Skip to content

AP Gangplank, Ludens Echo active

PS2 SW Berry··0 votes·1,760 views

I play AP Gangplank quite often now but am finding myself in awe as to why Ludens Echo's active does not proct on GP's Q ability. When in game and you get the item, it'll work on your ult but not the Q. It kind of sucks because I'm sure this would really help in a team fight situation when using the active on Ludens.

13 Comments

Serevas3 votes

The reason this doesn't apply the Luden's Echo damage is because Gangplank's Q is considered by the game to be a melee auto attack, so it applies on hit effects just like an auto attack would, but no spell effects, such as the Luden's Echo damage.

Stray Kat3 votes

Works the same as Ezreal's Q with Luden's basically. It procs On-hit effects, but not On-spell effects.

PS2 SW Berry

Yup. I just realized this yesterday with AP Ez. But at least Ez has other abilities than just his ult to proct the passive. But I feel like it should be changed. It is still an ability after all.

BeatzBoyFTW1 votes

So you're saying abilities like Chogath's Q should also procs lifesteal?

ÇaitUltedJFK1 votes

This is sorta why they removed it in a few modes.

Zarxis1 votes

Does it work after you acquire Lich Bane (Does Lich Bane's proc cause Luden's Echo to work with Ezreal and Gangplank Qs)?

PS2 SW Berry1 votes

Lichbane does work on both Ez and GP but not Ludens echo.

Zarxis1 votes

[{quoted}](name=SpcInc Zodiac,realm=NA,application-id=LqLKtMpN,discussion-id=dWBzAIt0,comment-id=00030000,timestamp=2015-03-28T14:31:21.163+0000)

Lichbane does work on both Ez and GP but not Ludens echo.

You misunderstand me. I was asking as to whether Lich Bane's proc itself (not the on-hit spell) triggers Luden's or not. Judging by the sheer number of these threads, I guess not.

4Clang Cliffert1 votes

Parrrley does Proc itself with lichbane

Matthias91191 votes

This is intentional. If it procced spell effects then you could potentially have one Q:

  • deal normal damage
  • crit
  • trigger Spellblade
  • trigger Statikk Shiv (potentially critting as well)
  • trigger Rylai's
  • trigger Liandry's
  • trigger Luden's

While hilarious, this would probably be unfair.

Stray Kat1 votes

{quoted}

This is intentional. If it procced spell effects then you could potentially have one Q:

  • deal normal damage
  • crit
  • trigger Spellblade
  • trigger Statikk Shiv (potentially critting as well)
  • trigger Rylai's
  • trigger Liandry's
  • trigger Luden's

While hilarious, this would probably be unfair.

But I CAN trigger all of these with one E on Kayle. Which is kind've obnoxious lol.

Matthias91192 votes

It's a different sort of ability, because it gives her an on-hit splash. The damage from the AOE splash is considered "spell damage" and can proc Rylai's/Liandry's/Luden's.

Nasus' Q, Ez's Q, and GP's Q are all considered to actually be basic attacks, not just "bonus damage that is applied when you attack". This means that, for example, you can lifesteal off the ability's bonus damage. Kayle cannot; her bonus damage would count towards spell vamp instead.

GaleWinUnleashed1 votes

Spells like Gangplank Q that apply on-hit effects are essentially treated as if they are auto-attacks with a bit of bonus damage. It seems to be consistent across all similar spells, such as Ezreal's Q and Yasuo Q.

More from Report a Bug