Skip to content

Why doesn't GP passive proc Ludens like other DOT abilities?

Sexy Choir Boys··2 votes·1,117 views
Gangplanks passive does 4 damage over 3 seconds stacking 3 times... * /r/leagueoflegends

Gangplank Gangplank is everyone's favorite salty pirate of the League, whats unique about Gangplank is that he has many different builds, playstyles, and roles which he can play. Many people experiment with this champion and I have as well. I started playing Ap Gp and couldn't stop laughing as it is just so fun and entertaining to play, eventually I began playing him quite a bit with friends and had a great time. When Ludens item 3285 was introduced I was excited to test it out with Gangplank, when I found out it didn't work I was disappointed and later on I found out that other DOT abilities such as Brand passive, Fizz W, Etc. all worked with this new item. Why not Gangplank's? Gangplank passive does magic damage like all of the other DOT abilities but fails to work with Ludens. This should be an easy fix and I hope to see this change in the future. Thank you.

13 Comments

Oni San Darius3 votes

Yes, this would be a good addition to Gangplank. This would add a lot more variation in Gangplank builds. This would make gangplank more viable in games and he would be chosen more often. This is an amazing idea that would make me once again main Gangplank like I used too.

stvnstar2 votes

It doesnt proc luden's becuase it isn't a spell effect. GP's passive is applied with auto attacks (and his q because it acts like a ranged auto and a spell cast) so you can activate and proc sheen with the one ability. So ludens would proc if it was part of his q or applied with another damaging spell but blahdeblah

tl;dr its basically calling it a part of his auto attacks not spells

Matthias91191 votes

So ludens would proc if it was part of his q...

GP's Q (and Nasus' Q and Ezrael's Q) will not apply "on spell damage" effects. They are auto attacks as far as the game is concerned.

Lil SweatySlayer1 votes

Its Gangplanks passive not his q that hes talking about dude.

Sexy Choir Boys3 votes

But the game should take it as a spell, since it is technically an ability. It shouldn't matter what his passive is triggered off of, (an auto, ability, etc.) it should be considered an individual ability which is magic damage and therefore should proc Ludens.

Lil SweatySlayer3 votes

Ap gp tp op Gangplank

Matthias91191 votes

...it should be considered an individual ability which is magic damage and therefore should proc Ludens.

Sorry. Riot decided that isn't how it should work. This would make spell effect items way more powerful on certain champions.

Matthias91191 votes

Completely passive on-hit abilities don't proc things like Rylai's or Luden's. It has to be something active. (see also: damage from Nashor's Tooth. Also note that you don't spellvamp off anything like this.)

GP's Q doesn't trigger Luden's or Rylai's because it is treated exactly as if it were an auto attack (it crits, you can lifesteal off it, it procs on-hit abilities). Ezrael's and Nasus' Q abilities work the same way.

Sexy Choir Boys4 votes

In this case we are not talking about GP's Q, we are talking about his passive not procing Ludens, which is completely different. GP's passive is magic damage and is triggered off of auto-attacks, just like Fizz W and Teemo E. If it truly does not proc because the ability is a passive then that is absurd since every ability should be registered as on even if it is a passive. And in that case Brand passive procs Ludens and that's a passive, it is technically an On-Hit ability that is triggered off of landing spells. While GP's is triggered off of autos and his Q which is basically and Auto-attack. And if GP's Q does not Proc Ludens, which it shouldn't, his passive which is triggered off of his Q should.

Matthias91191 votes

GP's passive is magic damage and is triggered off of auto-attacks, just like Fizz W and Teemo E.

Teemo's E and the passive portion of Fizz's W work exactly like GP's passive. You cannot spellvamp or trigger "on spell damage" effects solely from passive on-hit effects.

If it truly does not proc because the ability is a passive then that is absurd since every ability should be registered as on even if it is a passive.

It's a balance decision. They will not let you proc Rylai's or Luden's or Liandry's "for free" just by AAing. You must cast an active ability.

And in that case Brand passive procs Ludens and that's a passive, it is technically an On-Hit ability that is triggered off of landing spells.

Brand's passive is a burn effect that is applied as part of him dealing damage with an active ability. By "on-hit" I mean "applied passively on every auto attack"; that is how Riot uses the term in their game.

Sexy Choir Boys2 votes

Brand's passive is a burn affect that is "applied passively on every ability" so really it's no different. And since it is magic damage it should apply ludens.

Matthias91191 votes

As it explains on the wiki:

Blaze is a spell effect that is applied by his abilities.

A "spell effect" (http://leagueoflegends.wikia.com/wiki/Spell_effect) is:

Spell effects are effects that trigger on a champion's damaging abilities. They apply to all damaging abilities, with the exception of on-hit effects or abilities that specify that they apply on-hit effects.

Brand's passive works exactly like Luden's/Rylai's/Liandry's and will apply in the same situations as those. ie, when you activate an ability and that ability deals damage to an enemy. (Except for a handful of abilities, like GP's Q, that are classified as auto attacks.) Brand's passive itself can also trigger spell effects (e.g. it will refresh Rylai's and Liandry's, and can trigger Luden's), but that is not a general thing that applies to all effects that deal magic damage.

Zazusha1 votes

GP's passive is an On-Hit-Effect. meaning it is only applied Via auto attacks and anything "on spell hit" will not apply to it. Such taht GP's Q, Ezreal's Q, and others DO NOT proc Ludens.

More from Report a Bug