Skip to content

Not sure if working as intended

LaughingMan11··1 votes·612 views

Was playing an ARAM yesterday and noticed Shaco's boxes didnt proc item 3151 or item 3116 i went into a custom game with a friend to double check to make sure i didnt miss see it, and indeed neither item proc'd with the jack in the box skill, just confused if its supposed to work that way of if the skill isnt working properly.

15 Comments

Dr Jarjarbinks1 votes

I believe its not supposed to proc those. Same with heimer turrets I think. I think zyras plants proc them though, being that they arent an ability to be spammed with a single button.

LaughingMan111 votes

i dont think id call a 12-15 sec cool down "spamable" Lol, but i think its kind of silly if thats the reason, i mean shaco in general doesnt have much going for him he loses a lot of viability at high level because people understand his tricks. To have one of his main damage abilities, in my opinion, gimped like that, lowers his usefulness all the more aside from being a backdoor ADC like yi, only minus the team fight usefulness and ability to carry. Lol

Dr Jarjarbinks1 votes

"spammable" was the wrong word. I meant an ability used with one button. Zyra needs to use 2 buttons to pace a plant. I don't actually know why its this way but I am pretty sure it is this way.

LaughingMan111 votes

I agree the fact that its one button push, but at the same time, Teemo shrooms apply both, and can literally alomst kill people off of one shroom. you cant kill someone with one Jack-in-the-Box, not from full HP anyway. It usually takes 3-4 to have a chance. So i guess i just dont see why they cant have it, if it is working as intended.

Matthias91191 votes

"Traps" that just deal damage once proc those passives, "turrets" that can independently attack multiple times don't.

Zyra's an exception because her plants are so short-lived, not because they take multiple spellcasts to activate.

Dr Jarjarbinks1 votes

^this is more likely the relevant difference

Dr Jarjarbinks1 votes

on a more obvious note, teemo shrooms are his ult while shaco boxes are not.

LaughingMan111 votes

Teemo shrooms also do more damage than a box, and still proc both, so uber damage

Dr Jarjarbinks1 votes

If you are implying that shaco boxes should proc liandry's or that teemo shrooms should not, I disagree.

LaughingMan111 votes

Im not really implying anything, Im saying shaco boxes should proc at least either Liandry's OR Raylais, beecause ill admit both on shaco boxes would be rather OP.

LaughingMan111 votes

Also, i went and test played heimer to test that theory, Heimer turrets DO apply both liandry's and Raylai's but only off of the laser blast the turret launches. So literally shaco boxes are the only trap/turret that doesnt apply them, so again, is it a bug, or working as intended.

Dr Jarjarbinks1 votes

Again, it is no bug. Now that you said it I do recall the laser procing but that makes a lot more sense than shaco boxes. To make it the "same"(because obviously people who know more than either of us have balanced this already so this is about getting you to accept it) you would have to change shaco boxes to fire a single shot which would proc liandy's and ralyai(because it wouldn't make much sense to proc one and not the other I dont think). Like you said heimer turrets proc on their laser which must charge and fires much less regularly than the other attack. So as it stands there is no obvious comparison between the two(not the one you are making at least) because they have different abilities, turrets and boxes function differently, and it is all balanced(or attempted balance) around factors much more relevant than "they both put something on the ground that shoots."

I hope this didn't come across as condescending or malicious. I could go back and reword it to be nicer(as I meant this all to be a pleasant discussion) but I am WAY too lazy for that=)

LaughingMan111 votes

Dont worry, i know you arent being condescending or any such fluff, it just makes me a bit irritated that because of very minor differences in skills, champions like shaco, who have almost no good competitive play, get shafted because it might be too strong, personally id happily take a shaco box damage nerf (preferably base his ratios there have been destroyed enough all ready) just to let liandrys and raylias work, it might bring some viability back to shaco as more than just another back door champ, at least the rest (fiora, yi, trynd, ect) can all actually carry and/or have an impact late game, with shaco you just have to make it to mid game and hes literally nothing more than an irritant in a 4v5. Hes not scary past early game in anywhere past level 20. Shaco is a character full of tricks, once those get figured out, he loses his power. So in order to stay competitive with shaco you have to literally out smart every person you play against in new ways otherwise you cant be helpful to a team. Every other champion has some sort of mechanic that, no matter how far behind they get, lets them shine in some fashion. Shaco can be ahead, but falls off so hard that he becomes ignorable as long as you can stop him from split pushing. So im not really complaining about shacos boxes being dumb via game mechanics, just about how his kit is so nerfed in comparison to other champs. Kinda like Morde, but thats a topic for a different forum.

Matthias91191 votes

Generally, summoned units that attack independently don't proc "on spell hit" passives. Zyra's an exception because her plants only live for a few seconds and are basically extensions of her other spells.

LaughingMan111 votes

Shaco's boxes also only last a few seconds, and are pretty easy to remove come mid-late game, so again, not seeing much difference.

More from Report a Bug

More by LaughingMan11