Skip to content

[game play] Sivir shield doesn't absorb Q from Lucian

shíns··13 votes·2,276 views

hi, just a report to say that the shield (E) from sivir don't absorb ALWAYS the Q from lucian.

Pay attention, we tried several time and sometime it absorb the damages and sometimes it absorb (u get the mana) but u got the damage from Piercing light too ! . i only try it in howling abyss and 5v5 and the bugs occured only in 5v5 (for us) . But i let you do all the test needed !

the spell was directly put on sivir (not by "Q a creep and hitting sivir") so you have to try it too :D

ty for fixing it because absorbing a spell save ur life often!

11 Comments

Ayame Isaki2 votes

I've seen this on ARAM quite a few times against a variety of champs. I think the bug might be in the shield logic itself and tied to a specific champion.

MattAkhavan1 votes

nvm

Savastano1 votes

I believe it to be, because it is physical damage. Sivir puts a SPELL SHIELD on, absorbing the magical damage. Physical damage isnt. ITs why you can still burst a morganna down even though her spell shield is up . If you notice it absorbs a spell. So when your versus somebody like a blitzcrank an he grabs your butt, it is magical damage + based off AP. Hence a Spell. I believe this is why.

OverpoweredSoap1 votes

{quoted}

I believe it to be, because it is physical damage. Sivir puts a SPELL SHIELD on, absorbing the magical damage. Physical damage isnt. ITs why you can still burst a morganna down even though her spell shield is up . If you notice it absorbs a spell. So when your versus somebody like a blitzcrank an he grabs your butt, it is magical damage + based off AP. Hence a Spell. I believe this is why.

Sivir is suppose to be shielding both types of damage however.

EndlessSorcerer3 votes

Spellshields don't typically care about the damage type, only whether it was an ability used. The ability could be magical, physical, or ture damage (or not deal damage) and still be blocked by a spell shield. This includes Banshee's Veil, Sivir's E, and Nocturne's W. I'm not quite sure how this applies to on-hit abilities (such as Talon Q or Nasus Q) and too lazy to look it up for you, but it should be easy to find a list of interactions easily if you searched.

Morgana's Black Shield is different and behaves similar to a (health) shield than a spell shield, except it only blocks magic damage and prevents the target from being CCed.

ravenswolfy1 votes

{quoted}

Spellshields don't typically care about the damage type, only whether it was an ability used. The ability could be magical, physical, or ture damage (or not deal damage) and still be blocked by a spell shield. This includes Banshee's Veil, Sivir's E, and Nocturne's W. I'm not quite sure how this applies to on-hit abilities (such as Talon Q or Nasus Q) and too lazy to look it up for you, but it should be easy to find a list of interactions easily if you searched.

Morgana's Black Shield is different and behaves similar to a (health) shield than a spell shield, except it only blocks magic damage and prevents the target from being CCed.

Nasus Q goes through sivir's spellshield since its treated as a basic attack and not an ability.

doubleguac1 votes

Sivir's spell shield can absolutely absorb physical damage spells. It's supposed to absorb any ability, regardless of damage type.

LiveWire0031 votes

If you get targeted by Q, you block it. If he targets something else and hits you, you don't block it.

shíns1 votes

{quoted}

If you get targeted by Q, you block it. If he targets something else and hits you, you don't block it.

this is not true ^^ we made the test. sometimes u absorb it , sometimes u dont even he target you directly

L7xLoTek1 votes

Sounds like something that should be fixed for all champions with spell shield. I wonder how Banshee's Veil works against Lucian, then.

Did you try activating the shield pre-cast or only to block damage? It's possible this is a "zilean bomb" kinda bug where if you had spell shield up before the bomb was cast, it was negated, but if you already had the bomb on you it was too late.

ham sandwitch981 votes

damage type doesn't matter its a spell

More from Report a Bug