Skip to content

I'd like opinions from the community as a whole (Reds and Arbiters too, preferably?)

A Deadly Wind··3 votes·1,105 views

I'd like to know how everyone feels about the general player mental health in this game and how it is negatively affected, as well as a few term explanations/clarifications if I may?

Let's start first off with the most common term when it comes to PB&M: Toxicity

I think toxicity is where someone else takes their shitty mood and pushes that on to the other players in their match. This mood could be caused by outside factors or by the game itself. This then can cause the other players to get upset purely because someone else decides they need to cuss them out over a few mistakes or constantly berate them over it.

I feel like this spreading negativity is where the term toxicity comes from, because if you're "contaminated" then you're bound to spread that to others and cause them to become toxic as well and it's a giant domino effect of negativity from hell.

Once I think of other stuff to say I'll come back, but for now I need to rest. I'd like opinions from anyone who sees this.

26 Comments

ModWuks3 votes

My view of toxicity is when a player continuously spews his/her negativity into the game and onto the players in the game. An example of this can be for an individual who perhaps gets ganked top lane and immediately types in a rather aggressive and accusatory manner to criticize his/her jungler for not ganking. Toxicity is sort of a state where a player becomes so negative that the player becomes a repulsive figure that the other individuals in the game find it difficult to or are reluctant to communicate to the person in question.

Regarding general player mental health, I would say that everyone has a different mood that they bring into the game that may be influenced by outside factors (bad day at school/work, fight with a friend/significant other, losing streak). And this is completely fine; you can have a mood when you go into the game, but what you can't do is let this mood negatively affect the game or the communications that go on between players. To clarify, sure you had a bad day, but if you're going bash another player on your team because he's not performing too well, there's a good chance that you may be punished. And players who can't separate their negative attitudes outside the game from their in-game behavior are typically the ones who have a difficult time avoiding restrictions on their account; however, hopefully this new sub-board should be able to shine some light on how players can retain a positive or neutral attitude in the game, even if that's not necessarily how they feel in reality.

Thanks for the question, and thanks for reading!

A Deadly Wind1 votes

I really appreciate and respect this response. These parts are the ones I like most:

Toxicity is sort of a state where a player becomes so negative that the player becomes a repulsive figure that the other individuals in the game find it difficult to or are reluctant to communicate to the person in question. you can have a mood when you go into the game, but what you can't do is let this mood negatively affect the game or the communications that go on between players.

I really like all of the responses but these in particular are great. I really appreciate it, Wuks!

AV3NKA1 votes

<3

Lugg3 votes

I think toxicity is where you blame teammates. Even if they are having a bad game, talking down to them is just going to make them play worse.

ModUlanopo3 votes

[{quoted}](name=A Deadly Wind,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=aNuNf5oN,comment-id=,timestamp=2015-11-01T13:56:12.324+0000)

I'd like to know how everyone feels about the general player mental health in this game and how it is negatively affected, as well as a few term explanations/clarifications if I may?

Let's start first off with the most common term when it comes to PB&M: Toxicity

I think toxicity is where someone else takes their shitty mood and pushes that on to the other players in their match. This mood could be caused by outside factors or by the game itself. This then can cause the other players to get upset purely because someone else decides they need to cuss them out over a few mistakes or constantly berate them over it.

I feel like this spreading negativity is where the term toxicity comes from, because if you're "contaminated" then you're bound to spread that to others and cause them to become toxic as well and it's a giant domino effect of negativity from hell.

Once I think of other stuff to say I'll come back, but for now I need to rest. I'd like opinions from anyone who sees this.

I think resilience, patience and morale vary a great deal from player to player and game to game (I'm sorry, I just can't bring myself ti use the phrase "player mental health"). We had a terrible ARAM last night where four of the enemy were Kayle, Kindred, Zilean and Bard. It was awful and I had a hard time keeping my temper, even though I'm somewhere between casual and competitive. After we lost, my friend and I talked about other stuff for a while to let the frustration drain out. We won the next one pretty handily.

As far as berating goes, I do my best to fight against it. First off, I try to be actively positive wherever I can, even if someone is struggling. "Well done" and "Good job" are probably the most common things I type, when I type at all. If someone starts grumbling, I try to get them to stop, but obliquely. For example, if someone coughs up first blood, I might say, "It's okay, we got this." I think that building and maintaining morale is as much of a skill as last-hitting, perhaps even more, seeing as I'm a support main.

nerak232 votes

I feel like this spreading negativity is where the term toxicity comes from, because if you're "contaminated" then you're bound to spread that to others and cause them to become toxic as well and it's a giant domino effect of negativity from hell.

I understand where you are coming from, really I do ! But I also feel like we as a community can spread positive attitudes also.

This is an issue I'd like to see addressed eventually here. I'm not sure how to do it or what it is or even if it'd would help most, but it's worth a try.

For instance when I'm in-game and someone starts being negative, right away I will ask Nicely for them to stop...and I mean things like 'hey, relax we don't want to hear this' or something easy going like that..but I try to never engage the person in a word war, ever...If they continue to make comments I try to encourage the person they are picking at and if I can help that player.

After the game if I fell like they we over the top then I hit the report button but I Never ask anyone else to do this. I hope we can start to learn to deal with toxic people and after reading the reasons some people may rage It should help understand where we need to start imploring any new strategies about easing a competitive game.

nerak232 votes

however, hopefully this new sub-board should be able to shine some light on how players can retain a positive or neutral attitude in the game, even if that's not necessarily how they feel in reality.

Reading my mind ? lol Nicely said :)

Archon X1 votes

people are toxic because sometimes allies play like absolute garbage

get better at the game then people aren't toxic to you, works every time

Axxlon6 votes

[{quoted}](name=Archon X,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=aNuNf5oN,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2015-11-01T13:58:32.772+0000)

people are toxic because sometimes allies play like absolute garbage

get better at the game then people aren't toxic to you, works every time

except that's your problem for being a jackass about it :\

Archon X1 votes

Hi yes thank you for calling me a jackass.

You are bronze 3 which means you are a casual player.

I am platinum 1 which means I am a somewhat serious player.

I play to win, every game, doesn't matter if it's ranked, normal, ARAM, etc.

In ranked, I am matched with people of the same elo. That means they should be of the same skill level. This entails multiple concepts.

  1. They should know how to build
  2. They should not feed, dying a few times is acceptable because shit happens when you party naked
  3. They should rotate properly, prioritize objectives, and assist with vision
  4. They should not say stupid shit like "gg, ff 20" if the score is 5-1 at 10 minutes.

When someone violates one of these simple principles at the high plat or low diamond level it means that they were either elo boosted or are intentionally trolling. There is simply no excuse for piss poor performance. Mistakes happen, for sure. But making the same exact error, or making 'mental mistakes' like not knowing how to build correctly are not acceptable. It breeds toxicity.

Instead of wasting 4 other people's time, realize that this game is not random, it is scientific, and there are empirical means by which each player can increase the chance of victory.

Mathbalnase3 votes

Rank does not excuse toxicity. Whether you're leading in Worlds, or getting stomped in Wood 5, don't be a douche.

A Deadly Wind3 votes

[{quoted}](name=Archon X,realm=NA,application-id=ZGEFLEUQ,discussion-id=aNuNf5oN,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2015-11-01T13:58:32.772+0000)

people are toxic because sometimes allies play like absolute garbage

get better at the game then people aren't toxic to you, works every time

Aaaaaand the epitome of what I said in my last sentence in my 2nd paragraph:

This then can cause the other players to get upset purely because someone else decides they need to cuss them out over a few mistakes or constantly berate them over it.

Thanks for proving a point I guess :x

Archon X1 votes

yeah I'm not really clear on the point you're making

I used to have pretty bad positioning, but I watched videos, read guides, and got coaching. And thus I improved. I'll still get caught out sometimes, usually when deep warding, and if it happens I'll apologize in teamchat. I still lose games for sure but I'm not fucking up every 5 minutes. It's really not that difficult to just stop digging a hole? Just know your limits and be conservative if you're losing, don't think you can duel someone a couple levels and 1k gold over you.

Shac Norris1 votes

I would say that Ranked queues bring the most toxicity, but i do see alot of toxic players in normals..

It's just that when you really want to win, and to win, you have to rely on other people, but to be honest, not everybody have the same mindset, when one says: engage, another will say : Disengage. And when anyone is doing poorly, instead of being constructive, they just crap on the player that did poorly and blames him for the whole game.

It happened to me the last game i played :P I played Shaco support, so i'm already used to getting screamed at anyway, The enemies just assumed i was Pink Ward (A well known ap shaco player) And they harassed me non-stop everytime i died, at some point even my ally jumped in lol

AV3NKA1 votes

Hate breeds hate. Blame makes everyone feel like crap. Mental health wise I have finally uninstalled the game as theres nothing worse that when u want to escape your world to just have fun somehow on your own it back fires. I have suggested riot create some form or at least donate or something for mental illness its not ok for people to give any negativity to anyone. Its a fun game that creates teamwork responsibility kinship and forgiveness and FUN FUN FUN ppl who take it way too seriously and breed negativity because their pride in winning a game is more important than another human being sitting on the otherside of the computer is not ok. I would say truly reward the mentors, encouraging people and fun ones to make this community and people better. Each individual needs to view responsibly that they are dealing with human beings and just because its not face to face gives no one the right to not treat them like a human being.

jaymc11301 votes

To be honest, as an adult, I've never cared what people said in chat in game for the most part. Being upset or rude or hateful never really bugged me. I'd just mute you. Trash talk? Muted. I mean, riot gave us a button to filter that filth and since I'm old enough to comprehend it's purpose I used it for that purpose. That type of toxic action in my 5 years of playing wasn't ever something that bugged me greatly or was cause to bicker back in chat or demand everyone spam the report feature against the offending player.

What always bugged me, and still does to this day, are toxic actions taken by players. Players who intentionally feed, intentionally throw games, disrupt laning and farming, steal jungle camps out of spite, afk from the game, use third party cheats like loldrop or scripts. Those types of toxic actions don't have an in game solution, I don't have a button to kick the guy who's afk from the team and get a new useful team member. This type of thing affecting my ranking was always the primary source of frustration with the game and would cause me to want to rip the offending player's head off.

To me, the only toxicity worth caring about are the types of toxic actions the eliminate winning the game as a real possibility. I can win the game with a rager, I can't win with a duo who refuses to cooperate with the team and sit in base spamming dance/taunt. The fact that those types of toxic actions often lead to verbal toxicity has always been my issue with the way riot handles the situation, particularly after tribunal went down and we saw a dramatic increase in trolling in games since there were no longer repercussions and trolling could be used to bait players into raging.

In the end I guess I'll likely always be frustrated at the lack of tools to combat the actual root causes of toxicity in game as it seems there is very little riot is willing to do to solve some of those issues.

EvilDustMan1 votes

{quoted}

it seems there is very little riot is willing to do to solve some of those issues.

Except that you report it and they use their suite of gameplay tools to realize that person was trolling? This is a thing. This is a thing they do. This is a thing Lyte talks about.

jaymc11301 votes

{quoted}

Except that you report it and they use their suite of gameplay tools to realize that person was trolling? This is a thing. This is a thing they do. This is a thing Lyte talks about.

It's a thing they do. But very, very poorly. After tribunal went down intentional feeders had 2 whole years where they were allowed to do so without repercussions provided they didn't use chat. Riot still does next to nothing about afks, low priority queues do not stop persistent afkers, in the past tribunal used to ban them and it was more effective. Players who troll subtly and intentionally throw games or perform other trolly actions have next to no chance of being caught or punished for those behaviors currently. I had a tahm kench who got upset and decided to spend 20 minutes trying to prevent me from leaving the base once by constantly devouring me. He was never punished for that, I followed his account activity for 2 months afterward.

Does riot say they do stuff about those types of things? Sure. Do they catch and punish a high percentage of those who troll in such fashion? No, probably less than 5%, and most of the ones that are caught are caught because they trolled AND were verbally abusive. I like that riot is taking steps to solve some of these issues... but it's still been 5 years and they have made extremely little progress. I'm still affected by players intentionally trolling my games on a daily basis. And it happens multiple times in a day with alarming regularity. This has an effect on the community as a whole in terms of our mental health regarding the game. The player base is perennially frustrated about those types of things and the lack of response by riot which breeds negative attitudes and this leads to the frustration boiling over as toxicity.

shrug

EvilDustMan1 votes

{quoted}

Do they catch and punish a high percentage of those who troll in such fashion? No, probably less than 5%,

[citation needed]

jaymc11301 votes

{quoted}

[citation needed]

Sorry don't have actual data that I can give. This is just from personal experience tracking those players account activities that I have reported for those types of actions. About 1 in 20 times I've noticed that player being banned or ranked restricted. There's no doubt the statistic I've given is flawed because there is only so much I can do by sending in support tickets since there is no report feature that actually works for those type of things.

Pelkrock1 votes

I'd say there is some truth to what you say. Thing is not everyone will ignore people who are toxic in chat. Personally I don't even mute people who are flaming me or someone I just don't bother responding to it since it nets very little result. I'll just say things like "mid mia drag open they're at baron or whatever". Problem is even when the flaming is directed at me my team will often spend time typing to defend me or join in on the flame game. Wasting their time, I mean I have seen people going back and fourth about meaningless stuff at fountain while mid tower drops. Being verbally toxic effects game even if you think you're the big boy who can ignore it. Fact is most the people on your team won't which will effect your games. It is a toxic action.

jaymc11301 votes

{quoted}

I'd say there is some truth to what you say. Thing is not everyone will ignore people who are toxic in chat. Personally I don't even mute people who are flaming me or someone I just don't bother responding to it since it nets very little result. I'll just say things like "mid mia drag open they're at baron or whatever". Problem is even when the flaming is directed at me my team will often spend time typing to defend me or join in on the flame game. Wasting their time, I mean I have seen people going back and fourth about meaningless stuff at fountain while mid tower drops. Being verbally toxic effects game even if you think you're the big boy who can ignore it. Fact is most the people on your team won't which will effect your games. It is a toxic action.

Oh without a doubt it's still a toxic action to spend more time arguing than playing, there's no debate that verbal toxicity is a bad thing for games. I've just found that other types of toxic behavior have greater impact more regularly. Part of this is because of my high skill level which can allow me to overcome infighting among team members by simply kicking butt and taking names, which has the simultaneous effect of calming my teammates down. I can affect a rager to the point they stop whining and get back to playing on occasion because they see they still have a chance to win and one player carrying pretty hard.

But there are some types of toxic actions which I have zero ability to counter act. I can play peacemaker among arguers, but I can't magically overcome a 3v5 situation when a duo decides they just don't want to play and prefer to spite the rest of the team. To me it's an issue that the things I can't overcome have less resources applied by riot to combat the adverse effect this has on my ranking than the amount of resources applied by riot to combat something I can overcome easily by being a positive presence and a leader.

Pelkrock1 votes

I'll agree to that someone just running into tower over and over again is pretty hard to annoy. I was pretty pissed when in my promo's a jungler decided to feed because I came to his aid and got the kill granted he would have been fine without me but gold shared is gold shared lol. I just don't see how Rito can stop the trolls? Unless they want to hire a giant work force. I mean unless the person does it every single game how do you flag that from having a bad game?

jaymc11301 votes

{quoted}

I'll agree to that someone just running into tower over and over again is pretty hard to annoy. I was pretty pissed when in my promo's a jungler decided to feed because I came to his aid and got the kill granted he would have been fine without me but gold shared is gold shared lol. I just don't see how Rito can stop the trolls? Unless they want to hire a giant work force. I mean unless the person does it every single game how do you flag that from having a bad game?

Replay. Easiest way to know of some one was trolling is to watch replay. But yeah that would require a staff to view games. Unlikely to happen, riot's unwilling to spend resources on that type of stuff.

7ha7guy7771 votes

Considering the volume of games played on a daily basis, sifted through even the flagged games would take a long time me. Millions of games. > millions of Riot employees.

Lord Boltrix1 votes

Mordekaiser

"Misery loves company."

Toxicity in a nutshell.

Because people who are toxic are miserable on some level for various reasons, and find that they can't just make themselves happy, so they have to drag other people down to their level of misery to feel content to some degree.

More from Player Behavior

More by A Deadly Wind