope her castle built of the worlds ashes is grand and great for the travesty committed that is this skin set. As beautiful as the art is, and kudos to the splash artists and art team despite a few issues, I will not be purchasing these because these are not what they should have been for the price.

Please, please reconsider these skins. I truly hope in the future even, if my plea goes unheeded, it will at least make you check twice when considering future skin line ups as well as who and what should get to be called a legendary.

46 Comments

4 Step Cadence8/28/2019, 7:00:01 AM3 votes

Cho'Gath has 2 legendary skins. Corki has 2 legendary skins. Darius has 2 legendary skins. Ezreal has a legendary skin and an ultimate skin. Heim has 2 legendary skins. Leona has 2 legendary skins(even though they're technically the same skin but whatever). Tristana has 2 legendary skins.

Granted some of those skins may not be considered legendary by today's standards, but the point still stands. If those champions can have more than one legendary skin, then so can Xayah and Rakan.

Ebonmaw Dragon8/28/2019, 6:06:50 AM3 votes

[{quoted}](name=Imperial Pink,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=6ZZNNlwu,comment-id=,timestamp=2019-08-28T01:58:59.228+0000)

But you gave them frillier, fluffier cosmic skins and expect us to be happy they're getting a almost, repeat skin?

Im not going to lie, out of all the criticism that i have heard... this one makes alot of sense to me. I totally forgot that they had Cosmic Skins and the new ones are basically that same thing+ something extra.

BlackKnightJack8/28/2019, 5:28:05 AM2 votes

Decidedly not true. Star Guardian Xayah is amazing.

Jesi Oni8/28/2019, 7:32:50 AM2 votes

Well I dont like those skins but skins that you want would be even worse... I almost vomited reading about your expectations.

PrettyGirlsFeet8/28/2019, 10:25:05 AM2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Imperial Pink,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=6ZZNNlwu,comment-id=,timestamp=2019-08-28T01:58:59.228+0000)

I am imploring you from the depths of my soul. Never do this again.

drama queen. didn't even read more past this

Chembaron Yamada8/28/2019, 10:54:21 AM2 votes

I got the feeling that Star Guardian is way more popular than Battle Academia....

Daddy Viktor8/30/2019, 4:27:58 AM2 votes

Urgot Urgot Urgot Urgot Urgot

Stargot will be a reality!!!!!!

G0blinSlay3r8/28/2019, 2:02:38 AM2 votes

Now you know how i feel about project jinx.

Tíma8/30/2019, 12:55:50 PM2 votes

Xayah is made to seem like an even bigger bitch than she is

This is one of my biggest complaints against this skin. For all the issues with her not having a purified form, her personality is absolutely abhorrent. The description of the skin says she died and was resurrected, seems almost happy about it, but also has doubts...about what? All of her VO lines make her sound bitter, angry and like she is lashing out to everyone in some way shape or form. She is supposed to be this tragic hero that got manipulated by Zoe into being evil, not this hard edged anti-villain that hates everyone. That is not likeable nor does it make me feel sympathetic to her circumstances.

Rakan on the other hand is grounded and keeps his sympathetic slant by being self sacrificing because of his love for Xayah. People can empathize with that and admire his selflessness. You can tell that he is forcing himself when he fights against his friends, whilst being the lovable dork we know Rakan can be.

Xayah? Bitchy and cruel to the degree that she loses my sympathy because she does not show any vulnerable moments. She never shows any feelings of hesitation against fighting her friends, these supposed doubts she has about...whatever she has doubts about, or an unwillingness to want be Zoe's puppet. The closest line we get is

"I can play the part of the evil star guardian come back to betray her friends, but I don't have to be happy about it" Which tells us she is self aware of her being manipulated...but she doesn't seem to be doing anything about it. Like she has just resigned herself to being Zoe's plaything whilst reveling in being harsh and cruel to her friends. That is not sympathetic. That does not make me feel for her. That makes me apathetic and tired. Definitely will not be purchasing this skin.

LadyAlbaKurosaki8/28/2019, 2:41:29 AM2 votes

They are bleak. Too much, their story, their recalls their dance, their pallette. Star guardian fans liked them because they were the oposite of bleak and I doubt the birbs mains were into Star Guardians anyways. Objectively the skins are decent but almost no one wanted them... not like this at least