Okay, here's what I see when I read this chat log.
You Si: wow ur bad
You Si: man
You Si: srsly bad
You Si: he's as bad as you
You Si: can we get 9 reports
You Si: on vic
You Si: 9 report sscutb
Constant harassment directed towards your teammates as well as report calling to boot. This is not acceptable in any way, shape or form and only serves to make you look like a jerk. Also, if a player is performing poorly then chances are that they already know that. Because of that, they don't need you wasting time constantly harassing them over it.
You Si: dont ever call mid fail fck
Excuse me but who died and made you leader? With the way you've been acting so far you definitely do not deserve that title, nor should you be trying to boss others around with your constant need to harass others for having a bad game.
You Si: pls
You Si: for the record
You Si: cho has nothing with you losing ur lane
You Si: it is u
You Si: ur just bad/
More harassment from you. Again, if they know they're having a bad game they don't need you rubbing it in.
You Si: wake trhe fck up cho
You Si: 9 report on vic
You Si: 9 reports
You Si: two weeks ban
You Si: enjoy lol
You Si: too good lol
You Si: 9 reports on vic
You Si: insta lock on mid and qq'ed as hell
You Si: lol
You Si: hes a bronze fck
Once again, more verbal harassment and report calling from you. Also, you're in no position to be laughing at others considering you've already received a 2-week ban yourself for exactly the kind of behavior that you've displayed in this game.
You Si: not going to waste my time
You Si: maybe end it
You Si: any reason why we're wasting time
Now correct me if I'm wrong here, but to me this gives the impression that you've already given up and have stopped participating in the game. Maybe to you it's them just wasting time but maybe to them it's just trying to make a comeback if possible.
You Si: lol
You Si: stfu
You Si: he's qqing why he lost to you nid
You Si: lol
And once again, directing harassment towards Viktor, only this time in all-chat. You couldn't have just kept it in team chat, oh no, you had to go and bring it to all-chat as well for whatever reason there.
Conclusion: The reason that you got punished is because from the very start you went on an all-out crusade against your teammates simply for having poor performances that game. Not only that but you constantly called for reports against them as well. You should've learned from your 2-week ban and 35-games worth of chat restriction that this kind of behavior is unacceptable, but because you refused to do so and kept it up you got permabanned because of it. It wasn't just this game that got you punished either, oh no: it was this game+the many other games that you got valid reported in as well.
My advice: Don't call for reports, ever, as this is just considered harassment by both Riot and the general community as well. If you need to report someone then just do it without wasting time calling for reports against them. Also, just because someone is having a bad game doesn't give you the excuse nor the right to start verbally harassing them over it. That's not gonna get them to play better-more often than not it actually makes them perform worse instead. If you want to try to get your teammates to perform better, then try a little positive reinforcement and encouragement sometimes instead of just being a really negative jerk about it.
My verdict: Punish.
P.S. What the other players did matters none, as this here is about you and you alone. From Understanding the Tribunal:
4) That player in my game was far worse than me. Why am I banned???
a) I'll keep this one simple: retaliation isn't OK. Reacting to a toxic player by being toxic just incites that player to be even worse--it also ruins the game for up to 8 other players. It is far, far worse to watch two people yelling at each other all game than it is to watch 1 player ranting into blank space. Almost everyone in the game can find someone out there that behaves worse than they do--but so what? Finding someone worse doesn't justify your behavior or justify retaliation. We expect more out of our players. What players often don't realize is... those other players in your game that you thought were worse? Nearly 100% of the time, those players were banned even before you were. If someone is being toxic, just report them and move on. If you retaliate, both of you will be banned. It's really that simple.
5) Low skill players should be banned from the game! The Tribunal should only ban Leavers/AFK and intentional feeders, those are the only types of players that really ruin games!
a) No. Just no. Jerks ruin games. League of Legends is for everyone whether they are 500 Elo or 2500 Elo. It's not a game for jerks.
From Ulanopo's Knowledge Base:
I ask for reports because they were ruining my fun and I want to make sure they are punished.
Yeah, I know. People suck. A lot. And its natural to be angry with them. What you cant do, however, is harass them and report begging is generally considered to be harassment. Riot has said that reported is the most toxic word in League.
http://youtu.be/a-5yKdpR0kU?t=34m10s
(Assistance from Butterfly44)
I should be allowed to speak however I like to people who started it or are griefing me.
I was provoked or taunted. I should be allowed to defend myself.
Why did you vote to punish me when others were behaving worse?
You should know that Riot specifically instructs jurors to ignore most of the conduct of people in a case other than the accused. The reason for this is rather simple: rather than one person causing trouble, you now have two or more. In my more cynical moments, I have phrased it thus:
Timmy, Tommy and Sarah are trapped in an elevator.
Timmy loses his temper and soils himself.
Tommy gets angry at the smell and decides to retaliate by soiling himself.
Now Sarah is trapped with two smelly idiots.
Dont be Timmy or Tommy. Stop ****ing your pants.
An informal poll of the Tribunal regulars shows that most jurors are willing to excuse a certain amount of response to someone who is attacking you, but that it isnt considered an excuse for you to become toxic in response. You get MAYBE one or two lines of response. Anything more than that and youre part of the problem.
From Lyte (link (http://forums.na.leagueoflegends.com/board/showthread.php?p=27540071#post27540071)):
We strongly believe that it is not OK to retaliate. If a player refuses to cooperate and says something negative, then players should ignore the player and report them after the game. Players can ignore or mute players by pressing the Mute button on the Scoreboard [when you hit TAB] in the game.
Emphasis mine.
**Im worried about people reporting me for nothing.**
- Most threats to report are just that: a threat and nothing more. Just mute and report them.
- You need to be reported in at least 15% of your games to see the Tribunal. A few reports here and there aren't going to get you in trouble as long as you don't let your frustration turn you toxic.
- Even if you go to Tribunal, rest assured that we do actually pardon people, as long as the case is clean. I suggest trying to play with friends if you're feeling stressed. Teamwork OP, yo.
- It might take longer than you like, but we get the bullies eventually. Then they come here and cry that they lost their account. Schadenfreude, it's what's for dinner.
Is there any way to remove my permaban?
Keep in mind that we dont have the power to remove your ban. Only Riot has that ability.
BANS THAT CANNOT BE LIFTED
- Behavioral
- Tampering with the game client
- DDOS
- Real-life harassment, threats or stalking
- Elo boosting
BANS THAT MIGHT BE LIFTED
- Inappropriate name
- Payment problems